# Why do men have nipples? (How evolution works)
![[images/Why-Do-Men-Have-Nipples-How-Evolution-Works.webp]]
**Creator:** Joel is Curious · **Published:** 2026-11-16 · **Length:** 1:52 (YouTube Short) · [Watch on YouTube](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw)
> Caption source: **YouTube auto-generated English captions (en-orig)**, fetched with yt-dlp (android_vr client) on the first try. No TubeAlfred credits were used. About 380 words; timestamps are from the captions, which needed no corrections beyond punctuation (the burned-in caption writes "build 'em"). The short is a vertical talking-head take outdoors in front of yellow autumn trees and a fence (grey hoodie with the hood up, printed with a cactus and a yellow light bulb; glasses, grey beard), with burned-in captions and overlay cards: "Milk lines / about a month into pregnancy" (a body outline with two lines from the armpits to the thighs); "Most of each line fades. One spot stays."; "Sometimes an extra one stays, on the same line"; "Up to 5% of people in some places have an extra nipple"; "one blueprint" with a car and a pickup; "In human embryos: one bump (genital tubercle) → penis with male hormones / clitoris without"; "Mouse, before birth: female building / male building"; "Grown mice (rats: 12 and 0): female 10 / male 0"; "Male rats: normal 0 / hormones blocked up to 12"; and "Boys' nipples: Mice, rats: build → erased / Humans: build → kept (no step removes them)." The thumbnail is a "How evolution works / Why do men have nipples?" title card. Screenshots are one about every 20 s.
## Summary
"Why do men have nipples? Men don't feed babies, so why would a man's body build them?" The answer, Joel says, "starts about a month in your mother's pregnancy." Back then two faint lines ran down the front of your body "from around your armpits down toward your thighs." They're called milk lines, "and other mammals get them, too." Most of each line fades away, but one spot on each side stays and becomes a nipple. Sometimes an extra spot stays as well: "that's a third nipple, and it usually sits somewhere along that line." In some places up to 5% of people have an extra one. "One of my sons has three."
Up to this point "boys and girls are made from the same blueprint. It's kind of like a car maker who draws one blueprint for two different models." Nipples aren't the only example: "In human embryos, the same small little bump becomes a penis or a clitoris depending on male hormones." In people, boys' and girls' nipples are "basically the same until puberty. Then different hormones determine how much that tissue grows." And "a grown man can grow breast tissue when his hormones are out of balance."
"In some mammals, the male body gets rid of them completely, like mice." A male mouse starts building nipples the same as his sisters; then, before he's born, "male hormones just make them shrink away." Grown male mice and rats don't have nipples, while their sisters have 10 or 12. "If you block those hormones in the womb, then male rats keep their nipples. At high doses, they keep all 12 like their sisters." So "the males carry the whole blueprint, but mice and rats just have an extra step that erases it."
"Humans don't have that step. In a boy, nothing removes the nipples before birth." Why didn't we evolve that step? "Apparently, losing them wouldn't help a man, so nothing pushed our ancestors' genes to drop them. So it's not that men needed nipples. Women need them, and they're both built from the same blueprint. We just never had an evolutionary need to get rid of them." And the other side of the puzzle is open: "As far as I can find, nobody knows why mice and rats did. Nipples are cool."
## Outline
### 0:00 Why would a man's body build them?
- [0:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=0s) "Why do men have nipples? Men don't feed babies, so why would a man's body build them?"
- [0:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=4s) "The answer starts about a month in your mother's pregnancy."
![[images/Why-Do-Men-Have-Nipples-How-Evolution-Works-t0003.webp]]
### 0:05 Milk lines
- [0:05](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=5s) "Back then, two faint lines ran on the front of your body from around your armpits down toward your thighs, and they're called milk lines, and other mammals get them, too."
- [0:15](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=15s) "Most of each line fades away, but one spot on each side stays, and it becomes a nipple."
### 0:20 A third nipple
- [0:20](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=20s) "Sometimes an extra spot stays as well, and that's a third nipple, and it usually sits somewhere along that line."
- [0:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=25s) "In some places, up to 5% of the population have an extra one. One of my sons has three."
