# Joshua Never Conquered Canaan. Here’s What Really Happened ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened.webp]] **Creator:** Bart D. Ehrman channel ([@bartdehrman](https://www.youtube.com/@bartdehrman)) · **Show:** *Misquoting Moses* with Joel Baden, hosted by Megan Kraege (episode 10) · **Published:** 2026-10-09 · **Length:** 1:09:29 · [Watch on YouTube](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU) > Caption source: `yt-dlp` returned YouTube's English auto-generated captions (`en-orig`, about 11,000 words) through the **web_embedded** client after the android_vr, android, ios and tv clients hit YouTube's bot check. Quotes come from those captions and may contain small transcription errors. The captions spell the host "Megan Craig"; the video description spells her name **Megan Kraege**, which is used here. The video has no chapters, so the section headings below are this note's own. The video file could not be downloaded, so the screenshots are low-resolution YouTube storyboard frames (320x180, enlarged). > **Who's on screen:** Bart Ehrman does **not** appear. It is a two-person video call between host **Megan Kraege** (of the Bart Ehrman team) and **Dr. Joel Baden**, Hebrew Bible scholar. > **Promotion:** A mid-roll segment ([23:13](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1393s)) promotes Baden's live course *The Bible by Committee: How the Pentateuch Was Really Written* (10 lectures and 5 Q&A sessions, live October 30 to November 1, early-bird discount until October 10) at bartehrman.com/pentateuch. Listener questions go to bartehrman.com/askjoel. > **Series:** This episode marks episode 10 of the show and its first Ask Joel segment. Later *Misquoting Moses* episodes in this folder: [[You'll Never Look at Bible Genealogies the Same Again|You’ll Never Look at Bible Genealogies the Same Again]] (2026-10-30) and [[The Golden Calf Wasn't A False God|The Golden Calf Wasn’t A “False God.”]] (2026-11-06). ## Outline ### Two conquest stories, neither true (0:00 to 1:04) - [0:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=0s) Cold open: in the end of Numbers and in Joshua, "the Israelites sweep the land in a lightning military campaign, completely destroying the Canaanites, then apportioning the land among the Israelite tribes." In Judges the allotment comes first, the taking is slower and less systematic, and "some of the most significant cities, including Jerusalem, remained under Canaanite control." But "scholars don't think that either of these stories actually happened." So why would the Israelites tell these stories, and how did this society actually come to be? ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t0019.webp]] *Cold open: a woodcut of the twelve tribes camped around the tabernacle, with Latin labels* ### Joshua and Judges as competing traditions (1:04 to 4:17) - [1:06](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=66s) Kraege welcomes Baden back and announces the first listener-question segment, Ask Joel, "to celebrate episode 10." - [2:13](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=133s) "Here's a strong open": in the Pentateuch the contradictory strands are easy to separate, but past it, in Joshua through Kings, "it's very muddy." Baden lets slip that he is currently thinking hard about the composition of Joshua through Kings, "particularly Joshua," and is not sure the same kind of sources are at work. - [3:12](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=192s) What is clear is that there are traditions "in contradiction or that duplicate each other": parallel stories, texts with an editorial frame that says something different, and "two entire books almost," like Joshua and Judges, with different assumptions about what happened. ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t0069.webp]] *Kraege welcomes Joel Baden back* ### The Bible's origin stories: patriarchs versus Exodus (4:17 to 11:42) - [4:17](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=257s) Kraege: "Scholars don't think either of those stories actually happened. That includes you." Baden: "you just asked a question that's going to take me 45 minutes to answer." - [5:20](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=320s) There is a roughly consistent biblical story: Abraham called by God, then Isaac and Jacob, and Jacob's sons as the 12 tribes. But there was also a separate, older tradition in which Israel "becomes a people essentially when they're taken out of Egypt." Before the texts were written there were many oral and written traditions "fused together over time into a sort of coherent or semi-coherent whole." - [6:24](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=384s) Evidence for the Exodus tradition: God offering a new deal ("I will be your God and you'll be