# Do I believe in Adam and Eve? (Science) ![[images/Do-I-Believe-In-Adam-And-Eve-Science.webp]] **Creator:** Joel is Curious · **Published:** 2026-11-19 · **Length:** 2:44 (YouTube Short) · [Watch on YouTube](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M) > Caption source: **YouTube auto-generated English captions (en-orig)**, fetched with yt-dlp (android_vr client) on the first try. No TubeAlfred credits were used. About 550 words; timestamps are from the captions. The captions write "28 grades" (0:28) and "weasle" (1:34); the creator says *28 greats* and *weasel*, as the burned-in captions show, and they're corrected here. The short ends mid-sentence ("That's why when people ask") and loops back to its opening line ("Do I believe in Adam and Eve? I do, in a way"). It is a vertical talking-head take indoors at a wooden desk in what looks like a hotel room (bed and a green book behind him; maroon hoodie, dark-rimmed glasses, grey hair and beard), with burned-in captions and overlay cards: "the one-pair idea: everyone alive comes from two people"; "×2 every generation, about every 30 years" (a growing tree above "you"); a "generations back / spots on your tree" table (10, around 1700: 1,024, "grandparents with 8 greats"; 20, around 1400: 1,048,576; 30, around 1100: 1,073,741,824, "spots, 28 greats back"); "The year 1100" (a huge red square of spots beside a small green one for the people alive, "same scale: the same people fill many spots"); "one person, two spots on your tree"; "one person's descendants, doubling" (10 generations ~1,000; 20 ~1 million; 30 ~1 billion); two buckets ("no one alive today comes from them" / "ancestor of everyone alive today"); "a computer model of the whole earth" ("after Rohde, Olson & Chang, Nature 2004, Fig. 2"); a timeline "Everyone alive back then, in the cautious model (Rohde, Olson & Chang 2004)": 7,000+ years ago, the Great Pyramid about 4,600 years ago, AD 1 about 2,000 years ago; and a closing chart "All Adam, all Eve: not one pair at the top, but a whole population" contrasting "the one-pair account (Ussher, Bible counts; ramps between: inferred)" (Adam and Eve 4004 BC; the Flood, 8 people, 2348 BC, Gen 7:13; Israel about 600,000 men, 1491 BC, Ex 12:37; ~200 million in AD 1, "usual estimate") with "the cautious model" (5–27 million in 5000 BC, 7,000+ years ago), "both end at 8.3 billion people today... 300 to 1,600 times as many as in 5000 BC... widths not to scale." The thumbnail is a "Science / Do I believe in Adam and Eve?" title card. Screenshots are one about every 20 s, plus the two model cards (1:59 and 2:35). ## Summary "Do I believe in Adam and Eve? I do, in a way, but I don't think they're just one pair." You have two parents, each of them had two parents, "so the spots on your family tree double every generation, about every 30 years or so." Ten generations back, around 1700, "you have about a thousand grandparents with eight greats"; 20 generations back, a million; 30 back, around AD 1100, "a billion grandparents with 28 greats. I realize it's very hard to believe, but it's just math." "But only about 300 million people were alive in 1100. So how do you have a billion grandparents in that generation? You don't. The same people fill more than one spot." If your mother's great-great-great-great-grandfather was the same man as your father's great-great-great-grandfather, "one person takes up two spots on your tree," and the further back you go, the more that happens. "We're all marrying and dating distant cousins." Now flip it and go forward. One person alive thousands of years ago, two kids, each with two kids: a thousand descendants in 10 generations, a million in 20, a billion in 30. But there weren't a billion people on Earth then either, so their descendants start having kids with each other. "As long as your descendants keep having descendants and as long as humans keep mixing, your descendants are going to weasel their way into every family tree eventually," unless the line dies out. So, given enough generations, "there's a point in time you can go back to where either all of your descendants have died out or you're an ancestor of everyone alive. Every person alive that long ago is in one of those two buckets." How long ago? "Three researchers built a model of the entire earth": continents, countries, towns and water, "with people occasionally moving between them, so no group was ever entirely cut off." In the cautious version it was "about 7,000 years ago, before the pyramids"; with "a little more movement between the different societies," 4,000 years. That's your family tree, "not