![[images/Why-Do-Men-Have-Nipples-How-Evolution-Works-t0023.webp]]
### 0:29 One blueprint, two models
- [0:29](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=29s) "Okay, up to this point, boys and girls are made from the same blueprint. It's kind of like a car maker who draws one blueprint for two different models."
- [0:37](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=37s) "Nipples aren't the only example. In human embryos, the same small little bump becomes a penis or a clitoris depending on male hormones."
![[images/Why-Do-Men-Have-Nipples-How-Evolution-Works-t0043.webp]]
### 0:46 The same until puberty
- [0:46](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=46s) "In people, boys and girls' nipples are basically the same until puberty. Then different hormones determine how much that tissue grows."
- [0:51](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=51s) "And a grown man can grow breast tissue when his hormones are out of balance."
### 0:55 Mice erase them before birth
- [0:55](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=55s) "In some mammals, the male body gets rid of them completely, like mice."
- [1:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=60s) "A male mouse starts building nipples the same as his sisters. Then before he's born, male hormones just make them shrink away."
- [1:06](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=66s) "Grown male mice and rats don't have nipples, while their sisters have 10 or 12."
![[images/Why-Do-Men-Have-Nipples-How-Evolution-Works-t0063.webp]]
### 1:10 Block the hormones
- [1:10](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=70s) "If you block those hormones in the womb, then male rats keep their nipples. At high doses, they keep all 12 like their sisters."
- [1:17](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=77s) "So the males carry the whole blueprint, but mice and rats just have an extra step that erases it."
![[images/Why-Do-Men-Have-Nipples-How-Evolution-Works-t0083.webp]]
### 1:23 Humans don't have that step
- [1:23](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=83s) "Humans don't have that step. In a boy, nothing removes the nipples before birth."
- [1:28](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=88s) "So why didn't we evolve that step? Apparently, losing them wouldn't help a man, so nothing pushed our ancestors' genes to drop them."
### 1:37 Women need them
- [1:37](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=97s) "So it's not that men needed nipples. Women need them, and they're both built from the same blueprint."
- [1:43](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=103s) "We just never had an evolutionary need to get rid of them."
- [1:46](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q5xGRqtcKdw&t=106s) "As far as I can find, nobody knows why mice and rats did. Nipples are cool."
![[images/Why-Do-Men-Have-Nipples-How-Evolution-Works-t0103.webp]]
## Anti-evolution argument
*Stated fairly, from Answers in Genesis and Creation Ministries International. The short itself doesn't quote an opponent; it is part of the "How evolution works" series. These are the standard creationist answers to the same question.*
- **"Vestigial" is a poor argument for evolution:** Tommy Mitchell (Answers in Genesis) writes that the "frequently promoted evolutionary view" treats male nipples as leftovers that lost an ancestral function, and that "this is a very poor evidence for evolution" [R8]. Jerry Bergman (*Journal of Creation*) likewise argues "the claim that the human male nipple is vestigial, or rudimentary, is shown to be erroneous," and that evolutionists too readily assumed "unknown function likely meant no function" [R9].
- **A vestige of embryology, and "design economy":** "Male nipples are not a vestige of evolution but are instead a vestige of embryology... Nipples in males are actually an evidence of 'design economy'" [R8]. Bergman: "Men have nipples because they have already started to develop at the time when the male hormonal signal to differentiate is activated," and "male nipple development is therefore a result of sexual differentiation designed to produce sexual dimorphism" [R9].
- **They aren't useless:** male nipples "are very sensitive and are a source of sexual stimulation... they are fully vascularized and have more than adequate nerve supply"; and "if nipples and breasts are 'useless' to males, they are equally useless to prepubescent girls" [R8]. Bergman: "The male nipple is equally as sensitive as the female nipple" [R9].
- **Evolution has no answer:** "It is, in fact, the evolutionists who have a problem with this issue, as they can provide no reason for the existence and persistence of male nipples in an evolutionary scenario" [R8].
