# You’ll Never Look at Bible Genealogies the Same Again ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again.webp]] **Creator:** Bart D. Ehrman channel ([@bartdehrman](https://www.youtube.com/@bartdehrman)) · **Show:** *Misquoting Moses* with Joel Baden, hosted by Megan Kraege · **Published:** 2026-10-30 · **Length:** 59:48 · [Watch on YouTube](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY) > Caption source: `yt-dlp` with the **android_vr** client returned YouTube's English auto-generated captions (`en-orig`, about 10,200 words) on the first try. Quotes come from those captions and may contain small transcription errors. The captions spell the host "Megan Craig"; the video description spells her name **Megan Kraege**, which is used here. Section headings follow the episode outline in the description. Screenshots are from the 360p video. > **Who's on screen:** Bart Ehrman does **not** appear. It is a two-person video call between host **Megan Kraege** (of the Bart Ehrman team) and **Dr. Joel Baden**, Hebrew Bible scholar. > **Promotion:** A mid-roll segment ([22:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1322s)) promotes Baden's live course *The Bible by Committee: How the Pentateuch Was Really Written* (10 lectures and 5 Q&A sessions, recorded October 30 to November 1, with a bonus discussion with David Carr the following Monday) at bartehrman.com/pentateuch. Listener questions go to bartehrman.com/askjoel. > **Series order:** The next episode, announced at the end, is [[The Golden Calf Wasn't A False God|The Golden Calf Wasn’t A “False God.”]] ## Outline ### Why Biblical Genealogies Matter More Than You Think (0:00 to 2:15) - [0:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=0s) Cold open: "Generation after generation, begat after begat." Kraege lists the genealogies readers skip (Genesis 4–5, 10–11, 25, 36, Exodus 1, Chronicles: "Ever read Chronicles? Like all the way through? No, you haven't.") and teases what is hidden in them: a man who lives 969 years, another who "doesn't die" and seemingly ascends to heaven, "the names of cities disguised as people", "family drama that begins in the womb", and "the age-old verbal assault of accusing your neighbors of being the product of incest." - [1:12](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=72s) Welcome back to *Misquoting Moses*, with an Ask Joel segment at the end. Baden admits he had the same question about filling a whole episode: "it'll be an adventure for everyone." ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t0003.webp]] *Host Megan Kraege opens the episode* ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t0075.webp]] *Kraege and Joel Baden on the call* ### Why Ancient Texts Include Lists and Genealogies (2:15 to 4:24) - [2:13](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=133s) "It's pretty common." The *Iliad* has its ships and shields, the Babylonian creation account *Enuma Elish* ("the like great Genesis 1 equivalent") ends with a list of Marduk's divine titles, and even *Moby-Dick* stops to enumerate. Listing is "a feature, not a bug." - [3:05](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=185s) Different genealogies do different jobs. Modern readers lack "the genre competence" to read genealogies (or ritual texts like Leviticus, a future episode); it is a form the ancients liked and we have lost touch with. - [4:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=243s) Kraege: we do have genealogies today. Baden: "this is the Bible's 23andMe." The comparison works, except that 23andMe's lineage is scientific while the Bible's "is more conceptual and not always true or real or historical"; ancient people thought lineage had "just about everything to do with who they were as people." ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t0160.webp]] *Baden on lists in the Iliad, Enuma Elish and Moby-Dick* ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t0280.webp]] *"This is the Bible's 23andMe"* ### Are Biblical Genealogies Historically Accurate? (4:24 to 6:48) - [5:21](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=321s) "Well, probably not", starting with "our 969-year-old friend Methuselah. Great guy by the way." Very roughly, the Bible runs from "definitely didn't happen" to "more likely happened": "I trust what I read in Genesis less than what I read in Ezra. I don't trust anything I read in Chronicles", which is where many of the genealogies are. - [6:06](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=366s) A list of pre-flood people with near-thousand-year lives and the list in Ezra of families returning from exile may both be untrue, but "I don't think they came into being the same way and I don't think they're doing the same work." ### Two Genealogies, One