# Working in Public
*Nadia Eghbal's study of how open source software is actually made and kept alive in the GitHub era. Her argument is that the picture of open source as a big, many-handed collaboration is out of date. Most widely used projects are run by one or a few maintainers who face a crowd of users and casual contributors. Their scarce resource is attention, not code or money. She sorts projects into four types (federations, clubs, toys, stadiums), separates the cheap act of creating code from the ongoing cost of maintaining it, and ends by applying the lessons to online creators in general. Stripe Press published it on 4 August 2020. The author now publishes as Nadia Asparouhova.*
> **What I read.** I did **not** read the printed book, the ebook or the audiobook. There is no legal free full text (see section 2). Here is what I did read. **(1)** The publisher's description and the **contents list** (Introduction; Part 1 "How People Make", chapters 01–03; Part 2 "How People Maintain", chapters 04–05; Conclusion; Credits; Notes), as given in a retailer's publisher-supplied record ([Ex Libris](https://www.exlibris.ch/de/buecher-buch/english-books/nadia-asparouhova/working-in-public/id/9780578675862/)) and confirmed by two reviews. **(2)** Mark Nagelberg's detailed reading notes, which give the **section headings inside each chapter** with Kindle locations and quote the text ([Nagelberg](https://www.marknagelberg.com/roam-notes-on-working-in-public-by-nadia-eghbal/)). **(3)** Other readers' chapter notes and reviews (Shingai, Julian Elve, Opensource.com, Louis-Philippe Véronneau, Will Vincent). **(4)** The author's own earlier essays and data that the book grows out of, including *Roads and Bridges* (2016) and "The rise of few-maintainer projects" (2019). **(5)** Retailer, library and catalog records, and the author's launch interviews. Quotations from the book are given only where a named source prints them, and are marked with that source, for example "(Kindle loc. 134, via Nagelberg)". Kindle locations are the note-taker's, not page numbers. The section headings below come from Nagelberg's notes, and I could not check them against a copy.
Related in this vault:
- Publisher folder: [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/Stripe Press|Stripe Press]]. This is the ninth Stripe Press book by release date, after [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/High Growth Handbook - Elad Gil|High Growth Handbook]], [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/The Dream Machine - M. Mitchell Waldrop|The Dream Machine]], [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/Stubborn Attachments - Tyler Cowen|Stubborn Attachments]], [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/The Revolt of the Public and the Crisis of Authority in the New Millennium - Martin Gurri|The Revolt of the Public]], [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/An Elegant Puzzle - Will Larson|An Elegant Puzzle]], [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/Get Together - Bailey Richardson, Kevin Huynh, and Kai Elmer Sotto|Get Together]], [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/The Making of Prince of Persia - Jordan Mechner|The Making of Prince of Persia]] and [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/The Art of Doing Science and Engineering - Richard W. Hamming|The Art of Doing Science and Engineering]].
- Closest companions in the vault: [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/Get Together - Bailey Richardson, Kevin Huynh, and Kai Elmer Sotto|Get Together]], another Stripe Press book about how communities form and grow, which this book complicates: Eghbal argues that many successful projects are not communities at all. [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/The Revolt of the Public and the Crisis of Authority in the New Millennium - Martin Gurri|The Revolt of the Public]] covers the same platform-driven shift toward networked individuals from the political side.
- Next in the Stripe Press queue: Donald W. Braben's *Scientific Freedom* (#366, Stripe Press 2020). Stewart Brand's *Maintenance: Of Everything, Part One* (#375) comes back to maintenance as a theme.