talking about your DNA. From most of those ancestors you get very little or no DNA... DNA comes down in chunks, and most of them never get a chunk to you, but they're still on your tree." So "more than about 7,000 years ago, the probability is that they were all Adam and Eve, every one of them, as long as they have any living descendants at all." The description gives the details: the 2004 *Nature* paper's cautious and high-migration dates (5,353 BC and 2,158 BC for the all-or-none point; 1,415 BC and AD 55 for the most recent person on everyone's tree), the 1999 math behind it, population estimates for AD 1100, the isolation caveat (a fully cut-off group, such as Tasmania, pushes the date back), a correction to Wikipedia's account of the model, and a note that mitochondrial Eve and Y-chromosome Adam are "something else": single lines, mothers only or fathers only, both more than 100,000 years ago. ## Outline ### 0:00 Not just one pair - [0:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=0s) "Do I believe in Adam and Eve? I do in a way, but I don't think they're just one pair." - [0:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=4s) "You have two parents. Each of them had two parents. So, the spots on your family tree double every generation about every 30 years or so." ![[images/Do-I-Believe-In-Adam-And-Eve-Science-t0003.webp]] ### 0:13 A billion spots by 1100 - [0:13](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=13s) "So, 10 generations back, which is around 1700, you have about a thousand grandparents with eight greats." - [0:22](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=22s) "20 generations back, it's a million. 30 back, around 1100 AD, it's a billion grandparents with 28 greats." - [0:31](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=31s) "I realize it's very hard to believe, but it's just math. You're doubling every generation." ![[images/Do-I-Believe-In-Adam-And-Eve-Science-t0023.webp]] ### 0:35 The same people fill many spots - [0:35](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=35s) "But only about 300 million people were alive in 1100. So, how do you have a billion grandparents in that generation? You don't. The same people fill more than one spot." - [0:46](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=46s) "Say your mother's great great great great grandfather was the same person as your father's great great great-grandfather. One person takes up two spots on your tree." - [0:54](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=54s) "And the further back you go, the more that happens... We're all marrying and dating distant cousins." ![[images/Do-I-Believe-In-Adam-And-Eve-Science-t0043.webp]] ### 1:03 Flip it and go forward - [1:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=63s) "Now, flip it and go forward. Let's take one person who was alive thousands of years ago." - [1:11](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=71s) "In 10 generations, that's about a thousand descendants. In 20, it's a million. In 30, it's a billion. But there weren't a billion people on Earth during that generation." - [1:22](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=82s) "Their descendants start having kids with each other. So there are fewer descendants than just the math of doubling every generation." ![[images/Do-I-Believe-In-Adam-And-Eve-Science-t0063.webp]] ### 1:28 Into every family tree, or none - [1:28](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=88s) "As long as your descendants keep having descendants and as long as humans keep mixing, your descendants are going to weasel their way into every family tree eventually. But again, that assumes that your line doesn't die out." - [1:43](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=103s) "There's a point in time that you can go back to where either all of your descendants have died out or you're an ancestor of everyone alive. Every person alive that long ago is in one of those two buckets." ![[images/Do-I-Believe-In-Adam-And-Eve-Science-t0083.webp]] ### 1:54 A model of the whole Earth - [1:54](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=114s) "The question is how long ago was that? Three researchers built a model of the entire earth." - [1:59](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=119s) "It had continents, countries, towns, water bodies with people occasionally moving between them. So no group was ever entirely cut off." ![[images/Do-I-Believe-In-Adam-And-Eve-Science-t0103.webp]] ![[images/Do-I-Believe-In-Adam-And-Eve-Science-t0119.webp]] ### 2:07 About 7,000 years, or 4,000 - [2:07](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=127s) "In the cautious version, it was about 7,000 years ago before the pyramids. And again, everyone alive then either has no descendants or they are an ancestor of everyone alive today." - [2:17](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=137s) "If you build in a little more movement between the different societies, that number goes from 7,000 years to 4,000 years." ![[images/Do-I-Believe-In-Adam-And-Eve-Science-t0123.webp]] ### 2:23 Family tree, not DNA - [2:23](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=143s) "Now, that's your family tree. It's not talking about your DNA. From most of those ancestors, you get very little or no DNA because they're too far back." - [2:30](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=150s) "DNA comes down in chunks, and most of them never get a chunk to you, but they're still on your tree." ![[images/Do-I-Believe-In-Adam-And-Eve-Science-t0143.webp]] ### 2:34 All Adam, all Eve - [2:34](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=154s) "So, more than about 7,000 years ago, the probability is that they were all Adam and Eve, every one of them, as long as they have any living descendants at all." - [2:42](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cQWFXobRo8M&t=162s) "That's why when people ask..." (loops to the opening: "Do I believe in Adam and Eve? I do, in a way.") ![[images/Do-I-Believe-In-Adam-And-Eve-Science-t0155.webp]] ![[images/Do-I-Believe-In-Adam-And-Eve-Science-t0163.webp]] ## Anti-evolution argument *Stated fairly, from Answers in Genesis and Creation Ministries International. The short doesn't quote an opponent; these are the standard young-earth positions on the question it answers.* - **Adam and Eve were the first two humans, and everyone descends from them:** "According to Scripture, Adam and Eve were the first human beings on the planet"; Eve was named "because she was the mother of all living" (Genesis 3:20); and "it's not possible to deny a real Adam and Eve while at the same time believing the rest of the Bible" [R10]. - **Genetics fits two people a few thousand years ago:** Robert Carter (CMI) writes that "there is abundant evidence that the entire human race came from two people just a few thousand years ago (Adam and Eve), that there was a serious population crash (bottleneck)... (at the time of the Flood), and that there was a single dispersal of people across the world after that (the Tower of Babel)," and that "essentially all of the genetic variation among people today could have been carried within two people, if you discount mutations that occurred after our dispersion" [R11]. - **"Mitochondrial Eve" dates rest on evolutionary assumptions:** for evolutionists "'Eve' was never the mother of all those living during her lifetime, nor was she the first woman"; the roughly 200,000-year date reflects "presuppositions," so researchers "overestimate their 'Eve' by 194,000 years" [R12]. - **A "genealogical" Adam and Eve is not the biblical one:** reviewing S. Joshua Swamidass's book, Carter and John Sanford say a model in which Adam and Eve "can be the genealogical ancestors, but not the genetic ancestors, of all people alive today, after people evolved from apes, fails all biblical tests," and that in Acts 17:26 Paul "specifically says that from this 'one man' God made 'every nation of mankind'... There is only one biblical candidate for this man: Adam" [R13]. ## Answer *Point by point. Numbers refer to the References table.* ### 1. The doubling is just math - 2^10 = 1,024, 2^20 = 1,048,576 and 2^30 = 1,073,741,824, exactly the card's figures; ten generations back are your great×8 grandparents and 30 back are great×28. Geneticist Graham Coop puts it the same way: "your number of ancestors k generations back grows at 2^k (again ignoring the possibility of inbreeding...)" [R6]. At about 30 years a generation, 10, 20 and 30 generations before 2026 land near 1726, 1426 and 1126, matching "around 1700 / 1400 / 1100." ### 2. Far fewer people than spots - Tabulated estimates of world population in AD 1100 include Biraben (1980) 301 million and McEvedy & Jones (1978) 320 million, as the description says; others in the same table run higher (HYDE 353 million, PRB 450 million) [R3]. Every one is far below a billion, so the same people must fill many spots ("pedigree collapse"). The description's "about 300 million" is the low end of the range; the conclusion doesn't depend on it. ### 3. All or none: the math - Joseph Chang (1999) proved that in a randomly mating population of size n, the most recent