Tradition: Genesis 4 and 5 (6:48 to 12:26) - [6:52](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=412s) Put side by side, Genesis 4 and 5 have "basically all the same people with tiny little variations in their names" (Methuselah in one, Methusael in the other) in roughly the same order, yet they read as successive generations, which "doesn't really work." - [7:38](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=458s) Genesis 4 comes from one Pentateuchal source and Genesis 5 from another ("What's a Pentateuchal source? You have to take my class to find out"). Two kids listing the US presidents would match too, but that is implausible for people with thousand-year lifespans; more likely there was "a common Israelite tradition" of antediluvian ancestors whose legends are now lost. - [9:11](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=551s) The idea is not unique to the Bible: the Mesopotamian **Sumerian King List** also has a flood and kings before it with enormous reigns. It is a way of linking the present to the mythic past. - [10:42](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=642s) Genealogies bracket the periods of the past: creation to Noah, then the flood, then more genealogy to Abraham, Isaac and Jacob (still mythical, but not "cosmically mythical"). They fill "otherwise empty historical mythic historical space": if creation is followed by "everyone on Earth died, I got to have everyone on Earth." Genesis 10 has the earth branching out after the flood, and genealogy gets us to one family, Abraham's, with everyone already settled. ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t0450.webp]] *Genesis 4 and 5: the same names in two sources* ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t0590.webp]] *Baden on the Sumerian King List* ### Methuselah and the Meaning of Extraordinary Lifespans (12:26 to 16:40) - [12:58](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=778s) The long lifespans reflect a broader ancient Near Eastern belief that "things were different back then." Baden loves the line "the past is a foreign country"; we wrongly assume ancient people had no sense of history or change, but the Bible depicts eras (Eden, before the flood, before Abraham, the patriarchs) as unlike the writers' own time. - [14:30](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=870s) The ages in the early genealogies are one way of saying "it was just a different kind of world." Kraege jokes that she keeps chipping away at what is unique about Israel; there were "ancient Egyptologists in ancient Egypt." - [15:15](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=915s) Mesopotamian kings collected antiquities (the library of Ashurbanipal). And anyone living in 7th-century Israel "would have been surrounded by ruins", which demands a sense of history; that sensibility explains a fair chunk of the early-history material in the Pentateuch, Joshua and Judges. ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t0780.webp]] *"The past is a foreign country"* ### How Different Biblical Sources Use Genealogies (16:40 to 21:54) - [16:47](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1007s) In the primeval history (Genesis 1–11) the two sources' genealogies (Genesis 4–5 and 10–11) do the same job and draw on shared motifs. After that they differ. - [17:33](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1053s) Genesis 36, Esau's descendants, is "one of the roughest genealogies in the Bible because it's not even a genealogy of us... honestly, who cares?" Long ago readers saw it and thought "uh-oh, Moses didn't write this", because Esau's line runs far past Moses, almost to the author's present. It explains how the Edomites of the author's day relate to the ancestors. - [19:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1143s) That is the Priestly author, who also gives Moses and Aaron's family genealogy in Exodus 6 and opens Numbers with censuses ("you know how the Book of Numbers is called the Book of Numbers?"): the tribes, their heads, the totals, "the exact 603,000... something hundred and something", "and there's math." - [19:50](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1190s) This is the priestly love of system: "to put it crudely, sort of bean counting." Lists lend a text "an air of accuracy"; naming people made the Bible seem true, and scholars still argue that some lists came from older sources. "I mean, they're not true." Kraege: "It lends an air of truth. It doesn't lend grounds of truth." ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t1090.webp]] *Baden on Esau's genealogy in Genesis 36* ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t1200.webp]] *The Priestly source and the census lists in Numbers* ### The Bible by Committee: Understanding the Pentateuch's Origins (21:54 to 25:11) - [22:02](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1322s) Course segment: *The Bible by Committee*, recorded live from Friday, October 30. "It's going to be very spooky." Baden promises an inductive "show and tell": "here's how I know what I know", "the great sort of detective mystery story of the Bible." - [23:08](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1388s) The weekend ends with a bonus Monday discussion with David Carr of Union Theological Seminary, a long-time interlocutor who does not "see eye to eye exactly" with Baden on how the Pentateuch came to be, about the assumptions scholars bring. Recordings of all 10 lectures stay available at bartehrman.com/pentateuch. ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t1335.webp]] *Course banner: October 30 to November 1* ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t1470.webp]] *The Bible by Committee: How the Pentateuch Was Really Written, with Joel Baden* ### Hidden Insults, Political Rivals, and Family Lines (25:11 to 30:08) - [24:58](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1498s) Kraege: the genealogies can be "shady", sneaking insults at Israel's enemies into lists of who begat whom. - [25:10](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1510s) Some names carry traditions: Nimrod in Genesis 10 "is not a bad guy... it's a shame he really got smeared in the press"; he was a warrior who built cities. In Numbers 26 ("truly one of the top chapters"), a priestly census list, someone (perhaps a later hand) filled out names with stories: among the Levites comes Korah, who ten chapters earlier led a rebellion and died, and the list nods at it. A census list "shapes what exists... It's a societal structuring mechanism." - [27:27](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1647s) Kraege raises Genesis 19, where Lot's daughters bear the ancestors of Moab and Ammon, "two of Israel's biggest enemies." Baden: that is a narrative with genealogical consequences rather than the genre of genealogy, but "that's good like taunting." All of Genesis is a story of how everyone is related or not; Hebrew and Moabite differ only dialectally ("If you can read one, you can read the other"), so Israel had to explain "How come we're not them and they're not us?" ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t1560.webp]] *Baden on Nimrod and Korah* ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t1690.webp]] *Lot's daughters, Moab and Ammon* ### Genealogies as Worldbuilding and Historical Storytelling (30:08 to 35:44) - [29:45](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1785s) Micronarratives sit inside genealogies and microgenealogies inside narratives. Baden promises a Numbers episode to defend it from Kraege's "smears and accusations." - [30:32](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1832s) The Pentateuch's lists are a mythological past, so what are they lists of? Often eponymous ancestors whose "names really are places or regions or tribes"; a list of Judah's descendants includes towns and regions of Judah. Naming cities after people goes back to Genesis 4. - [32:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1923s) Ezra's list of returning families was written within some memory of the return, but "really you like know the names of all of those people?" - [32:48](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1968s) Baden's pet theory, "I would never put in print": some lists are "patron lists for the authors. Like just a reminder, no one was writing for free." A scribe's backer might say "put my family in there." "I think it's probably not true", but even a contemporary list need not be true, and whether it is matters less than why anyone wanted it in the text: "a sense of completeness, a sense of accuracy, a sense of realism." Kraege: "world building." Baden: "exactly right. You're a nerd." ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t2030.webp]] *Baden's pet theory: patron lists for paid scribes* ### Why Chronicles Begins with Nine Chapters of Genealogies (35:44 to 40:59) - [35:05](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2105s) Kraege: the Ezra lists also serve exclusion of foreigners and defining a "pure Israelite". What is Chronicles doing? - [35:50](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2150s) Chronicles retells Kings "from a perspective a few hundred years later" (a Chronicles episode will come "468 episodes from now"). It cares about the monarchy and David; most of 1 Chronicles is the David story, but it starts at chapter 10. "The first nine chapters of Chronicles is a genealogizing basically of everything from Genesis 1 through