## 1. Book facts
| | |
|---|---|
| Title | *Working in Public: The Making and Maintenance of Open Source Software* |
| Author | Nadia Eghbal, now **Nadia Asparouhova**. Her site says: "I changed my last name; you can also find my work under Nadia Eghbal" ([nadia.xyz](https://nadia.xyz/)). Amazon, OverDrive, Open Library and Barnes & Noble now list the book under Asparouhova. The 2020 first printing, the Stripe Press catalog and this vault's queue use Eghbal |
| Publisher | Stripe Press. Ex Libris lists the publisher as Stripe Matter, Inc. ([Stripe Press](https://press.stripe.com/working-in-public); [Ex Libris](https://www.exlibris.ch/de/buecher-buch/english-books/nadia-asparouhova/working-in-public/id/9780578675862/)) |
| Hardcover | Publication date **4 August 2020**, 256 pages, ISBN 978-0578675862 / 0578675862. List price $22 ([Stripe Press catalog data](https://stripe.press/catalog.json); [Open Library OL28341888M](https://openlibrary.org/books/OL28341888M)). Amazon's Kindle page showed the hardcover at $17.43 against a $22.00 print list price on 2026-11-20 ([Amazon Kindle](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08BDGXVK9)). Amazon's hardcover page returned a captcha to my box |
| Release-date note | Amazon (Kindle), OverDrive and Open Library give 4 August 2020. The a16z launch episode of 1 August 2020 calls the book "coming out just this week" ([a16z](https://a16z.com/podcast/a16z-podcast-working-making-creating-in-public-and-private/)). The author's own open-source page lists it as "July 14, 2020" ([nadia.xyz/open-source](https://nadia.xyz/open-source)). That is the same day and month as *Roads and Bridges* (14 July 2016), so it is probably a copying slip. I use 4 August |
| Ebook | Kindle ASIN B08BDGXVK9, 4 August 2020, 256 pages print length, $12.99 on 2026-11-20 ([Amazon Kindle](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08BDGXVK9)). Ebook ISBN 9781953953308 per Open Library ([work OL20919943W](https://openlibrary.org/works/OL20919943W)) |
| Audiobook | Unabridged, read by **Tara Oakes**, 7 h 35 min, released **9 October 2020**. Audible showed 4.4 stars from 70 ratings on 2026-11-20 ([Audible B08KWQ1G7X](https://www.audible.com/pd/Working-in-Public-Audiobook/B08KWQ1G7X); [Amazon audiobook B08KWR85F8](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08KWR85F8)) |
| Ratings | Amazon showed 4.5/5 from 417 ratings (formats combined) on 2026-11-20 ([Amazon Kindle](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08BDGXVK9)) |
| Library data | Open Library work [OL20919943W](https://openlibrary.org/works/OL20919943W) (hardcover [OL28341888M](https://openlibrary.org/books/OL28341888M)); Google Books [EKeUzQEACAAJ](https://books.google.com/books?id=EKeUzQEACAAJ); OverDrive title 6144966. I found no OCLC number: WorldCat search returns nothing usable to my box, and the Google Books API was over quota (429) |
| Where it came up | Stripe Press catalog, added at Marshall's request on 2026-11-13 (relayed by Obsidian Author). Queue #365 |
## 2. Book resources
**Free (legal).**
- **No legal free full text of the book.** Stripe Press and the author have not posted it. Open Library marks the work "no ebook", and I found no Internet Archive copy, checked 2026-11-20. Sites offering a "free PDF" of *Working in Public* are either unauthorized copies or paid summary services (for example Bookey). They are not linked here.
- **The author's earlier report, *Roads and Bridges: The Unseen Labor Behind Our Digital Infrastructure*** (Ford Foundation, 14 July 2016), is free from the publisher. It is the book's predecessor and covers the funding side ([Ford Foundation page](https://www.fordfoundation.org/learning/library/research-reports/roads-and-bridges-the-unseen-labor-behind-our-digital-infrastructure/); [PDF](https://www.fordfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/roads-and-bridges-the-unseen-labor-behind-our-digital-infrastructure.pdf)).
- **"The rise of few-maintainer projects,"** *Increment*, May 2019 issue, is a free early statement of the book's central claim about solo and few-maintainer projects ([Increment](https://increment.com/open-source/the-rise-of-few-maintainer-projects/)).
- **Free working essays behind particular chapters**, on the author's site: "Understanding user support systems in open source" (27 September 2018), "Methodologies for measuring project health" (18 July 2018), "An alternate ending to the tragedy of the commons" (3 May 2018), "Governance without foundations" (31 October 2018), "Making money with licenses" (14 March 2019) and "The Twitch argument for GitHub Sponsors" (24 May 2019). All are listed on [nadia.xyz/open-source](https://nadia.xyz/open-source). Her data sets are on GitHub, for example [user-support](https://github.com/nayafia/user-support).
- **Talks and podcasts** (section 4) are free.
**Where to get it.**
- **Publisher:** [Stripe Press](https://press.stripe.com/working-in-public) ($22 hardcover; the catalog links to Amazon, Bookshop and Barnes & Noble).
- **Amazon print:** [hardcover, 0578675862](https://www.amazon.com/dp/0578675862/), Stripe Press, 4 August 2020, 256 pp. $17.43 on 2026-11-20 (from the format panel on the Kindle page). I found no paperback.
- **Kindle:** [B08BDGXVK9](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08BDGXVK9), $12.99 on 2026-11-20.
- **Audible:** available, read by Tara Oakes, 7 h 35 min, unabridged, released 9 October 2020 ([Audible B08KWQ1G7X](https://www.audible.com/pd/Working-in-Public-Audiobook/B08KWQ1G7X); [Amazon audiobook B08KWR85F8](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08KWR85F8)).