common ancestor of everyone lived about lg n generations ago, and "at about 1.77 lg n generations before the present... all individuals who have any descendants among the present-day individuals are actually ancestors of all present-day individuals" [R2]. That is the video's "two buckets." ### 4. The world model and its dates - Rohde, Olson & Chang (2004) added "population substructure" because "the random mating model ignores essential aspects" of real mating [R1]. Their simulation has "three levels of substructure: continents, 'countries' and 'towns'," ports with migration rates in "people per generation," and starts "in 20,000 BC" [R1]. - Cautious settings ("5% of individuals migrating out of their home town, 0.05% migrating out of their home country, and 95% of port users born in the country") give "a mean MRCA date of 1,415 BC and a mean IA date of 5,353 BC"; with more migration "the mean MRCA date is as recent as AD 55 and the mean IA date is 2,158 BC" [R1]. All four numbers in the description are exact. - 5,353 BC is about 7,400 years before 2026 and 2,158 BC about 4,200, so "about 7,000" and "4,000" are fair roundings; the description's "about 4,200 to 7,400 years" is exact. The Great Pyramid was built c. 2600 BC, about 4,600 years ago [R9], so "before the pyramids" is right for the cautious date (the higher-migration date, 2,158 BC, is after it). ### 5. "No group was ever entirely cut off": a model assumption, with the authors' own caveats - The paper says that "if a group of humans were completely isolated... the MRCA would have to have lived before the start of the isolation," and that Tasmania "may have been completely isolated from mainland Australia between the flooding of the Bass Strait, 9,000–12,000 years ago, and the European colonization... starting in 1803," so "the IA date for all living humans must fall before the start of isolation" [R1]. The description reports this correctly. It also means the true worldwide all-or-none date is probably older than the model's 7,400 years if that isolation was total. - The Bering Strait: the conservative run uses "ten per generation" each way, and even "one person in each direction every ten generations" only moves the MRCA "from 3,415 years to 3,668 years" [R1]. The description's "about ten people each way per generation" is accurate. - "Actual migration rates among populations are very poorly known" [R1], which the description quotes, hence the range. ### 6. Family tree, not DNA - "Because DNA is inherited in relatively large segments from ancestors, an individual will receive little or no actual genetic inheritance from the vast majority of the ancestors living at the IA point" [R1]; the description quotes this exactly. Coop: material from a given ancestor "is inherited in large chunks"; nine generations back the autosomes from your mother are "broke, on average, into 286 large chunks, and these are spread across your 256 ancestors," so on average each contributes about one block and by chance some contribute none [R6]. That is the video's "most of them never get a chunk to you." ### 7. Mitochondrial Eve and Y-chromosome Adam - Poznik et al. (2013) estimate the most recent common ancestor of the Y chromosome at "120 to 156 thousand years" and of the mitochondrial genome at "99 to 148 thousand years," and conclude that "male lineages do not coalesce significantly more recently than female lineages" [R4]. "Both more than 100,000 years ago" is right except for the very bottom of the mitochondrial range. This also answers the AiG note [R12] in part: these single-line ancestors are not claimed to be the only people alive, which is exactly the video's point about one line vs. a whole population. ### 8. The Wikipedia correction - Wikipedia's "Identical ancestors point" article says Rohde, Olson and Chang "showed through simulations that, given the false assumption of random mate choice without geographic barriers," the point "would be surprisingly recent, on the order of 2,000–5,000 years ago" [R5]. The paper's simulation explicitly models geography and limited migration [R1], so the description's correction ("That was the simple version. The 2004 model added the barriers") is accurate. ### 9. What the short does and doesn't answer - The young-earth position [R10, R11] is that everyone descends *only* from one created pair. The short's argument shows something different: that "Adam and Eve" in a genealogical sense is a whole population, everyone with surviving descendants more than about 7,000 years ago. It doesn't address the genetic question of whether human diversity could come from two people