# Stubborn Attachments
*A short book of moral and political philosophy by the economist Tyler Cowen. His claim is that we should "maximize the rate of sustainable economic growth", measured broadly as "Wealth Plus", subject only to near-absolute human rights. Compounding growth swamps almost every other consideration over long enough spans, so it can settle disagreements that usually look unresolvable. He also argues that the distant future deserves nearly as much moral weight as the present, that redistribution should go only as far as it helps growth, and that radical uncertainty about consequences is a reason to think big and respect rights, not a reason to give up. Cowen says he worked on it for about twenty years. Stripe Press published it on 16 October 2018, its third book.*
> **What I read.** I read the whole text in Cowen's own free web edition: the essay he posted on Medium on 25 July 2016 as "'Stubborn Attachments': Full Text", which was later taken down. I read it from the Internet Archive's 30 May 2017 capture ([Wayback](https://web.archive.org/web/20170530204015/https://medium.com/stubborn-attachments/stubborn-attachments-full-text-8fc946b694d)), about 44,000 words including the reference list. Stripe Press published that text in 2018 with light revisions. I did not have the printed book, so I compared the draft with passages quoted from the book in readers' notes ([Derek Sivers](https://sive.rs/book/StubbornAttachments); [Fluidself](https://fluidself.org/books/business/stubborn-attachments)). The wording is nearly identical, but with some fixes and updates. The restitution example now runs to 2018 at 7% and gives "more than $65 million", where the draft's figure was wrong (see section 6). Parfit's chapter is now correctly called "Mistakes in Moral Mathematics", and the roulette-wheel analogy for political certainty became the World Series. Quotations below are from the 2016 web edition unless marked "book". **No page numbers**: I never saw the printed pagination.
Related in this vault:
- Publisher folder: [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/Stripe Press|Stripe Press]]. This is the second book in Stripe Press release order, after [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/High Growth Handbook - Elad Gil|High Growth Handbook]]. Axios's July 2018 story on Stripe's move into publishing already named a Cowen title as "in the pipeline".
- Next in the queue from the same press: *The Revolt of the Public* (Martin Gurri, 2018), which Stripe Press published a month later.
- Philosophical background in this vault: Cowen calls himself a "two-thirds utilitarian". For the classical utilitarian he is half-arguing with, see [[Book Summaries/Bentham, Jeremy/An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation - Jeremy Bentham|Bentham's Principles of Morals and Legislation]]. For a liberty-first contrast, see [[Book Summaries/Mill, John Stuart/On Liberty - John Stuart Mill|Mill's On Liberty]].
## 1. Book facts
| | |
|---|---|
| Title | *Stubborn Attachments: A Vision for a Society of Free, Prosperous, and Responsible Individuals* |
| Author | Tyler Cowen |
| Publisher | Stripe Press, the publishing imprint of Stripe ([Stripe Press](https://press.stripe.com/stubborn-attachments)) |
| Published | 16 October 2018, in hardcover and Kindle ([Amazon hardcover](https://www.amazon.com/dp/1732265135); [Kindle](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07G9DFC8W)). Cowen announced it on 9 August 2018: "I have been working on this book for about twenty years" ([MR](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/08/stubborn-attachments-published-stripe-press.html)) |
| Earlier versions | **25 July 2016:** a free full-text web edition on Medium, signed by Cowen at the Mercatus Center, with PDF downloads ([Wayback](https://web.archive.org/web/20170530204015/https://medium.com/stubborn-attachments/stubborn-attachments-full-text-8fc946b694d)). **Spring 2017:** offered as an "advance peek bonus book" to people who pre-ordered *The Complacent Class* ([MR, 28 Apr 2017](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/04/stubborn-attachments-podcast-ft-alphaville.html)). **July 2017:** discussed on EconTalk as a book "online… at Medium.com" ([EconTalk](https://www.econtalk.org/tyler-cowen-on-stubborn-attachments-prosperity-and-the-good-society/)). The Medium post was later taken down ([Kamdar's notes](https://mbkamdar.github.io/book-notes/cowen-stubborn-attachments/)) |