- **Other retailers:** [Bookshop.org](https://bookshop.org/books/working-in-public-the-making-and-maintenance-of-open-source-software/9780578675862); [Barnes & Noble](https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/working-in-public-nadia-asparouhova/1147501336?ean=9780578675862) (both links from the Stripe Press catalog; not opened from my box).
- **Libby/OverDrive:** **ebook available** (OverDrive title 6144966, Stripe Press, listed under "Nadia Asparouhova"). On 2026-11-20 Los Angeles Public Library had 2 copies (1 available) and New York Public Library had 1 (0 available) ([LAPL search](https://lapl.overdrive.com/search?query=working+in+public); [NYPL search](https://nypl.overdrive.com/search?query=working+in+public)). San Francisco and Chicago public libraries returned no copy. I found no OverDrive audiobook. Search under "Asparouhova": a search for "Eghbal" returned nothing.
- **Hoopla:** not checked reliably. Its search needs JavaScript and returned nothing usable to my box.
- **Internet Archive lending / Open Library borrow:** none. Open Library has the work but no borrowable copy (2026-11-20).
- **Project Gutenberg:** not applicable (in copyright, 2020).
**Catalog records.** [Open Library](https://openlibrary.org/works/OL20919943W); [Google Books](https://books.google.com/books?id=EKeUzQEACAAJ); [WorldCat search](https://search.worldcat.org/search?q=bn:9780578675862) (no OCLC number confirmed); [Goodreads search](https://www.goodreads.com/search?q=9780578675862).
**Cover:** [Open Library cover image](https://covers.openlibrary.org/b/id/10290182-L.jpg).
## 3. Author biography
**Before open source.** Nadia Eghbal studied at Tufts University. Protocol Labs' author page lists a BS in political science and environmental sciences from Tufts, and also lists the University of Tübingen ([Protocol Labs Research](https://research.protocol.ai/authors/nadia-eghbal/index.html)). She worked in venture capital at Collaborative Fund and left in May 2015. In her words, she then set out to answer "What is not venture backable in tech right now?" and later sharpened it to what tech "absolutely cannot do without". Open source infrastructure was the one category that survived ([Medium, 13 Jan 2016](https://medium.com/@nayafia/how-i-stumbled-upon-the-internet-s-biggest-blind-spot-b9aa23618c58)).
**Open source research (2015–2020).** With Ford Foundation support she wrote *Roads and Bridges: The Unseen Labor Behind Our Digital Infrastructure* (14 July 2016), which argued that open source code is public infrastructure that needs maintenance. She co-hosted the *Request for Commits* podcast with Changelog (2016–2018). At GitHub (about 2016–2018) she worked on the open source developer experience, the Open Source Guides (launched 14 February 2017) and the 2017 Open Source Survey. She then did a year of independent research on the production and economics of open source at Protocol Labs, which is where she wrote most of this book ([nadia.xyz/open-source](https://nadia.xyz/open-source); [Perell podcast notes](https://perell.com/podcast/nadia-eghbal-open-source-software/); [a16z](https://a16z.com/podcast/a16z-podcast-working-making-creating-in-public-and-private/)). The year ranges for GitHub and Protocol Labs come from a LinkedIn profile summary shown in search results, so treat them as approximate.
**Substack and after.** Substack announced on 8 January 2020 that she had "joined our team to help writers flourish", in charge of its writer-success work ([On Substack, 8 Jan 2020](https://on.substack.com/p/supporting-writers-on-substack)). A LinkedIn profile summary in search results says she joined as Substack's second employee. That is unverified. She also ran Helium Grants, a microgrant program for individuals ($1K–$5K), for two years ([nadia.xyz/projects](https://nadia.xyz/projects)). Later research, funded by Emergent Ventures, Schmidt Futures, the Ethereum Foundation (Summer of Protocols) and others, covered tech culture and philanthropy, "idea machines", and advanced meditation (the jhanas). Under her new surname she published *Antimemetics: Why Some Ideas Resist Spreading* (Dark Forest Collective, 2025; ISBN 979-8-9929364-0-7) ([nadia.xyz](https://nadia.xyz/); [Google Books](https://books.google.com/books/about/Antimemetics.html?id=tEE80QEACAAJ)). Her site now says "I currently work at Asterisk" (*Asterisk* magazine) ([nadia.xyz](https://nadia.xyz/)). She writes a Substack newsletter ([nayafia.substack.com](https://nayafia.substack.com/)) and posts as @nayafia.
**Name.** She has changed her last name from Eghbal to Asparouhova. A 15 April 2022 newsletter already calls her "Nadia Asparouhova (formerly Nadia Eghbal)" ([Kat's Kable #268](https://vishalkatariya.com/katskable/268)). I have not found a public statement of the exact date. She has no Wikipedia article (searched 2026-11-20).