a few thousand years ago [R11]; that is a separate population-genetics argument the short doesn't take up. - The genealogical result is also the basis of Swamidass's *The Genealogical Adam and Eve*, which argues a recently created couple could be "rightly identified as the ancestors of everyone" alongside evolution [R14]; CMI rejects that reading on biblical grounds [R13]. The short takes neither side on theology; its "in a way" is about genealogy, not about a created pair. - The closing card's Ussher dates are accurate to the *Annals*: creation 4004 BC; the Flood entered in AM 1656, late 2349 BC on Ussher's reckoning, with "The Second Age of the World" opening in 2348 BC, the commonly quoted Flood date; and the Exodus in AM 2513, 1491 BC [R7]. The verses cited say the eight went into the ark (Genesis 7:13) and "about six hundred thousand on foot that were men, beside children" (Exodus 12:37) [R8]. ## Key takeaways - Your family tree has 2^n spots n generations back: about a billion by AD 1100, when roughly 300–450 million people were alive, so the same people fill many spots. - Far enough back, everyone with surviving descendants is an ancestor of everyone alive today (Chang 1999's all-or-none point). - In Rohde, Olson & Chang's structured world model that point is 5,353 BC (cautious) or 2,158 BC (more migration); the most recent person on everyone's tree is 1,415 BC or AD 55. - Those dates assume no group was completely cut off; the authors note Tasmania may have been, which would push the true all-or-none date back before 9,000–12,000 years ago. - Genealogical ancestors are not genetic ones: most ancestors that far back pass you no DNA. Mitochondrial Eve and Y-chromosome Adam are single lines, about 100,000–156,000 years ago. - Young-earth creationists hold that all humans descend only from a created first pair a few thousand years ago; the short reframes "Adam and Eve" as a whole ancestral population rather than rebutting that claim with genetic evidence. ## Things mentioned ### Ideas - Family-tree doubling; pedigree collapse ("the same people fill more than one spot"); marrying distant cousins; descendants going forward; the all-or-none ("identical ancestors") point; most recent common ancestor; genealogical vs. genetic ancestry; DNA inherited in chunks; mitochondrial Eve and Y-chromosome Adam ### Places and times - AD 1700, 1400, 1100; "before the pyramids"; the Bering Strait and Tasmania (description); the one-pair timeline on the closing card (Adam and Eve 4004 BC, the Flood 2348 BC, Israel 1491 BC, AD 1) ### People - "Three researchers" (Douglas Rohde, Steve Olson, Joseph Chang); Ussher (closing card) ### Works (from the description) - Rohde, Olson & Chang, *Nature* 431:562 (2004); Chang, *Advances in Applied Probability* 31:1002 (1999); Biraben (1980) and McEvedy & Jones (1978) population estimates; Poznik et al., *Science* 341:562 (2013); Wikipedia ("Identical ancestors point"); Genesis 7:13 and Exodus 12:37 (closing card) ### Links from the description - https://doi.org/10.1038/nature02842 · https://doi.org/10.1239/aap/1029955256 · https://joeliscurious.com · https://www.instagram.com/joeliscurious/ · https://www.tiktok.com/@joeliscurious · https://x.com/JoelisCurious · https://www.youtube.com/@joeliscurious ## Claims check | Claim in the video | Verdict | Source or note | |---|---|---| | Family-tree spots double every generation (about 30 years) | **Accurate** | 2^k ancestors, ignoring inbreeding [R6] | | 10 generations back (around 1700): about a thousand, "eight greats" | **Accurate** | 1,024; great×8 grandparents | | 20 back: a million; 30 back (around 1100): a billion, "28 greats" | **Accurate** | 1,048,576 and 1,073,741,824 | | Only about 300 million people were alive in 1100 | **Accurate (low end)** | Biraben 301M, McEvedy & Jones 320M; other estimates to 450M [R3] | | The same people fill many spots | **Accurate** | Follows from the numbers; pedigree collapse | | Far enough back, everyone is an ancestor of all or of none | **Accurate** | Chang 1999 [R2]; Rohde et al. 2004 [R1] | | Three researchers built a model of the whole Earth with continents, countries, towns | **Accurate** | Rohde, Olson & Chang 2004 [R1] | | In the model, no group was ever entirely cut off | **Accurate as a model assumption** | Authors note real complete isolation (Tasmania) would push the date back [R1] | | Cautious version: about 7,000 years ago, before the pyramids | **Accurate** | IA 5,353 BC (~7,400 years) [R1]; Great Pyramid c. 2600 BC [R9] | | More movement: about 4,000 years | **Accurate** | IA 2,158 BC (~4,200 years) [R1] | | From most of those