David." - [36:35](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2195s) It clearly draws on the whole Pentateuch as we have it, from all the sources, "making it into an Excel spreadsheet" to reach the story it wants to tell. The New Testament "also starts with a genealogy" doing the same work. - [38:06](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2286s) Kraege: Matthew's genealogy differs from Chronicles, and Chronicles differs from Moses's genealogy in Exodus; only when you stop demanding that they line up can you learn from them. - [38:51](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2331s) Ruth: a "lovely" self-contained story (with intimate relations "that involve like feet that aren't feet") to which "a secondary hand has tacked on" a short genealogy making Ruth an ancestor of David. The genealogy explains why the story matters: "Creation, flood, Abraham. Genealogies make those all into one connected whole." ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t2200.webp]] *Chronicles' nine chapters of genealogy* ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t2350.webp]] *The genealogy added to the end of Ruth* ### David's Lineage, Kingship, and the Origins of Messianic Hope (40:59 to 47:15) - [41:10](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2470s) The David genealogies are propaganda: within about a century David becomes the model king and the ancestor of the Messiah. To be king in Judah "you have to be descended from David", and once that was the rule people stood up to say "I also am Spartacus, right? I am a descendant of David", which is how coups in the south still produce "David people." - [42:40](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2560s) David unifies disparate tribes, creating the lasting legend of a unified golden-age kingdom. After the Babylonian exile removes David's line "never to return", the hope of restoration becomes eschatological and messianic, "and that's how you get the genealogy at the beginning of Matthew." - [44:13](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2653s) Kraege: this seems more uniquely Israelite, since in Egypt and Mesopotamia even foreigners could seize the throne. Baden: it is "only Judah"; the northern kingdom of Israel had no divinely appointed lineage and constant coups and dynasty changes, and its people were "just as Israelite", though the Bible comes from the south. - [45:45](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2745s) Elsewhere kings took the names of a golden-age past (Sargon and Sargon II, the many Ramesses), as later with Louis XIV, XVI and XVII or "George Bushes." Kraege: commenters say she looks like Louis XIV; Baden's hair "is not a wig... It's not a sheitel, either." - [47:18](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2838s) Wrap-up: people in every present look back and say "the past was better." ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t2520.webp]] *Baden on David's lineage and messianic hope* ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t2800.webp]] *"It's not a wig, by the way"* ### Ask Joel: Missing Material in the Pentateuch (47:15 to 51:38) - [48:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2884s) Does the Pentateuch preserve all of the four sources? "I guarantee we don't have everything." Read separately, each source has gaps: characters appear without a birth and vanish without a death. - [48:49](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2929s) A compiling principle: things that can happen twice in reality can happen twice in the text ("possible for a dude to pass his wife off as his sister kind of as many times as he wants"), but "nobody can be born twice", so when two sources report the same birth or death only one is kept, and not always from the same source. - [49:36](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2976s) Bigger gaps too: E, "probably the gappiest", likely lacks its beginning and a chunk in the middle. That may be loss rather than cutting: the beginning or end of a scroll is the outside part, most likely to be damaged. Since contradictions were left in, nobody was mostly trying to cut. None of the sources, "except probably D", is complete. ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t2900.webp]] *Ask Joel: gaps in the Pentateuchal sources* ### Ask Joel: Israel, Canaan, and Palestine (51:38 to 56:40) - [51:10](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=3070s) **Alan:** why call the people and place "Israel"? Because the Bible names the land Israel, as Edom is Edomite land and Moab Moabite. The name is a moving target: Jacob renamed Israel; the northern kingdom; the united kingdom under David and Solomon; Judah after the north falls; the returning exiles as "the true Israel". Who counts as the real Israel is "an ongoing to this day kind of conversation." - [53:28](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=3208s) Canaan is the biblical name of the region and its people, also known from other ancient Near Eastern sources, stretching from Syria and Lebanon down to Egypt's border. - [54:13](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=3253s) Palestine, "the third rail of biblical politics", comes from "Philistine", first the coastal Philistine area and later the broader region: "if anyone ever tells you that Palestinian is a modern term, they're wrong. It's a very ancient term", going back before Jesus, a replacement once "Canaanite" no longer named a real people. - [55:46](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=3346s) Kraege: Bible maps use any of these names depending on age. Baden: the terms are not coterminous or simultaneous, and calling the region Israel rather than Canaan is a political claim: "They're not neutral terms." ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t3150.webp]] *Ask Joel: Israel, Canaan and Palestine* ### Ask Joel: Was Child Sacrifice Practiced in Ancient Israel? (56:40 to 59:48) - [56:32](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=3392s) **John:** was child sacrifice common, and does the Bible both forbid and command it? "It's almost true", worth a full episode. The brief version: it existed in the ancient world, "probably" was practiced in Israel, but was not common in either. Whether God ever commanded it according to the Bible is the debate: "I say no", though "some prominent scholars on the internet" say yes. - [58:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=3483s) Sign-off, praising the show's audio and video upgrades. Next episode: the golden calf, "maybe my favorite and also most vexing story" in the Pentateuch. Questions to bartehrman.com/askjoel; new episodes "of silliness, snark, and scholarship on Fridays." ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t3420.webp]] *Ask Joel: child sacrifice* ![[images/Youll-Never-Look-at-Bible-Genealogies-the-Same-Again-t3556.webp]] *Sign-off: bartehrman.com/askjoel* ## Key takeaways - Lists and genealogies were a normal, valued literary form in the ancient world; modern readers have lost the skill to read them. - Biblical genealogies are not reliable family trees, but they show how Israel understood its origins and its neighbours. - They bridge empty mythic time (creation to flood to Abraham) and stitch separate stories into one history. - The near-identical lists in Genesis 4 and 5 point to a shared pre-flood tradition, like the Sumerian King List. - Priestly lists and censuses create an "air of accuracy", not proof of it. - Genealogies define "us and them": smears against Moab and Ammon, names that are really places, exclusion in Ezra. - Chronicles, Ruth and Matthew use genealogy to connect everything to David, whose lineage became Judah's royal ideology and the root of messianic hope. ## Claims check | Claim | Verdict | Notes | |---|---|---| | Methuselah lived 969 years; another man "doesn't die" ([0:47](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=47s)) | Accurate (as the text says) | Genesis 5:27; Enoch "walked with God; then he was no more, because God took him" (Genesis 5:24). | | Genesis 4 and 5 list nearly the same names from two sources ([6:52](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=412s)) | Accurate | A standard observation: Cain/Kenan, Enoch, Irad/Jared, Mehujael/Mahalalel, Methushael/Methuselah, Lamech. Genesis 4 is usually assigned to J and Genesis 5 to P. | | *Enuma Elish* ends with a list of Marduk's names ([2:19](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=139s)) | Accurate | Its closing tablets proclaim Marduk's fifty names. | | The Sumerian King List has pre-flood kings with thousand-year lifespans ([9:56](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=596s)) | Understated | Its antediluvian kings reign for tens of thousands of years (Alulim 28,800 years in common versions), far longer than the biblical figures. | | Genesis 36's genealogy runs past Moses, which made readers doubt Mosaic authorship ([18:18](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1098s)) | Accurate | Genesis 36:31 lists kings of Edom "before any king reigned over the Israelites", a classic point raised by medieval and early modern critics. | | The Numbers census totals "603,000... something" ([19:50](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1190s)) | Accurate | 603,550 (Numbers 1:46; 2:32); the second census in Numbers 26:51 gives 601,730. | | Numbers 26 nods to Korah, who led a rebellion ten chapters earlier and "died when God burned him and his followers alive" ([26:41](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1601s)) | Partly