## 4. Author interviews and talks
**About the book (2020 launch)**
- **a16z Podcast, "Working, Making, Creating in Public… and Private" (1 August 2020).** Book-launch episode with Sonal Chokshi on community types, stadiums and the "dark forest" internet; transcript online ([a16z](https://a16z.com/podcast/a16z-podcast-working-making-creating-in-public-and-private/)).
- **The Changelog #408, "Working in Public" (12 August 2020).** With Adam Stacoviak and Jerod Santo, the show that produced her *Request for Commits* podcast; transcript online ([Changelog](https://changelog.com/podcast/408)).
- **New Books Network (12 August 2020).** Interview hosted by Matthew Jordan ([New Books Network](https://newbooksnetwork.com/nadia-eghbal-working-in-public-the-making-and-maintenance-of-open-source-software-stripe-press-2020)).
- **Hanselminutes #749, "Working in Public: Open Source Software with Nadia Eghbal" (13 August 2020)**, with transcript ([Hanselminutes](https://hanselminutes.com/749/working-in-public-open-source-software-with-nadia-eghbal)).
- **David Perell, *North Star* podcast, "Nadia Eghbal: Open-Source Software" (2020).** Covers zero marginal cost, GitHub versus social media, the bystander effect, and why she wrote a book instead of doing a PhD ([Perell](https://perell.com/podcast/nadia-eghbal-open-source-software/)).
- **Sustain Episode 51 (28 August 2020).** Covers the book and *Roads and Bridges* ([Sustain](https://podcast.sustainoss.org/51)).
**Earlier talks the book builds on**
- **"Consider the maintainer," linux.conf.au keynote (24 January 2017)** ([video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2AR1owg0ao); [slides](https://www.slideshare.net/NadiaEghbal/consider-the-maintainer)).
- **"Rebuilding the cathedral," Strange Loop (30 September 2017)** ([video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VS6IpvTWwkQ); [slides](https://www.slideshare.net/NadiaEghbal/rebuilding-the-cathedral)).
- **"Where money meets open source," JupyterCon (25 August 2017)** ([video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bjAinwgvQqc)).
- **"Funding open source, the hard way," Django Under the Hood (4 November 2016)** ([video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HokXBjDS_UA)).
- ***Request for Commits*** podcast, two seasons (4 August 2016–21 March 2018), produced by Changelog ([Changelog RFC](https://changelog.com/rfc)).
## 5. Summary
**Thesis.** Our mental model of open source as a big, cooperative, participatory community no longer describes how most widely used code is made. Modern open source, shaped by GitHub, is increasingly the work of one or a few maintainers watched by a large audience. The maintainers' job has become curation: "The problem facing maintainers today is not how to get more contributors but how to manage a high volume of frequent, low-touch interactions. These developers aren't building communities; they're directing air traffic" (Kindle loc. 134, via Nagelberg). Code that is already published behaves like a public good. *Producing* it behaves like a commons in which the depletable resource is the maintainer's attention. Software is not free to keep alive. Its maintenance costs rise with users and with time. And because creators, not communities, are becoming the centers of online life, open source is a model for understanding online creators in general (publisher description; [Nagelberg](https://www.marknagelberg.com/roam-notes-on-working-in-public-by-nadia-eghbal/); [Elve](https://www.synesthesia.co.uk/2020/08/14/notes-on-eghbal-working-in-public/)). The book also changes her earlier, funding-first framing. As Véronneau quotes it: "Only when we understand the underlying behavioral dynamics of open source today, and how it differs from its early origins, can we figure out where money fits in" (p. 184, via [Véronneau](https://veronneau.org/book-review-working-in-public-by-nadia-eghbal.html)).
**Outline.** Part and chapter titles are from the publisher-supplied contents. Section headings inside chapters are from Nagelberg's reading notes, with his Kindle locations. No page numbers were available to me.
**Introduction.** Open source is usually imagined as built by large communities, but most projects rely on a few maintainers. She cites a study of 275 popular GitHub projects in which nearly half of all contributors contributed only once, and accounted for under 2% of commits. Code is trending toward modularity: "a mille-feuille layer cake of little libraries instead of one big, jiggling Jell-O mold" (loc. 114, via Nagelberg). The maintainer's role is becoming curation. In the late 1990s open source was the "poster child" for hopeful "peer production" (loc. 180, via Nagelberg).
**Part 1: How People Make**
1. **01 GitHub as a Platform.** Sections: *The Liberation of Code* (tarballs and mailing lists, then distributed version control. Stallman, Raymond and Torvalds as the founding figures; Linux 1991, Git 2005). *The Triumph of Convenience* (SourceForge, founded 1999, as "the MySpace of code-hosting platforms". GitHub's spread of permissive licenses such as MIT over the free software movement's copyleft. Platforms give creators distribution). *From Hackers to Huskies* (developers known for who they are rather than one project, especially in JavaScript). *The GitHub Generation* (newer developers treat open source as a convenient way to make things rather than an ideology).