ancestors you get little or no DNA; DNA comes in chunks | **Accurate** | "Little or no actual genetic inheritance" [R1]; Coop [R6] | | More than ~7,000 years ago, everyone with living descendants is "Adam and Eve" | **Accurate to the model; contested as fact** | Model-dependent; migration rates "very poorly known"; Tasmania caveat [R1] | | (Description) Wikipedia says the result rests on random mating without barriers; the 2004 model added barriers | **Accurate** | Wikipedia's wording [R5] vs. the paper's structured model [R1] | | (Description) Mitochondrial Eve and Y-chromosome Adam both more than 100,000 years ago | **Mostly accurate** | Y 120–156 ky; mt 99–148 ky [R4] | | (Card) Ussher: Adam and Eve 4004 BC, the Flood 2348 BC, Israel 1491 BC | **Accurate** | *Annals*: 4004 BC; Flood AM 1656 (into the ark late 2349 BC; Second Age opens 2348 BC); Exodus 1491 BC [R7] | | (Card) Flood 8 people (Gen 7:13); about 600,000 men (Ex 12:37) | **Accurate** | KJV text [R8] | | (Card) ~200 million in AD 1; 5–27 million in 5000 BC | **Accurate (as estimates)** | Table: AD 1 170–330M, so ~200M is low-middle; 5000 BC 5M (McEvedy & Jones) to 27M (PRB) [R3] | | (Card) 8.3 billion people today | **Not checked** | Current-year figure; not verified here | ## References | # | Source | Exists? | Use in the video / role | Link | |---|---|---|---|---| | R1 | Douglas L. T. Rohde, Steve Olson & Joseph T. Chang, "Modelling the recent common ancestry of all living humans," *Nature* 431:562–566 (2004-09-30) | **Exists; accurate** (full text read, author-hosted PDF; abstract on nature.com) | Description source: the world model, 5,353 BC / 2,158 BC and 1,415 BC / AD 55, ten migrants per generation across the Bering Strait, Tasmania, "very poorly known," "little or no actual genetic inheritance" | [doi:10.1038/nature02842](https://doi.org/10.1038/nature02842) · [PDF (steveolson.com)](https://steveolson.com/uploads/2009/04/nature-common-ancestors2.pdf) | | R2 | Joseph T. Chang, "Recent common ancestors of all present-day individuals," *Advances in Applied Probability* 31(4):1002–1026 (1999) | **Exists; accurate** (abstract read) | Description source: "the math under it": lg n and 1.77 lg n generations | [doi:10.1239/aap/1029955256](https://doi.org/10.1239/aap/1029955256) | | R3 | "Estimates of historical world population," Wikipedia (table citing Biraben 1980 and McEvedy & Jones 1978, among others) | **Exists; accurate** (table read; the primary works were not read) | Description source: 301M and 320M in AD 1100; added: other estimates; card figures for 5000 BC and AD 1 | [Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estimates_of_historical_world_population) | | R4 | G. David Poznik et al., "Sequencing Y chromosomes resolves discrepancy in time to common ancestor of males versus females," *Science* 341(6145):562–565 (2013) | **Exists; accurate** (abstract read, Europe PMC; PMC4032117) | Description source: Y 120–156 ky, mtDNA 99–148 ky | [doi:10.1126/science.1237619](https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1237619) | | R5 | "Identical ancestors point," Wikipedia | **Exists** (read); its description of the 2004 model is **contested** (misdescribes it as random mating without barriers) | Description: the Wikipedia claim it corrects | [Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identical_ancestors_point) | | R6 | Graham Coop, "How much of your genome do you inherit from a particular ancestor?," *gcbias* blog, 2013-11-04 | **Exists** (read) | Added: 2^k ancestors; DNA in chunks; ancestors who contribute zero | [gcbias.org](https://gcbias.org/2013/11/04/how-much-of-your-genome-do-you-inherit-from-a-particular-ancestor/) | | R7 | James Ussher, *The Annals of the World* (Latin *Annales*, 1650–54; English edition text) | **Exists; accurate** (text read) | Card source ("Ussher"): 4004 BC, 2348 BC, 1491 BC | [sermonindex.net text](https://sermonindex.net/ebooks/u/ussher-james-annals-of-the-world.txt) | | R8 | Genesis 7:13; Exodus 12:37 (KJV) | **Exists; accurate** (text read) | Card source: 8 people; about 600,000 men | [Gen 7:13](https://bible-api.com/Genesis+7:13?translation=kjv) · [Ex 12:37](https://bible-api.com/Exodus+12:37?translation=kjv) | | R9 | "Great Pyramid of Giza," Wikipedia | **Exists** (read) | Added: built c. 2600 BC, about 4,600 years ago | [Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Pyramid_of_Giza) | | R10 | "Adam and Eve: The True Account," Answers in Genesis | **Exists** (read) | Added: creationist argument; quotes checked | [answersingenesis.org](https://answersingenesis.org/adam-and-eve/) | | R11 | Robert W. Carter, "Adam, Eve