| ISBNs | Hardcover 978-1-7322651-3-4 (1732265135). Ebook 978-1-953953-35-3, shown on the Kindle listing; Open Library records it as "Stripe Matter Inc, 2018". Kindle ASIN B07G9DFC8W |
| Pages | 160 in hardcover ([Open Library OL35682676M](https://openlibrary.org/books/OL35682676M); Amazon). A public-library catalog record gives "158 pages ; 24 cm", call number 338.9 C8748s 2018, "First edition" ([Smart Library Search record](https://www.smartlibrarysearch.com/book/stubborn-attachments-cowen-tyler-S152C1190336)). Kindle: 161 pages |
| Audiobook | Unabridged, read by Jeremy Arthur, 3 h 32 min, Stripe Press, released 26 September 2018, with an accompanying PDF ([Audible](https://www.audible.com/pd/Stubborn-Attachments-Audiobook/B07HM6YW71)) |
| Royalties | Cowen said he would give all his royalties to an Ethiopian guide who had shown him around Lalibela, whom he called "Yonas [not his real name]", and send the money by Stripe ([MR, 13 Aug 2018](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/08/preface-stubborn-attachments-book-especially-important.html)). As far as I can tell this is the book's printed preface, but I did not check the printed book |
| Library data | Open Library work [OL26422034W](https://openlibrary.org/works/OL26422034W), 3 editions. No LCCN or OCLC number found |
| Blurbs | Cardiff Garcia, Cass R. Sunstein and others ([Stripe Press](https://press.stripe.com/stubborn-attachments)) |
**Where it came up.** On 2026-11-13 Marshall asked for the whole current [Stripe Press catalog](https://press.stripe.com/) to go into the queue (relayed by Obsidian Author). The queue block is in Stripe Press release order, earliest first. This book (Stripe Press edition 16 October 2018) is second, after *High Growth Handbook*. Catalog page: [press.stripe.com/stubborn-attachments](https://press.stripe.com/stubborn-attachments).
## 2. Book resources
**Free (legal).**
- **Cowen's own 2016 web edition (full text):** "'Stubborn Attachments': Full Text", posted by Cowen on Medium on 25 July 2016. The original URL [medium.com/stubborn-attachments/stubborn-attachments-full-text-8fc946b694d](https://medium.com/stubborn-attachments/stubborn-attachments-full-text-8fc946b694d) no longer serves it. The Internet Archive has it: [Wayback capture, 30 May 2017](https://web.archive.org/web/20170530204015/https://medium.com/stubborn-attachments/stubborn-attachments-full-text-8fc946b694d). This is the pre-publication draft, not the edited 2018 book, but it is the same argument, chapter for chapter.
- **Author's companion material:** the book's preface on royalties ([MR](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/08/preface-stubborn-attachments-book-especially-important.html)). The Stanford Arrow Lecture transcript, in which Cowen argues against his own book ([Discourse, 5 Mar 2020](https://www.discoursemagazine.com/p/is-economic-growth-a-moral-imperative)).
- **Not linked:** a full PDF headed "Stubborn-attachments-final-with-images" turns up on a university conference server (hume.ufm.edu). I could not confirm that it is authorized, so I did not use it or link it.
**Where to get it.**
- **Publisher:** [Stripe Press](https://press.stripe.com/stubborn-attachments) (links to Bookshop, Barnes & Noble and Amazon; list price $17).
- **Amazon print:** [hardcover, 1732265135](https://www.amazon.com/dp/1732265135).
- **Kindle:** [Kindle edition, B07G9DFC8W](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07G9DFC8W). Available.
- **Audible:** [B07HM6YW71](https://www.audible.com/pd/Stubborn-Attachments-Audiobook/B07HM6YW71), read by Jeremy Arthur, 3 h 32 min, unabridged (UK: [B07HM5V6NF](https://www.audible.co.uk/pd/Stubborn-Attachments-Audiobook/B07HM5V6NF)).