2. **02 The Structure of an Open Source Project.** *How Contributions Are Made* (patches and pull requests, commit access, RFC processes; reputation and complexity affect what gets merged). *Where Interactions Take Place* (repository versus project; issues and pull requests are hard to move off GitHub). *How Projects Change Over Time* (creation, then evangelism, then growth. At the growth stage a project either closes up again or distributes the work). *Classifying Project Types*. Four factors (technical scope, support required, ease of participation, user adoption) set the ratio of contributors to users, which gives four types. **Federations**: high contributor growth, high user growth (e.g. Rust, Node.js, Linux). **Clubs**: high contributors, low users. **Toys**: low and low. **Stadiums**: few contributors, many users (e.g. webpack, Babel).
3. **03 Roles, Incentives, and Relationships.** *A Theory of the Commons* (Elinor Ostrom's design principles for well-run commons). *Why We Participate in the Commons* (Yochai Benkler's "commons-based peer production" from "Coase's Penguin" (2002), which needs intrinsic motivation, modular and granular tasks, and low coordination costs. Federations and clubs mainly face coordination problems; stadiums mainly face curation problems). *How Platforms Broke Apart the Commons* (open projects have no membership boundaries: "Countries have citizenships and constituencies, but open source projects are open to anyone", loc. 1235). *The Role of a Maintainer* (maintainers are the bottleneck; they need curators as well as creators; their exits are to manage, to delegate, or to step down or disappear; unlike a book, a project is never "finished"). *Active and Casual Contributors* (casual contributors are "like tourists visiting New York City for a weekend", loc. 1569). *Active and Passive Users*. *Assessing the Health of a Project* (popularity, being depended upon, and activity; the "bus factor"; contributor counts mislead for stadiums).
**Part 2: How People Maintain**
4. **04 The Work Required by Software.** *Code as Artifact, Code as Organism* (software must change as its environment changes. She cites Google engineer Fergus Henderson that "most software at Google gets rewritten every few years". Maintenance cost is one reason large projects become modular. Forking is rarely a real exit). *The Hidden Costs of Software* (creation, distribution and maintenance. She cites a 2018 Stripe study that developers spend 42% of their time maintaining code. **Marginal** maintenance costs grow with users: infrastructure, tools, user support, moderation. Software is not perfectly non-rivalrous. **Temporal** costs come from entropy: technical debt, test infrastructure, dependencies, adapting to users). *Measuring the Value of Code*: *Dependencies* (value depends on how widely code is used and how easy it is to replace) and *Reputation*.
5. **05 Managing the Costs of Production.** She considers whether government should provide open source as a public good and argues it is poorly suited (code is transnational and moves fast), using the 1990s fights over cryptography and PGP as an example. Her Christmas-lights image: the problem arises only "if we think our neighbor owes us anything" (loc. 2535). *Production as a One-Way Mirror* (consumption of code is a public good; production is a commons of attention. Design for the "parasocial, or one-sided" relationships of stadiums. Avoid **extractive contributions**, whose cost to review exceeds their benefit). *Managing Producer Attention*: reduce up-front costs (CI, bots, linters, issue templates. "Among the top hundred projects on GitHub by issue volume in 2018, 93% of projects used issue templates", loc. 2806); limit available attention (Philip Guo's "n=1" approach; tiered attention as used by Homebrew's Mike McQuaid); distribute costs to user-to-user systems; increase available attention. *The Role of Money in Open Source*: *Who Funds Open Source Developers, and Why* (companies buy a line to maintainers and brand association; individuals sponsor people they admire, as patrons rather than donors) and *Where the Money Goes* (don't pay casual contributors. Bounties suit well-scoped tasks. Funding individuals can avoid project-governance problems, but organizations find it harder).
**Conclusion.** The value of platforms lies in their social graph: "we're starting to treat content not as a private economic good but as the externalization of our social infrastructure" (loc. 3402). She applies the book to other online creators through two problems. *Managing over-participation*: hiding or muting interactions, and recruiting curators. *Making money*: paywalls sell access to community rather than content, "more like the ticket kiosk at a theme park than a price tag on a car" (loc. 3573). Micropayments create decision fatigue. Patronage and subscriptions tie support to creators rather than content (all via Nagelberg).
**Key ideas.**
- **Federations, clubs, toys and stadiums.** A two-by-two of contributor growth against user growth. Much important infrastructure is a stadium: few makers, huge audience.