my people"), and prophetic texts that never mention the patriarchs but have God say "I found you in the wilderness" or "I have known you since Egypt." - [7:27](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=447s) Kraege points to the burning bush, where God has to explain that the ancestors knew him under another name. Baden: the Joseph story does the fusing. The patriarchs build altars, bury their dead and name trees to claim the land, then leave it, "and none of the stuff the patriarchs did ever matters again"; nobody returns to the ancestral cave. - [9:13](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=553s) "So, now I've got four things that aren't true": the ancestors story, the Exodus story, Joshua and Judges. - [9:32](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=572s) Kraege: all of them place Israel's origins outside the promised land (Abraham from Mesopotamia, the Hebrews in Egypt, outsiders in Numbers and Joshua). Baden will "circle back to that." - [10:34](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=634s) The big biblical story runs from one man to 12 tribes in their God-given territories. "But there is no archaeological or historical evidence for any of that." ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t0398.webp]] *Baden on the separate Exodus origin tradition* ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t0568.webp]] *"Now I've got four things that aren't true"* ### How do you tell where a people came from? (11:42 to 15:51) - [11:42](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=702s) Working out where people come from is one of the trickiest things in archaeology; pots and house styles can suggest links, but "it's not always easy to go one-to-one." - [12:45](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=765s) Kraege: the genealogies are not historical either; "We didn't have ancestry.com." Baden asks when a people becomes distinct: when did British colonial settlers become American? The Declaration of Independence? Coffee instead of tea? Losing the accent ("I'm from Boston, so we never quite lost the accent")? - [13:47](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=827s) Taking the Bible off the table, the first outside mention of Israel comes from "the most important guy in the world at that time" (Kraege): the Pharaoh of Egypt. - [14:54](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=894s) Pharaoh **Merneptah**, around the turn of the 12th century BCE, lists his conquests and says he wiped out the people of Israel, which in Egyptian royal boasting "probably means like I took some taxes from"; royal annals keep "totally wiping out the same people year after year." The text marks Israel as "a people not a nation," not a city or state. ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t0748.webp]] *Kraege: "We didn't have ancestry.com"* ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t0897.webp]] *Baden on Pharaoh Merneptah's mention of Israel* ### Biblical archaeology and the conquest model: Jericho and Ai (15:51 to 21:05) - [16:14](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=974s) The archaeological picture changed "in my lifetime." "If you think archaeology is a science uh you're wrong": its data is "just another text to be read and interpreted." - [17:50](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1070s) Late 19th and early 20th-century biblical archaeology meant digging "with a Bible in one hand and a spade in the other," looking for the Bible, "and that's always going to skew what you come up with." - [18:28](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1108s) At Jericho the first archaeologist saw ruined walls and said "Nailed it." In the 1960s (per Baden) **Kathleen Kenyon** found it "definitely destroyed, definitely not at the right time historically." Who lived there at the biblical date? "No one... Jericho was an abandoned heap of ruins." - [19:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1165s) Joshua's first two conquests are Jericho, "pile of ruins," and Ai, which "literally the word means ruin." The Israelites "looked at these giant piles of ruins and thought, 'I bet we did that.'" - [20:20](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1220s) The "conquest model" is "just a fancy way of saying what the Bible says." Kenyon's dig and others "totally busted that... There is virtually no archaeological evidence for a destruction at the right time." Kraege: "Conquest model in the trash." ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t1077.webp]] *Jericho, Kathleen Kenyon and the conquest model* ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t1246.webp]] *"Conquest model in the trash"* ### Peaceful infiltration and peasant revolt (21:05 to 23:13) - [21:05](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1265s) Scholars knew what didn't happen but not what did. One alternative kept the arrival from outside without the fighting: "a peaceful infiltration," but "there's no positive evidence for it." - [22:06](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1326s) In the '60s and '70s, "when it was very hip," a Marxist model made Israel an uprising of the local peasantry against "imperial capitalist overlords": "a full-blown really interesting theory... that had just no evidence." People were "throwing darts" until "in the '90s, we suddenly got new information." ### The Bible by Committee (23:13 to 25:25) - [23:13](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1393s) Course segment. Why teach it? "It's like solving a puzzle all the time": showing you what you think you know, how it doesn't work, then turning it "kind of by magic, but like not in the bad like uh prophetic magic kind of way" into something that does. - [24:50](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1490s) Kraege: 10 lectures, "as in-depth into the composition of the Pentateuch as you ever have in an online course," live from October 30 to November 1 with Q&A, recordings available "till Elijah returns." ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t1516.webp]] *Course banner: October 30 to November 1, bartehrman.com/pentateuch* ### Finkelstein's survey: villages in the hill country (25:25 to 31:41) - [25:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1525s) "We didn't know really until relatively recently." **Israel Finkelstein**, "pretty much the preeminent Israeli archaeologist," surveyed early Iron Age settlement (12th century BCE onward) rather than digging single sites. - [26:26](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1586s) He found "a sudden like giant proliferation of very small settlements" dotting the hill country north of Jerusalem: poor, scrubby land, unlike the fertile coastal plains with their industry, fishing and trade. - [28:29](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1709s) They sit exactly where the stories in Judges are set: "Ephraim and Manasseh and Benjamin," the area of Saul. The villages later coalesce and grow. - [29:33](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1773s) Are they Israelites? "I don't know that I do know that they're Israelites. What I know is that they become Israelites." Archaeologically "you'd be pretty hard-pressed to tell the difference between them and the Canaanites" (Kraege: "the bad guys?"): the same houses, pots and other markers of ethnicity. The likeliest reading is that they came from the Canaanite urban centres. ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t1595.webp]] *Finkelstein's survey: small villages in the hill country* ### Late Bronze Age collapse and the move to the hills (31:41 to 37:59) - [31:41](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1901s) Why leave nice places for hard ones? "Have you seen the Odyssey?" (neither has; Kraege jokes about Penelope and praises the Cyclops design). Around the start of the 12th century "essentially the entire ancient Mediterranean world collapsed in what is called the late Bronze Age collapse," for reasons not entirely clear: "some climate stuff... definitely some political stuff... probably some social stuff." Urban city-states in Greece, Turkey, Syria, Egypt and Canaan fell apart and people got on the move. - [33:47](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2027s) The Sea Peoples, including the Philistines, were "not a cause of collapse but a result of collapse"; their settlement in Canaanite territory added military pressure. Canaanites from collapsing cities, pushed by Philistines, become "migrants" looking for a safer place. - [35:09](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2109s) New technologies make the hills livable: cisterns for rainwater and terracing, "which you can still see evidence of in the hills of Israel today," also making it possible to keep animals. - [35:52](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2152s) Speculative but likely: separated villages form clans and tribes, customs and stories ("why do we live here?... because our ancestors were given this land"). Baden's example: in the hill country, days from the coast, shellfish spoil, so "they stopped eating shellfish up there," and it became a marker. Distinct pots and houses follow, "simply by virtue of, frankly, being separate." ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t1895.webp]] *"Have you seen the Odyssey?": the Late Bronze Age collapse* ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t2044.webp]] *Sea Peoples, Philistines and migrants to the hill country* ### Yahweh, Baal and the archaeology of religion (37:59 to 42:13) - [38:27](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2307s) Kraege raises "a pretty big elephant in the room": scholars don't know exactly where Yahweh came from, yet nearly every book of the Hebrew Bible agrees "Yahweh is the God of Israel," while the Canaanites worship Baal, "very similar to Yahweh in a lot of very suspicious ways," and a large pantheon known from their dug-up texts. - [40:29](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2429s) Some evidence is inscriptional ("May you be blessed by Yahweh"). Canaanite gods are easy to find because they have statues; Baden recalls excavating at Ashkelon, famous for a small bull or calf statue "clearly meant to be like the god Baal." Yahweh worship had "no statue," so archaeology mainly sees an absence, though Israelites also left many statues of "just not the right ones." ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t2293.webp]] *"A pretty big elephant in the room": where Yahweh came from* ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t2493.webp]] *Ashkelon's calf statue and the absence of Yahweh images* ### What Canaanite origins explain: backsliding, not temptation (42:13 to 46:22) - [42:13](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2533s) Kraege: so many stories seem designed to stop Canaanite worship, "which would make sense if they were originally Canaanites." Baden: "Now, I went Marxist." - [43:17](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2597s) The Bible frames it as entering a land of tempting foreigners who will lead you astray. Read with the archaeology, "It's about backsliding into something old... because your dad worshipped Baal." The repeated warnings really say "You have to stop doing stuff the way that you're used to doing it." - [45:30](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2730s) In the biblical story the Israelites have "never met Baal," so the anxiety makes little sense; Kraege notes Baal and Yahweh have similar backstories, a future episode. ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t2692.webp]] *"Backsliding into something old"* ### Everyone but the Canaanites and Egyptians (46:22 to 49:47) - [46:22](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2782s) Baden's second point ("I have three"): every biblical story insists Israel came from elsewhere. Israel happily claims kinship with the Arameans (Rebekah, Laban), the Moabites and Ammonites (through Lot) and Esau's line, "everyone except for the Canaanites," which is "the lady doth protest too much." - [47:56](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2876s) Chart the peoples around Israel and the only two it is not related to are the Canaanites and the Egyptians, the two it "actually probably" has a historical relationship with: it came out of Canaan when Egypt controlled Canaan in the Late Bronze Age, and some part of Israel probably did come from Egypt (a future Exodus episode). - [48:30](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2910s) The slander of Canaanites is "anxiety about being identified with Canaanites," "a rather typical move of cultural identity building": dietary, religious and geographical markers that say "We are this, and we are definitely not that." ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t2892.webp]] *Identity building: "We are this, and we are definitely not that"* ### Israel and Judah: built from the ground up (49:47 to 56:54) - [49:47](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2987s) Third point: archaeology reverses the story "down into the time of David." Not one Israel that tragically splits after Solomon's death, but small tribal units that sometimes fought together and, under Philistine pressure, joined under Saul, only in the north. - [51:37](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3097s) Judah was a "largely unpopulated region in the south," with Jerusalem as "the Mason-Dixon line" of ancient Israel. The northern tribes (Ephraim, Manasseh and Benjamin at the core, plus Dan, Naphtali, Zebulun, Issachar, Asher, and perhaps groups across the Jordan) shared a language with dialects (the shibboleth story) and roughly the same deity, but were not a political entity until Saul. Kraege: none of the Judges stories is set in Judah. - [53:28](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3208s) David probably did unite Israel and Judah, but as "a completely new political entity," and when the north leaves after Solomon "That is a reversion." If you picture one man becoming a nation that conquers and then splits, "you've got it actually completely backward. Which is not your fault... You were just reading the Bible." - [55:51](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3351s) Instead: an organic, "ground-up" process. The archaeology "both totally undermines the biblical story and at the same time totally explain[s] why the biblical story looks the way that it does." ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t3091.webp]] *Judah, the "Mason-Dixon line" and the northern tribes* ### Ask Joel: Hebrew, Judahite and Canaanite (56:54 to 1:01:11) - [56:54](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3414s) **John:** does it make sense to call the language Hebrew? "Sure, we can call it whatever we want," but "there's nowhere in the Bible that actually calls it Hebrew." The only name Baden can think of is "Judahite," used in Jerusalem. Scholars distinguish Judahite Hebrew from northern "Israelian" Hebrew, dialect differences seen in the shibboleth story; his colleague **Gary Rendsburg** has worked on Israelian Hebrew's markers. - [59:04](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3544s) Why not just call it Canaanite? We have nothing we would call Canaanite as such; Ugaritic is "definitely a Canaanite language" but not a Canaanite script, readable from Hebrew, about 500 years apart. - [59:58](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3598s) An Israelite could walk to Moab, Edom, Ammon or Canaan and be understood, "like going from Massachusetts to Alabama" ("What do you mean, y'all?"); Aramaic territory would be "like going from Spain to Portugal." ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t3411.webp]] *Ask Joel: the first listener questions* ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t3640.webp]] *Dialects: "like going from Massachusetts to Alabama"* ### Ask Joel: Moses' Egyptian name (1:01:11 to 1:05:03) - [1:01:11](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3671s) **Jesse:** Moses is an Egyptian name like Ramses or Ramose without the divine element; was that deliberate? "I wish I knew." It is the Egyptian word meaning "son of or born to," as in Ramses and Thutmose ("son of Thoth"); a bare "son of" is odd, though "You find kids named Ben." - [1:02:13](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3733s) Options: a real person whose divine name element was dropped as too Egyptian (as Baal was removed from some names), "a bridge too far" for Baden; a made-up character with a "gestural Egyptian name," odd for an Israelite hero; or a lost figure known to be Egyptian. "I don't know," like asking why Achilles was named that; what matters is that the name is Egyptian, important for the Exodus story. ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t3790.webp]] *Ask Joel: Moses as an Egyptian "son of" name* ### Ask Joel: Jerusalem and Bethel (1:05:03 to 1:09:29) - [1:05:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3903s) **James:** why keep Jerusalem's name if it is named after a Canaanite deity? "They didn't change the names of anything." Jerusalem was a Jebusite city, and every Canaanite city Israel occupied kept its name. Its etymology is uncertain: "Salem" in Genesis 14 (the Melchizedek episode) looks like *shalom*, and *Yerushalayim* has a dual ending that "doesn't make sense." - [1:07:26](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=4046s) A clearer case is Bethel, "house of El," the chief Canaanite deity, almost certainly its name before Israel; the Bible has Jacob (or Abraham) name it, referring to Yahweh, which works because El is also a generic word for God. - [1:08:35](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=4115s) Sign-off: questions to bartehrman.com/askjoel; another episode "coming next week"; new episodes "of silliness, snark, and scholarship on Fridays." ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t3969.webp]] *Ask Joel: Jerusalem and Bethel* ![[images/Joshua-Never-Conquered-Canaan-Heres-What-Really-Happened-t4139.webp]] *End card: subscribe to the Bart Ehrman YouTube channel* ## Key takeaways - The Bible gives two incompatible conquest accounts (Joshua's lightning war and Judges' slow, partial settlement); scholars think neither happened. - The patriarchal and Exodus origin stories were once separate traditions, later fused, partly through the Joseph story. - Archaeology undid the conquest model: Jericho and Ai were already ruins at the biblical date. - Finkelstein's survey shows Israel emerging in small 12th-century hill-country villages whose material culture is essentially Canaanite. - The Late Bronze Age collapse and Philistine pressure plausibly pushed Canaanites into the hills, where separation produced a new identity. - That explains the Bible's warnings about Baal (backsliding, not temptation), its denial of Canaanite and Egyptian kinship, and a united Israel that was a late creation, not an original unity. ## Claims check | Claim | Verdict | Notes | |---|---|---| | Joshua has a swift total conquest; Judges a slow, partial one with Jerusalem left in Canaanite hands ([0:00](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=0s)) | Accurate | Compare Joshua 10–12 and 21:43–45 with Judges 1. Judges 1:21 says Benjamin did not drive out the Jebusites of Jerusalem, though Judges 1:8 says Judah burned it, and Joshua 15:63 also admits Jerusalem was not taken. | | Joshua says Jerusalem was conquered, Judges says it wasn't (Kraege, [51:32](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3092s)) | Oversimplified | Joshua 10 defeats Jerusalem's king but Joshua 15:63 says the Jebusites stayed; Judges 1 has it both ways (1:8 vs 1:21). | | At the burning bush God explains the ancestors knew him under another name (Kraege, [7:27](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=447s)) | Partly accurate | At the bush God is "the God of your father... of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob" (Exodus 3:6, 3:13–15); the explicit statement that the patriarchs knew him as El Shaddai, not Yahweh, is Exodus 6:2–3. | | Prophetic texts locate Israel's origin in the wilderness or Egypt ([6:24](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=384s)) | Accurate | E.g. Hosea 9:10 ("Like grapes in the wilderness, I found Israel") and Hosea 12:9 / 13:4 ("I am the LORD your God from the land of Egypt"). Baden does not cite chapter and verse. | | Merneptah's inscription around 1200 BCE is the first mention of Israel, marked as a people ([14:54](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=894s)) | Accurate | The Merneptah Stele (c. 1208 BCE) uses the determinative for a people rather than a land or city. Debated earlier readings (e.g. a Berlin pedestal relief) are not widely accepted. | | Kathleen Kenyon showed Jericho was unoccupied at the biblical date; Baden says "in the 1960s" ([18:28](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1108s)) | Mostly accurate | Kenyon excavated Jericho in 1952–58 and published through the 1950s–80s; she overturned John Garstang's 1930s dating of a destruction layer to Joshua's time. | | Ai means "ruin" and was a ruin at the time ([19:25](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1165s)) | Accurate | *Ha-ʿAi* means "the ruin"; excavations at et-Tell show it abandoned from the Early Bronze Age until a small Iron I village. | | Peaceful-infiltration and peasant-revolt models lacked evidence ([21:05](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1265s)) | Fair summary | Associated with Albrecht Alt (infiltration) and George Mendenhall / Norman Gottwald (revolt, 1960s–70s); none is named in the video. | | Finkelstein's survey revolutionised the picture "in the '90s" ([22:59](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1379s)) | Roughly accurate | Finkelstein's *The Archaeology of the Israelite Settlement* appeared in 1988, with further surveys in the 1990s; it documented roughly 250 Iron I hill-country sites. | | Early Israelite villages are culturally almost indistinguishable from Canaanite ones ([29:33](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=1773s)) | Accurate / mainstream | The four-room house and collared-rim jars were once proposed as Israelite markers but also appear elsewhere; the absence of pig bones is the marker most often cited. | | The Philistines were a result, not a cause, of the Late Bronze Age collapse ([33:47](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2027s)) | Mainstream view | The Sea Peoples, including the Peleset (Philistines), appear in Ramesses III's records around 1177 BCE; most scholars see them as both symptom and agent of the wider collapse. | | Hill farming relied on cisterns and terracing ([35:09](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2109s)) | Accurate | A standard part of the settlement picture, though the dating of the earliest terraces is debated. | | Israelites stopped eating shellfish because it spoiled on the way to the hills ([36:56](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2216s)) | Speculative | Baden presents it as his illustration; the biblical ban is in Leviticus 11:9–12 and Deuteronomy 14:9–10. | | An Ashkelon calf statue is linked to Baal ([41:17](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2477s)) | Accurate | The silver-plated bronze calf found at Ashkelon in 1990 (c. 1550 BCE) is usually linked to Baal or El. | | "The lady doth protest too much" ([47:42](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=2862s)) | Accurate quote | Shakespeare, *Hamlet* (Act 3, scene 2); not named in the video. | | None of the Judges stories is set in Judah (Kraege, [53:30](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3210s)) | Mostly accurate | Othniel (Judges 3:9–11) is a Judahite exception, and some Samson stories touch Judah. | | The shibboleth story shows north/south dialect differences ([52:39](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3159s)) | Partly