- **Libby/OverDrive:** the ebook is available (OverDrive title 6144780, Stripe Press). On 2026-11-15 the Los Angeles and New York public libraries both had it ([LAPL](https://lapl.overdrive.com/media/6144780); [NYPL](https://nypl.overdrive.com/media/6144780)). San Francisco and Chicago returned nothing. I found no OverDrive audiobook.
- **Hoopla:** not checked reliably, because its search needs JavaScript and returned nothing usable to my box.
- **Internet Archive lending / Open Library borrow:** not available. The Internet Archive has no scan, and Open Library marks the work "no ebook".
- **Project Gutenberg:** not applicable (in copyright). The legal free option is Cowen's own 2016 web edition above.
**Catalog records.** [Google Books](https://books.google.com/books?id=ZxnBEAAAQBAJ) (id ZxnBEAAAQBAJ); [Open Library](https://openlibrary.org/works/OL26422034W); WorldCat [ISBN search](https://search.worldcat.org/search?q=bn:9781732265134) (rate-limited from my box, so not opened).
**Cover:** [Syndetics cover image](https://secure.syndetics.com/index.aspx?isbn=9781732265134/LC.JPG&client=sfpl).
## 3. Author biography
**Tyler Cowen** (born 21 January 1962, Bergen County, New Jersey; raised in Hillsdale, NJ) is an American economist. He is the Holbert L. Harris Professor of Economics at George Mason University and chairs its Mercatus Center ([Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyler_Cowen); [GMU faculty page](https://economics.gmu.edu/people/tcowen)).
- **Education.** BS in economics from George Mason (1983). PhD in economics from Harvard (1987), supervised by Thomas Schelling, with the dissertation *Essays in the Theory of Welfare Economics* (Wikipedia). Welfare economics, the foundations of judging one social state better than another, is exactly the subject of *Stubborn Attachments*. Cowen says he first read Parfit's population ethics in 1984 and has "been thinking about it ever since" (Appendix B).
- **Philosophy connections.** He co-wrote a paper with Derek Parfit, "Against the Social Discount Rate" (1992), which he quotes in Chapter 4. He has published in the philosophy journal *Utilitas*, including "The Epistemic Problem Does Not Refute Consequentialism" (2006), the basis of Chapter 6 ([Crossref](https://doi.org/10.1017/S0953820806002172)).
- **Public writing.** He has co-written the blog *Marginal Revolution* with Alex Tabarrok since August 2003, and has hosted the Mercatus podcast *Conversations with Tyler* since 2015. He was a Bloomberg Opinion columnist for roughly eight years, and since April 2025 has written for The Free Press (Wikipedia). In 2018 he founded Emergent Ventures, a Mercatus grant program launched with a $1 million grant from the Thiel Foundation (Wikipedia).
- **Books.** Among them: *In Praise of Commercial Culture* (1998); *Creative Destruction* (2002); *Discover Your Inner Economist* (2007); *The Great Stagnation* (2011), a *New York Times* bestseller per Stripe Press; *Average Is Over* (2013); *The Complacent Class* (2017); *Stubborn Attachments* (2018); *Big Business* (2019); and *Talent* (2022, with Daniel Gross) (Wikipedia).
- **Recognition.** *Foreign Policy*'s "Top 100 Global Thinkers" (2011); No. 21 on *Prospect*'s "World Thinkers 2015"; and, per Stripe Press, named in an *Economist* poll as one of the most influential economists of the past decade (Wikipedia; [Stripe Press](https://press.stripe.com/stubborn-attachments)).
- **Politics.** He is usually described as a pragmatic libertarian. In 2020 he coined "state capacity libertarianism" (Wikipedia). He is a teetotaler and on the 80,000 Hours podcast urged people to "completely, voluntarily abstain from alcohol" ([80,000 Hours](https://80000hours.org/podcast/episodes/tyler-cowen-stubborn-attachments/)).