and Noah vs Modern Genetics," Creation Ministries International, 2010-05-11 | **Exists** (read) | Added: creationist argument; quotes checked | [creation.com](https://creation.com/en/articles/noah-and-genetics) | | R12 | "Mitochondrial Eve," Answers in Genesis (News to Note), 2010-08-21 | **Exists** (read) | Added: creationist argument; quotes checked | [answersingenesis.org](https://answersingenesis.org/genetics/mitochondrial-dna/mitochondrial-eve/) | | R13 | Robert Carter & John Sanford, "A 'genealogical' Adam and Eve?" (review of Swamidass), Creation Ministries International, 2020-01-29 | **Exists** (read) | Added: creationist argument; quotes checked | [creation.com](https://creation.com/en/articles/review-swamidass-the-genealogical-adam-and-eve) | | R14 | S. Joshua Swamidass, *The Genealogical Adam and Eve: The Surprising Science of Universal Ancestry* (IVP Academic; paperback 2021-06-01) | **Exists** (publisher page read) | Added context: the same genealogical science applied to a created couple | [ivpress.com](https://www.ivpress.com/the-genealogical-adam-and-eve) | | R15 | "Ussher chronology," Wikipedia | **Exists** (read) | Added: Ussher's offices; 1650 *Annales*; 4004 BC | [Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ussher_chronology) | ### Not found or not checked - Biraben (1980) and McEvedy & Jones (1978) were checked only as tabulated on Wikipedia [R3], not in the original works. - Chang (1999) [R2]: abstract only. - Poznik et al. (2013) [R4]: abstract only. - The 8.3 billion "today" figure on the closing card wasn't checked. - No population-genetics source on whether two people a few thousand years ago could account for today's diversity was read here (a BioLogos article on it returned "Too Many Requests"); the short doesn't make that argument. ## Added context - **Series:** Part of the "Science" set, after [[Why can't you tickle yourself (Science, Part 1)]]; this one carries no part number. Previous upload: [[Why do men have nipples (How evolution works)]] (2026-11-16). Related: [[Where's the missing link Her name is Lucy. (Is evolution true Part 3)|Where's the missing link? Her name is Lucy.]] on human ancestry, [[Where 4.5 billion years comes from (The Age of the Earth, Part 5)]] on dating, and the Ussher-style one-pair chronology vs. the ages in [[Counting rings and ice (The Age of the Earth, Part 1)]]. - **Where the most recent common ancestor lived:** in the model "the MRCAs are nearly always found in eastern Asia," because that region connects to Eurasia and to the Pacific islands or the Americas [R1]. - **Unequal shares:** at the all-or-none point everyone has the same set of ancestors, but in very different proportions: "a present-day Norwegian generally owes the majority of his or her ancestry to people living in northern Europe at the IA point" [R1]. - **The theology debate around this result:** Swamidass uses universal genealogical ancestry to argue that a recently created Adam and Eve could be ancestors of everyone alongside an evolved population [R14]; CMI's reviewers reject this as failing "all biblical tests" [R13]. The short doesn't enter that debate. - **On the description:** it again mentions "first word on the evolution book," so the creator appears to be writing a book on evolution (no title given). ## Biographies ### Joel is Curious (the creator) YouTube channel **Joel is Curious**, mostly Shorts, from 2026-10-04. In his own words (video description): "I'm Joel, a software developer and former tech executive who likes to learn stuff. Science, history, Buddhism, Stoicism, and the thinkers behind them." He lists his sources in each description. (Sources: the video and its description.) ### Douglas L. T. Rohde, Steve Olson and Joseph T. Chang (cited in the description) Authors of R1. Affiliations as printed in 2004: Rohde, Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences, Massachusetts Institute of Technology (corresponding author); Olson, Bethesda, Maryland; Chang, Department of Statistics, Yale University [R1]. Chang is also the author of the 1999 paper [R2]. ### James Ussher (on the closing card) Archbishop of Armagh and Primate of All Ireland in the Church of Ireland; his 1650 *Annales Veteris Testamenti* gave the chronology dating creation to 4004 BC [R7, R15]. ### S. Joshua Swamidass (added context) M.D., Ph.D.; associate professor in the Laboratory and Genomic Medicine Division at Washington University in St. Louis (as described in R13); author of R14. ### Robert W. Carter and John Sanford (added context) Creation Ministries International authors; Carter wrote R11, and the two co-wrote R13.