- **Attention is the scarce resource.** Published code is a public good (non-rivalrous, non-excludable). Its production is a commons in which contributions "appropriate this attention from the commons" ([Elve](https://www.synesthesia.co.uk/2020/08/14/notes-on-eghbal-working-in-public/)).
- **Extractive versus non-extractive contributions.** Many well-meant issues, questions and pull requests cost a maintainer more than they give.
- **Software has real marginal and temporal costs.** "Zero marginal cost" holds only for static code.
- **The one-way mirror.** Successful creators (coders, streamers, writers) increasingly let anyone watch but limit who can interact.
- **From projects to people.** GitHub and social platforms move identity and reputation from communities to individuals, and funding follows people (patronage, sponsorships) more than projects.
- **Money comes after understanding.** Funding alone will not fix the sustainability problem without understanding the behavioral dynamics first (p. 184, via Véronneau).
**Reception.** Reviewers in open source praised it as the clearest account of how GitHub-era open source works. Opensource.com recommended it to "maintainer, contributor, or user", with the caveat that it over-explains basics for experienced readers ([Opensource.com](https://opensource.com/article/20/11/working-public-review)). Debian developer Louis-Philippe Véronneau saw a selection bias toward GitHub, Ruby and JavaScript projects, though the book "broke my Free Software echo chamber" ([Véronneau](https://veronneau.org/book-review-working-in-public-by-nadia-eghbal.html)). Will Vincent called it "a rewarding read" and the first book on the subject since Karl Fogel's *Producing Open Source Software* (2005) ([Vincent](https://wsvincent.com/working-in-public-book-review/)). Elve noted there is "no magic bullet … about open source funding" ([Elve](https://www.synesthesia.co.uk/2020/08/14/notes-on-eghbal-working-in-public/)). a Sustain co-host ("Eric" in the show notes) called it the "Open Source Bible" ([Sustain](https://podcast.sustainoss.org/51)).
## 6. Fact-check
These checks rely on the publisher, catalog records, readers' notes that quote the book, and the primary sources the book cites. I did not read the book's text or its endnotes, so where a claim is known only through a reader's paraphrase, I say so.
| Claim | Verdict | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Published by Stripe Press on 4 August 2020; ISBN 9780578675862; 256 pp. | Supported | [Amazon Kindle](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08BDGXVK9) (4 Aug 2020, 256 pp.); [Open Library OL28341888M](https://openlibrary.org/books/OL28341888M); [Stripe Press catalog data](https://stripe.press/catalog.json); OverDrive record dated 2020-08-04 |
| Author's own listing of the book as "July 14, 2020" | Disputed | Every retailer and catalog gives 4 Aug 2020, and the a16z launch episode (1 Aug 2020) says "coming out just this week" ([nadia.xyz/open-source](https://nadia.xyz/open-source); [a16z](https://a16z.com/podcast/a16z-podcast-working-making-creating-in-public-and-private/)) |
| A study of 275 popular GitHub projects found nearly half of contributors contributed only once, accounting for under 2% of commits | Supported | Pinto, Steinmacher and Gerosa, SANER 2016: 275 projects; 48.98% of contributors made a single commit, together 1.73% of commits ([DOI](https://doi.org/10.1109/saner.2016.68); [PDF](https://gustavopinto.org/lost+found/saner2016.pdf)). A 2020 replication using pull requests instead of commits found 66% casual contributors with 12.5% of accepted contributions ([DOI](https://doi.org/10.1109/saner48275.2020.9054855)), so the share depends on how contributions are counted |
| "A 2015 company blog post claimed that 45% of open source projects use [the MIT license]" | Supported, with a caveat | GitHub's March 2015 post: MIT used by 44.69% of *licensed* public, non-forked repositories ([GitHub blog](https://github.blog/open-source/open-source-license-usage-on-github-com/)). Most repositories had no license at all, so "45% of open source projects" slightly overstates the base |
| "A 2018 Stripe study … suggested that developers spend 42% of their time maintaining code" | Supported | Stripe, *The Developer Coefficient* (2018): 17.3 of a 41.1-hour week on maintenance, about 42% ([Stripe PDF](https://stripe.com/files/reports/the-developer-coefficient.pdf)) |
| SourceForge was founded in 1999; Torvalds created Linux in 1991 and Git in 2005 | Supported | Standard history (SourceForge launched November 1999; Linux announced August 1991; Git April 2005) |