accurate | Numbers 16 and 26:9–11. In the text the earth swallows Korah's group and fire consumes the 250 men offering incense; Numbers 26:11 adds that Korah's sons did not die. | | Lot's daughters bear Moab and Ammon "after the whole flood thing" (Kraege, [27:27](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1647s)) | Slip | Genesis 19:30–38 follows the destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah, not the flood. The Moab/Ammon origin is accurate. | | Hebrew and Moabite are close enough that "if you can read one, you can read the other" ([28:59](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=1739s)) | Broadly accurate | Both are Canaanite dialects; the Mesha Stele (9th century BCE) is readable with Biblical Hebrew. | | 1 Chronicles 1–9 is genealogy and the David story starts at chapter 10 ([36:35](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2195s)) | Accurate | Chapter 10 is Saul's death; David's reign begins in chapter 11. | | The genealogy at the end of Ruth makes Ruth David's ancestor and was added later ([38:51](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2331s)) | Accurate / widely held | Ruth 4:17–22 makes Ruth David's great-grandmother; many scholars see 4:18–22 as a secondary addition. | | "The past is a foreign country" ([12:58](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=778s)) | Accurate quote | Opening line of L. P. Hartley's *The Go-Between* (1953); not named in the video. | | The northern kingdom had constant coups and dynasty changes ([45:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2700s)) | Accurate | Kings records repeated usurpations (Baasha, Zimri, Omri, Jehu, Shallum, Menahem, Pekah, Hoshea). | | "Palestine" derives from "Philistine" and is an ancient name for the region ([54:13](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=3253s)) | Accurate | Herodotus (5th century BCE) uses *Palaistinē* for the region; Rome later named the province Syria Palaestina (2nd century CE). | | Kings in Egypt and Mesopotamia could be foreigners (Kraege, [44:13](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=2653s)) | Accurate | E.g. the Hyksos and the Nubian 25th Dynasty in Egypt, the Kassites in Babylonia. | | Child sacrifice existed but was not common; whether the Bible has God command it is debated ([57:17](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q9Q2eSO6nbY&t=3437s)) | Fair summary | Scholars debate texts such as Exodus 22:29 and Ezekiel 20:25–26; Baden's "no" is one side of that debate. The "prominent scholars on the internet" are not named. | ## Things mentioned ### Books and texts - *The Iliad*, Homer (the catalogue of ships and the shields) - *Enuma Elish*, the Babylonian creation epic (anonymous) - *Moby-Dick*, Herman Melville (title only) - *The Silmarillion*, J. R. R. Tolkien (cold-open joke) - The Sumerian King List and the Gilgamesh flood story (Mesopotamian) - *The Go-Between*, L. P. Hartley (source of "the past is a foreign country"; the book is not named in the video) - Biblical passages: Genesis 4–5, 10–11, 19, 25 and 36; Exodus 1 and 6; Numbers 1 and 26 (censuses) and Numbers 16 (Korah); Leviticus; Ruth 4; 1 Chronicles 1–10; Ezra (the list of returnees); Matthew 1 - Scholarly terms: the Pentateuchal sources (J, E, P, D), the Priestly author, eponymous ancestors, the primeval history ### Courses, people and other - *The Bible by Committee: How the Pentateuch Was Really Written*, Joel Baden's course (bartehrman.com/pentateuch), with a bonus discussion with David Carr - 23andMe; the library of Ashurbanipal; "I am Spartacus" (allusion to the 1960 film, not named); Sargon and Sargon II; Ramesses; Louis XIV, XVI and XVII; the George Bushes - Promised future episodes: Leviticus and ritual texts, Numbers, Chronicles, Ruth, child sacrifice, and the next episode on the golden calf ## Biographies - **Joel S. Baden**: Hebrew Bible scholar and professor at Yale Divinity School, a leading defender of the Documentary Hypothesis (the "neo-documentarian" approach). Books include *J, E, and the Redaction of the Pentateuch*, *The Composition of the Pentateuch*, *The Historical David* and *The Book of Exodus: A Biography*. He co-hosts *Misquoting Moses* on the Bart D. Ehrman channel. - **Megan Kraege**: member of the Bart Ehrman team and host of *Misquoting Moses*. - **David M. Carr**: Hebrew Bible scholar at Union Theological Seminary in New York, known for work on how the Hebrew Bible was formed (e.g. *The Formation of the Hebrew Bible*); Baden calls him a long-time interlocutor who does not fully share his view of the Pentateuch. - **Bart D. Ehrman**: New Testament scholar who retired from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill; his channel hosts the show. He does not appear in this episode.