accurate | Judges 12:6 contrasts Gileadites east of the Jordan with Ephraimites, so it is east/west rather than Israel/Judah, though it does show a dialect split. | | The Bible never calls the language "Hebrew"; it calls it "Judahite" ([57:41](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3461s)) | Accurate | *Yehudit* in 2 Kings 18:26, Isaiah 36:11 and Nehemiah 13:24; Isaiah 19:18 also speaks of "the language of Canaan." "Hebrew" for the language first appears in the Greek prologue to Sirach. | | Ugaritic is a Canaanite language but not a Canaanite script ([59:26](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3566s)) | Debated | Ugaritic uses an alphabetic cuneiform script; many linguists classify it as Northwest Semitic but separate from Canaanite proper. | | Moses is an Egyptian "son of / born of" name, as in Ramses and Thutmose ([1:01:11](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3671s)) | Accurate / widely held | Egyptian *ms(i)*, "born of," as in Ra-mes-su and Djehuti-mose; Exodus 2:10 gives a Hebrew folk etymology instead. | | Jerusalem is called Salem in Genesis 14, and its name may honour a Canaanite deity ([1:05:03](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=3903s)) | Accurate | Genesis 14:18; the name appears as Urusalim in the Amarna letters, often explained as "foundation of (the god) Shalim," though this is debated. | | Bethel means "house of El" and predates Israel ([1:07:26](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gKQOPMAspoU&t=4046s)) | Accurate | Genesis 28:19 has Jacob rename Luz as Bethel; Genesis 12:8 has Abraham camp near Bethel. | ## Things mentioned ### Books and texts - Biblical books and passages: Numbers, Joshua (Jericho and Ai) and Judges (the two conquest accounts); Genesis (Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, the Joseph story; Genesis 14, Salem and Melchizedek; Jacob naming Bethel); Exodus (the burning bush); the Pentateuch; Joshua through Kings; the prophetic books (the "I found you in the wilderness" tradition); the Shema; the shibboleth story (Judges 12) - The Merneptah inscription (Pharaoh Merneptah's victory text, c. 1200 BCE; "Merneptah Stele" not named) - Canaanite and Ugaritic texts (the Canaanite pantheon) - *The Odyssey*: the recent film (apparently Christopher Nolan's 2026 film; not named), and by extension Homer's epic - *Hamlet*, William Shakespeare ("the lady doth protest too much"; not named) - Israel Finkelstein's survey of early Iron Age settlement (published as *The Archaeology of the Israelite Settlement*, 1988; the book is not named) - Kathleen Kenyon's Jericho excavations (her books, e.g. *Digging Up Jericho*, are not named) - Gary Rendsburg's work on Israelian Hebrew (e.g. *Israelian Hebrew in the Book of Kings*; not named) ### Courses, people and other - *The Bible by Committee: How the Pentateuch Was Really Written*, Joel Baden's course (bartehrman.com/pentateuch) - Scholarly models: the conquest model, peaceful infiltration, the Marxist peasant-revolt model; the Late Bronze Age collapse; the Sea Peoples and Philistines - Places: Jericho, Ai, Ashkelon (calf statue), the central hill country (Ephraim, Manasseh, Benjamin), Judah, Jerusalem (Jebusite city), Bethel, Moab, Edom, Ammon, Ugarit - Deities: Yahweh, Baal, El, Thoth - Allusions: ancestry.com; British colonists becoming American; Ramses, Ramose, Thutmose; Achilles; "till Elijah returns" - Earlier episodes referenced: the Shema and David episodes; promised future episodes on the Exodus, Baal and Yahweh, and the Sea Peoples ## Biographies - **Joel S. Baden**: Hebrew Bible scholar and professor at Yale Divinity School, a leading defender of the Documentary Hypothesis (the "neo-documentarian" approach). Books include *J, E, and the Redaction of the Pentateuch*, *The Composition of the Pentateuch*, *The Historical David* and *The Book of Exodus: A Biography*. He co-hosts *Misquoting Moses* on the Bart D. Ehrman channel, and says here that he once excavated at Ashkelon. - **Megan Kraege**: member of the Bart Ehrman team and host of *Misquoting Moses*. - **Israel Finkelstein**: Israeli archaeologist (Tel Aviv University), known for his regional surveys of early Israelite settlement and the "low chronology"; co-author with Neil Asher Silberman of *The Bible Unearthed*. - **Kathleen Kenyon** (1906–1978): British archaeologist whose 1952–58 excavations at Jericho redated its destruction layers well before any Israelite conquest. - **Gary A. Rendsburg**: Hebrew Bible and Semitic languages scholar at Rutgers University, known for work on northern ("Israelian") Hebrew; Baden calls him a colleague. - **Bart D. Ehrman**: New Testament scholar who retired from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill; his channel hosts the show. He does not appear in this episode.