| Fergus Henderson: "most software at Google gets rewritten every few years" | Supported | Henderson, "Software Engineering at Google" (2017), says this ([arXiv 1702.01715](https://arxiv.org/abs/1702.01715)) |
| Ostrom's design principles and Benkler's "Coase's Penguin" (2002) conditions for commons-based peer production | Supported | Ostrom, *Governing the Commons* (1990); Benkler, "Coase's Penguin, or, Linux and *The Nature of the Firm*", *Yale Law Journal* 112 (2002) ([Yale Law Journal](https://www.yalelawjournal.org/article/coases-penguin-or-linux-and-the-nature-of-the-firm)) |
| NSA "changed [DES] to make it weaker so they could break it" | Disputed (wording known only from a reader's paraphrase) | This wording is Nagelberg's summary of the cryptography passage, not a confirmed quotation. The 1978 Senate Intelligence Committee summary found NSA persuaded IBM that a shorter key was adequate, but did not tamper with the design. The S-boxes later proved unusually resistant to differential cryptanalysis ([Senate summary PDF](https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/sites-default-filesations-95nsa.pdf); [Coppersmith 1994, IBM J. R&D](https://doi.org/10.1147/rd.383.0243)). The reduced 56-bit key is the strongest basis for the "weakened" view |
| PGP's source code was exported legally by printing it as a book | Supported | *PGP Source Code and Internals* (Philip Zimmermann, MIT Press, 1995) was published to take advantage of First Amendment protection for printed matter (general history; the book's own account was not checked) |
| "Among the top hundred projects on GitHub by issue volume in 2018, 93% … used issue templates" | Unverified | Comes from the author's own data set ([nayafia/user-support](https://github.com/nayafia/user-support); [essay](https://nadia.xyz/user-support)). I did not recompute it |
| Eghbal "interviewed hundreds of developers" | Unverified | Publisher's description ([Stripe Press catalog data](https://stripe.press/catalog.json)). Plausible given five years of fieldwork and two podcasts, but not documented as a count |
| The book "is only available on Amazon, exclusively in the United States" (Véronneau, Nov 2020) | Outdated | By 2026 it is sold by Bookshop, Barnes & Noble and Swiss retailer Ex Libris, and is in OverDrive library collections |
## 7. Citations and references
**Notable sources the book draws on or points to**
- Nadia Eghbal, *Roads and Bridges: The Unseen Labor Behind Our Digital Infrastructure* (Ford Foundation, 2016) ([PDF](https://www.fordfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/roads-and-bridges-the-unseen-labor-behind-our-digital-infrastructure.pdf))
- Elinor Ostrom, *Governing the Commons: The Evolution of Institutions for Collective Action* (Cambridge University Press, 1990): the commons design principles in chapter 3
- Yochai Benkler, "Coase's Penguin, or, Linux and *The Nature of the Firm*", *Yale Law Journal* 112 (2002) ([Yale Law Journal](https://www.yalelawjournal.org/article/coases-penguin-or-linux-and-the-nature-of-the-firm))
- Eric S. Raymond, "early open source's unofficial anthropologist" in chapter 1 (loc. 260, via Nagelberg), and author of *The Cathedral and the Bazaar* (1997/1999). Her 2017 talk "Rebuilding the cathedral" plays on that title
- Gustavo Pinto, Igor Steinmacher and Marco Aurélio Gerosa, "More Common Than You Think: An In-depth Study of Casual Contributors" (SANER 2016) ([DOI](https://doi.org/10.1109/saner.2016.68))
- Stripe, *The Developer Coefficient* (2018) ([PDF](https://stripe.com/files/reports/the-developer-coefficient.pdf))
- Fergus Henderson, "Software Engineering at Google" (2017) ([arXiv](https://arxiv.org/abs/1702.01715))
- GitHub, "Open source license usage on GitHub.com" (2015) ([GitHub blog](https://github.blog/open-source/open-source-license-usage-on-github-com/))
- Philip Guo's "n=1" approach and Mike McQuaid's tiered maintainer practices (Homebrew), as cited in chapter 5 (via Nagelberg)
- Author's own working essays and data: [nadia.xyz/open-source](https://nadia.xyz/open-source); ["The rise of few-maintainer projects"](https://increment.com/open-source/the-rise-of-few-maintainer-projects/)
**Every link used**
- Publisher and catalog: [Stripe Press book page](https://press.stripe.com/working-in-public); [Stripe Press catalog data](https://stripe.press/catalog.json); [Ex Libris record with contents](https://www.exlibris.ch/de/buecher-buch/english-books/nadia-asparouhova/working-in-public/id/9780578675862/)
- Retail: [Amazon hardcover](https://www.amazon.com/dp/0578675862/); [Amazon Kindle](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08BDGXVK9); [Amazon audiobook](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08KWR85F8); [Audible](https://www.audible.com/pd/Working-in-Public-Audiobook/B08KWQ1G7X); [Bookshop.org](https://bookshop.org/books/working-in-public-the-making-and-maintenance-of-open-source-software/9780578675862); [Barnes & Noble](https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/working-in-public-nadia-asparouhova/1147501336?ean=9780578675862)