## Answer
*Point by point. Numbers refer to the References table.*
### 1. Milk lines, one nipple each side, and the third nipple
- Schwartz et al. (2021): humans, "just like other mammals," have milk lines "running along the front torso from the arm pits (axilla) to the upper medial side of the thighs. They first appear between gestational week 4 and 5, but will regress"; "Humans typically have two nipples, regardless of sex"; incomplete regression gives supernumerary nipples, the "third nipple" being "most frequently located along the mammary ridges" [R1]. That matches the narration and the milk-line card.
- On prevalence the same review says supernumerary nipples "occur in 0.2–6% of the population, with prevalence varying greatly amongst geographic regions and ethnicities" [R1]. The video's "up to 5%" (card: "Up to 5% of people in some places") is a little under the review's upper bound; the description itself gives 0.2 to 6%. Wikipedia summarizes studies at about 1 in 18 to 1 in 40 [R11].
### 2. One blueprint: the genital tubercle
- Baskin et al. (2018): "The human penis and clitoris develop from the ambisexual genital tubercle"; it "differentiates into a penis under the influence of androgens," while in females, "without the influence of androgens," the homologous tissues stay unfused [R2]. The card ("one bump (genital tubercle) → penis with male hormones / clitoris without") is accurate.
### 3. The same until puberty; gynecomastia
- Macias & Hinck (2012): "In humans, sexual dimorphism is accomplished via a different mechanism and the bud is not severed during embryogenesis. Instead, male and female glands undergo comparable development until puberty when their regulation by different hormones specifies their size. Thus, human male breasts retain a normal growth potential as evidenced by the incidence of gynecomastia, the benign enlargement of breast tissue in males as a consequence of altered estrogen-androgen balance" [R3]. This is close to the narration line for line.
### 4. Mice and rats erase them
- Lab rats (Wistar, Sprague Dawley) "normally have 12 nipples (six pairs), the males normally have none"; "in common laboratory mice strains the ratio is 10 nipples (five pairs) in females to zero in males"; "androgen signaling during development prompts the nipple anlagen to regress in males" [R1]. In male mice "the mesenchyme surrounding the stalk continues to condense until it severs the bud" [R3].
- Kratochwil & Schwartz (1976) showed by tissue recombination that in the mouse mammary rudiment "only the mesenchyme... is the target tissue for testosterone," and the epithelial changes, "including its necrosis," follow from it [R4]. That is the "male hormones just make them shrink away" step.
- Blocking it: in rat studies with the anti-androgen flutamide given during the masculinisation window, male offspring retained 12 nipples at 16–50 mg/kg bw/day and "at around 2 weeks of age, these male offspring were practically indistinguishable from their female littermates as regards the presence of nipples" [R1]. The same review notes one study in that dose range found only six retained nipples, and that nipple retention is used as a toxicology biomarker for anti-androgenic chemicals [R1]. "At high doses, they keep all 12" is accurate.
### 5. Why men kept them: an inference, stated as one
- Zheng, Wang & Cooke (2025, preprint, not peer reviewed): "since the nipple has no function for most males, then why do most male mammals (including humans) have nipples, but mice, rats and horses do not?" and "the presence of nipples in male mammals is the evolutionary norm, while the loss of nipples during embryonic development in a few male species is the exception" [R5]. Their answer is about mechanism: androgen receptor is present in the developing mouse mammary gland but absent in the guinea pig's [R5].
- Biologist Andrew Simons put the same "why" in Scientific American: male nipples are "probably best explained as a genetic correlation that persists through lack of selection against them, rather than selection for them... So, why do men have nipples? Because females do" [R10]. The video's "losing them wouldn't help a man, so nothing pushed our ancestors' genes to drop them" is that explanation; the creator flags it as "apparently," and the description calls it "an inference, not a measurement."
### 6. "Nobody knows why mice and rats did"
- The sources describe how, not why: Zheng et al. propose that androgen receptor "may have been ectopically expressed in the fetal MG of a few mammals, such as mice and rats," without a tested reason it was favored [R5]. No tested adaptive explanation turned up here either. Daly (1979), which the description also cites, is about why male mammals don't lactate; only its record was checked [R7].
### 7. The creationist replies largely agree on the facts
- AiG's own explanation, "a vestige of embryology" because "very early in their maturation, male and female human embryos are essentially the same" [R8], is the developmental account the video gives. The short never calls male nipples vestigial or says they once nursed babies, so the "vestigial is a poor argument" reply [R8, R9] answers a claim the short doesn't make; Darwin did call male mammae "absolutely useless" (see 8).
- "Not useless" (sensation, nerve supply) [R8, R9] doesn't conflict with the video's point: a structure can be sensitive without having been selected in males. "Design economy" [R8] is a reading of the same shared blueprint; it doesn't by itself say why male mice, rats and horses lack nipples when most male mammals have them [R5].
- "Evolutionists... can provide no reason for the existence and persistence of male nipples" [R8] is answered by the shared-development plus no-selection-against explanation in R5 and R10, which the AiG article does not engage.
### 8. Darwin, in context
- Chapter 1 of the 1874 *Descent of Man* (p. 11) says rudimentary organs "are either absolutely useless, such as the mammæ of male quadrupeds, or the incisor teeth of ruminants which never cut through the gums" [R6]. The quote in the description is accurate.
- Darwin later qualified it (ch. 6, pp. 162–163): "The mammary glands and nipples, as they exist in male mammals, can indeed hardly be called rudimentary; they are merely not fully developed, and not functionally active," and he speculated that "during a former prolonged period male mammals aided the females in nursing their offspring" [R6]. That nursing hypothesis is the "vestigial" story the creationist articles target; the video's explanation doesn't depend on it.
## Key takeaways
- Every human embryo forms milk lines at about weeks 4–5; one spot on each side becomes a nipple in both sexes, and leftovers along the line are extra nipples (0.2–6% of people).
- Male and female bodies share one developmental plan until hormones diverge; the genital tubercle and the breast bud are examples, and human male breast tissue keeps its growth potential (gynecomastia).
- Male mice and rats have an extra androgen-driven step that destroys the nipple buds before birth; block androgens and male rats keep up to all 12.
- Humans lack that step. Why men kept nipples is an inference (no selection to remove them), not a measurement; why mice and rats lost them has no tested answer.
- Creationist sources agree on the shared embryology and call it "design economy"; they mainly rebut a "vestigial" claim the short doesn't make.
## Things mentioned
### Anatomy and development
- Milk lines (mammary ridges); nipples; supernumerary ("third") nipples; genital tubercle; penis and clitoris; male breast tissue and gynecomastia; puberty and hormones
### Animals
- Mice and rats (female 10 and 12 nipples; male 0); "other mammals" with milk lines
### Ideas
- One blueprint for two models (the car-maker analogy); development vs. purpose; an "extra step" that erases a trait; absence of selection; open questions ("nobody knows why mice and rats did")
### People
- The creator's son (three nipples)
### Works (from the description)
- Schwartz et al., *Frontiers in Toxicology* 2021; Baskin et al., *Differentiation* 2018; Macias & Hinck, *WIREs Developmental Biology* 2012; Kratochwil & Schwartz, *PNAS* 1976; Zheng et al. 2025 (preprint); Darwin, *The Descent of Man*, 2nd ed., 1874, ch. 1; Daly, *Journal of Theoretical Biology* 1979
### Links from the description
- https://joeliscurious.com · https://www.instagram.com/joeliscurious/ · https://www.tiktok.com/@joeliscurious · https://x.com/JoelisCurious · https://www.youtube.com/@joeliscurious
## Claims check
| Claim in the video | Verdict | Source or note |
|---|---|---|
| Milk lines form about a month into pregnancy, from the armpits toward the thighs | **Accurate** | Gestational weeks 4–5, axilla to upper medial thighs [R1] |
| Other mammals get milk lines too | **Accurate** | "Just like other mammals" [R1]; mouse mammary line [R3] |
| Most of each line fades; one spot on each side becomes a nipple | **Accurate** | Two nipples "regardless of sex" [R1] |
| An extra spot gives a third nipple, usually along the line | **Accurate** | "Most frequently located along the mammary ridges" [R1] |
| Up to 5% of people in some places have an extra one | **Accurate but conservative** | Review gives 0.2–6% by region [R1]; Wikipedia 1 in 18 to 1 in 40 [R11] |
| One of his sons has three | **Not checkable** | Personal |
| The same bump becomes a penis or clitoris depending on male hormones | **Accurate** | Ambisexual genital tubercle; androgens [R2] |