- Libraries: [LAPL OverDrive](https://lapl.overdrive.com/search?query=working+in+public); [NYPL OverDrive](https://nypl.overdrive.com/search?query=working+in+public)
- Catalog records: [Open Library work](https://openlibrary.org/works/OL20919943W); [OL28341888M](https://openlibrary.org/books/OL28341888M); [Google Books EKeUzQEACAAJ](https://books.google.com/books?id=EKeUzQEACAAJ); [WorldCat search](https://search.worldcat.org/search?q=bn:9780578675862); [Goodreads search](https://www.goodreads.com/search?q=9780578675862); [cover](https://covers.openlibrary.org/b/id/10290182-L.jpg)
- Author: [nadia.xyz](https://nadia.xyz/); [nadia.xyz/projects](https://nadia.xyz/projects); [nadia.xyz/open-source](https://nadia.xyz/open-source); [nadia.xyz/user-support](https://nadia.xyz/user-support); [Substack newsletter](https://nayafia.substack.com/); [Protocol Labs Research author page](https://research.protocol.ai/authors/nadia-eghbal/index.html); [On Substack announcement](https://on.substack.com/p/supporting-writers-on-substack); ["How I Stumbled Upon the Internet's Biggest Blind Spot"](https://medium.com/@nayafia/how-i-stumbled-upon-the-internet-s-biggest-blind-spot-b9aa23618c58); [Kat's Kable #268](https://vishalkatariya.com/katskable/268); [Antimemetics, Google Books](https://books.google.com/books/about/Antimemetics.html?id=tEE80QEACAAJ); [Ford Foundation report page](https://www.fordfoundation.org/learning/library/research-reports/roads-and-bridges-the-unseen-labor-behind-our-digital-infrastructure/); [Roads and Bridges PDF](https://www.fordfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/roads-and-bridges-the-unseen-labor-behind-our-digital-infrastructure.pdf); [Increment essay](https://increment.com/open-source/the-rise-of-few-maintainer-projects/); [user-support data](https://github.com/nayafia/user-support)
- Interviews and talks: [a16z Podcast](https://a16z.com/podcast/a16z-podcast-working-making-creating-in-public-and-private/); [Changelog #408](https://changelog.com/podcast/408); [New Books Network](https://newbooksnetwork.com/nadia-eghbal-working-in-public-the-making-and-maintenance-of-open-source-software-stripe-press-2020); [Hanselminutes #749](https://hanselminutes.com/749/working-in-public-open-source-software-with-nadia-eghbal); [David Perell](https://perell.com/podcast/nadia-eghbal-open-source-software/); [Sustain #51](https://podcast.sustainoss.org/51); [Consider the maintainer, video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W2AR1owg0ao); [slides](https://www.slideshare.net/NadiaEghbal/consider-the-maintainer); [Rebuilding the cathedral, video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VS6IpvTWwkQ); [slides](https://www.slideshare.net/NadiaEghbal/rebuilding-the-cathedral); [Where money meets open source](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bjAinwgvQqc); [Funding open source, the hard way](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HokXBjDS_UA); [Request for Commits](https://changelog.com/rfc)
- Reader notes and reviews: [Mark Nagelberg's notes](https://www.marknagelberg.com/roam-notes-on-working-in-public-by-nadia-eghbal/); [Shingai's notes](https://shingai.ghost.io/notes-on-working-in-public/); [Julian Elve's notes](https://www.synesthesia.co.uk/2020/08/14/notes-on-eghbal-working-in-public/); [Opensource.com review](https://opensource.com/article/20/11/working-public-review); [Louis-Philippe Véronneau review](https://veronneau.org/book-review-working-in-public-by-nadia-eghbal.html); [Will Vincent review](https://wsvincent.com/working-in-public-book-review/); [I Programmer Book Watch](https://www.i-programmer.info/book-watch-archive/13926-working-in-public-stripe-press.html)
- Fact-check: [Pinto et al. 2016](https://doi.org/10.1109/saner.2016.68); [Pinto et al. PDF](https://gustavopinto.org/lost+found/saner2016.pdf); [2020 replication](https://doi.org/10.1109/saner48275.2020.9054855); [GitHub license usage 2015](https://github.blog/open-source/open-source-license-usage-on-github-com/); [Stripe Developer Coefficient](https://stripe.com/files/reports/the-developer-coefficient.pdf); [Henderson 2017](https://arxiv.org/abs/1702.01715); [Benkler 2002](https://www.yalelawjournal.org/article/coases-penguin-or-linux-and-the-nature-of-the-firm); [Senate DES summary](https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/sites-default-filesations-95nsa.pdf); [Coppersmith 1994](https://doi.org/10.1147/rd.383.0243)