| Boys' and girls' nipples are basically the same until puberty | **Accurate** | "Comparable development until puberty" [R3] |
| A grown man can grow breast tissue when hormones are out of balance | **Accurate** | Gynecomastia, "altered estrogen-androgen balance" [R3] |
| Male mice start building nipples, then male hormones make them shrink before birth | **Accurate** | Androgen-driven regression; testosterone acts via mesenchyme [R1, R3, R4] |
| Grown male mice and rats have none; females have 10 or 12 | **Accurate** | Mice 10:0, rats 12:0 (lab strains) [R1] |
| Block the hormones in the womb and male rats keep their nipples; all 12 at high doses | **Accurate** | Flutamide 16–50 mg/kg bw/day; one study saw only six [R1] |
| Humans have no step that removes the nipples before birth | **Accurate** | "The bud is not severed during embryogenesis" [R3] |
| Losing them wouldn't help a man, so nothing pushed our ancestors to drop them | **Fair (inference)** | Mainstream explanation [R5, R10]; flagged by the creator as "apparently" |
| Nobody knows why mice and rats lost theirs | **Supported (as far as checked)** | Mechanism proposed, no tested "why" [R5] |
## References
| # | Source | Exists? | Use in the video / role | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| R1 | Schwartz, Christiansen, Hass, Ramhøj, Axelstad, Löbl & Svingen, "On the Use and Interpretation of Areola/Nipple Retention as a Biomarker for Anti-androgenic Effects in Rat Toxicity Studies," *Frontiers in Toxicology* 3:730752 (2021) | **Exists; accurate** (full text read) | Description source: milk lines weeks 4–5, armpits to thighs, two nipples regardless of sex, 0.2–6% extra nipples, rats 12:0 and mice 10:0, 12 retained "practically indistinguishable from their female littermates" | [doi:10.3389/ftox.2021.730752](https://doi.org/10.3389/ftox.2021.730752) |
| R2 | Baskin, Shen, Sinclair, Cao, Liu, Liu, Isaacson, Overland, Li & Cunha, "Development of the human penis and clitoris," *Differentiation* 103:74–85 (2018) | **Exists; accurate** (abstract read) | Description source: one genital tubercle, androgen-dependent | [doi:10.1016/j.diff.2018.08.001](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.diff.2018.08.001) |
| R3 | Macias & Hinck, "Mammary gland development," *WIREs Developmental Biology* 1(4):533–557 (2012) | **Exists; accurate** (full text read, PMC3404495) | Description source: human male bud "not severed," comparable until puberty, gynecomastia; also the male-mouse bud severing | [doi:10.1002/wdev.35](https://doi.org/10.1002/wdev.35) |
| R4 | Kratochwil & Schwartz, "Tissue interaction in androgen response of embryonic mammary rudiment of mouse: identification of target tissue for testosterone," *PNAS* 73(11):4041–4044 (1976) | **Exists; accurate** (abstract read) | Description source: male hormones make the mouse buds regress before birth (mouse only; the rat dosing figures are from R1) | [doi:10.1073/pnas.73.11.4041](https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.73.11.4041) |
| R5 | Zheng, Wang & Cooke, "Developmental basis of male nipple loss and retention in mammals," Research Square preprint, posted 2025-10-24 | **Exists; accurate** (full text read); **not peer reviewed** | Description source: "has no function for most males," "the evolutionary norm," "the exception"; also males of rat, mouse and horse lack nipples | [doi:10.21203/rs.3.rs-7697632/v1](https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-7697632/v1) |
| R6 | Darwin, *The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex*, 2nd ed. (John Murray, 1874), ch. 1 p. 11; ch. 6 pp. 162–163 | **Exists; accurate** (Darwin Online text read) | Description source: "absolutely useless" (said of "the mammæ of male quadrupeds"); added: Darwin's later qualification and male-nursing speculation | [darwin-online.org.uk](https://darwin-online.org.uk/content/frameset?pageseq=1&itemID=F944&viewtype=text) |
| R7 | Daly, "Why don't male mammals lactate?," *Journal of Theoretical Biology* 78(3):325–345 (1979) | **Exists** (PubMed record read; no abstract; content not checked) | Description source: "no tested explanation" for mouse and rat nipple loss; its subject is male lactation, adjacent to that claim | [doi:10.1016/0022-5193(79)90334-5](https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-5193(79)90334-5) |
| R8 | Tommy Mitchell, "Why Do Men Have Nipples?," Answers in Genesis, 2011-07-01 | **Exists** (read) | Added: creationist argument; quotes checked | [answersingenesis.org](https://answersingenesis.org/human-body/vestigial-organs/why-do-men-have-nipples/) |
| R9 | Jerry Bergman, "Is the human male nipple vestigial?," *Journal of Creation* 15(2):38–41 (2001), online at creation.com 2007-07-24 | **Exists** (read) | Added: creationist argument; quotes checked | [creation.com](https://creation.com/en/articles/is-the-human-male-nipple-vestigial) |
| R10 | Andrew M. Simons, "Why do men have nipples?," *Scientific American*, 2003-09-17 | **Exists** (read) | Added: "genetic correlation that persists through lack of selection against them" | [scientificamerican.com](https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-do-men-have-nipples/) |
| R11 | "Polythelia," Wikipedia | **Exists** (read) | Added: prevalence about 1 in 18 to 1 in 40 | [Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polythelia) |
| R12 | "Dr. Tommy Mitchell," Answers in Genesis bio | **Exists** (read) | Added: biography | [answersingenesis.org](https://answersingenesis.org/bios/tommy-mitchell/) |
### Not found or not checked
- R2 and R4 were checked from their abstracts, not the full papers.
- R7 (Daly 1979): only the bibliographic record; whether it discusses nipple loss in rodents wasn't checked.
- The "about 4 to 5 weeks" timing is in gestational weeks as R1 states it; whether that counts from conception or the last period wasn't checked.
- The creator's son's three nipples: personal, not checkable.
## Added context
- **Series:** Part of "How evolution works," after [[One drought. Bigger beaks. (How evolution works, Part 1)]] and [[Which came first, the chicken or the egg (How evolution works, Part 2)]]; this one carries no part number. Previous upload: [[Did Leakey make Homo erectus more ape-like (Response to Genesis Apologetics, Part 1)]] (2026-11-14). Related: the embryonic tail in [[Just a theory (Is evolution true Part 4)]] and whale hip bones as vestigial-but-used in [[Not a single piece of evidence for evolution (Is evolution true Part 6)]].
- **Not only rodents:** Zheng et al. list the horse alongside the rat and mouse as species whose males lack nipples [R5].
- **The rat result is a toxicology tool:** retained nipples in male rat pups are a standard regulatory marker (OECD test guidelines) for chemicals that block androgens, which is why the dose-response data in R1 exist [R1].
- **"Vestigial" or "byproduct":** mainstream accounts generally call male nipples a developmental byproduct of the shared plan rather than a remnant of a lost male function [R10], which is also how the short frames it; Darwin's 1874 male-nursing speculation is the older "vestige" story [R6].
- **On the description:** it again mentions "first word on the evolution book," so the creator appears to be writing a book on evolution (no title given).
## Biographies
### Joel is Curious (the creator)
YouTube channel **Joel is Curious**, mostly Shorts, from 2026-10-04. In his own words (video description): "I'm Joel, a software developer and former tech executive who likes to learn stuff. Science, history, Buddhism, Stoicism, and the thinkers behind them." He lists his sources in each description. (Sources: the video and its description.)
### Charles Darwin (cited in the description)
Naturalist (1809–1882); *On the Origin of Species* (1859) and *The Descent of Man* (1871; 2nd ed. 1874). Chapter 1 of the 1874 edition calls male mammae "absolutely useless"; chapter 6 qualifies that [R6].
### Tommy Mitchell (added context)
Physician (1956–2019); MD from Vanderbilt University School of Medicine (1984), board certified in internal medicine; speaker and author for Answers in Genesis from 2005 [R12]. Author of R8.
### Jerry Bergman (added context)
Creationist author; wrote R9 in *Journal of Creation*, Creation Ministries International's journal [R9].