He has called this book his "bottom lines": "my account of what I strongly believe you should believe too" ([MR, 13 Aug 2018](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/08/preface-stubborn-attachments-book-especially-important.html)).
## 4. Author interviews and talks
- **FT Alphachat with Cardiff Garcia (April 2017).** On the pre-publication edition. Garcia opens by calling it "maybe the first Foundational Tyler work". It closes with a "Desert Island, This or That" game (Hume over Plato, Shakespeare over everything). [MR post with links](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/04/stubborn-attachments-podcast-ft-alphaville.html); [transcript PDF](https://ftalphaville-cdn.ft.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/02124823/TylerCowenAlphachatTranscript-1.pdf)
- **EconTalk with Russ Roberts (recorded 24 July 2017, posted 7 Aug 2017).** Covers the Crusonia plant, aggregation, Arrow's theorem, inequality, the environment and education. [Link](https://www.econtalk.org/tyler-cowen-on-stubborn-attachments-prosperity-and-the-good-society/)
- **80,000 Hours Podcast #45 / *Conversations with Tyler* bonus, with Rob Wiblin (released 16–17 Oct 2018, publication week).** About three hours on discounting, aggregation, rules, uncertainty, rights, space, alcohol and Parfit. Wiblin pushes back from an effective-altruist, existential-risk angle. [80,000 Hours page with transcript](https://80000hours.org/podcast/episodes/tyler-cowen-stubborn-attachments/); [Conversations with Tyler](https://conversationswithtyler.com/episodes/rob-wiblin-interviews-tyler/)
- **Kenneth Arrow Lecture, Stanford, "Is Economic Growth a Moral Imperative?" (5 Nov 2019).** Cowen spends the talk giving "all of the arguments against my thesis": sustainability vs. growth, total vs. per-capita growth when populations shrink, Solow-model "once-and-for-all" gains, and animals. [Video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EO5jJFpbJvg) (McCoy Family Center for Ethics in Society); [transcript, Discourse](https://www.discoursemagazine.com/p/is-economic-growth-a-moral-imperative); [MR transcript post](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2020/03/transcript-of-my-stanford-talk-on-stubborn-attachments.html)
- **Author's own posts:** "*Stubborn Attachments* is being published by Stripe Press" ([9 Aug 2018](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/08/stubborn-attachments-published-stripe-press.html)); the royalties preface ([13 Aug 2018](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/08/preface-stubborn-attachments-book-especially-important.html)); his reply to a progressive review ([14 Dec 2018](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/12/progressive-review-stubborn-attachments.html)); and "My Stanford talk on all the problems with my arguments in *Stubborn Attachments*" ([Nov 2019](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2019/11/my-stanford-talk-on-all-the-problems-with-my-arguments-in-stubborn-attachments.html)).
## 5. Summary
**Thesis.** "When it comes to the future of our world, we have lost our way in a fundamental manner". We need "a tougher, more dedicated, and indeed a more stubborn attachment to prosperity and freedom" (Ch. 1). The working rule is the **Principle of Growth**: "We should make political choices so as to maximize the rate of sustainable economic growth, as defined by Wealth Plus". Its constrained version is the **Modified Principle of Growth**: "We should push for sustainable economic growth, but not at the expense of inviolable human rights" (Ch. 3). Over a long enough horizon, "the only non-growth-related values that will bind practical decisions are the absolute side constraints, or the inviolable human rights". In other words, a formula of "Growth and Human Rights".
**Three starting points** (Ch. 1): right and wrong are real; we should be skeptical of the individual human mind; and value is plural ("no single value is a 'trump card'"). He calls himself a "two-thirds utilitarian".
**Outline.** The seven chapter titles follow the book's contents as given in a library catalog record and Amazon. Section headings and content come from the 2016 web edition. The book numbers the conclusion as Chapter 7.
- **1. Introduction.** *Three Philosophical Starting Points; Six Critical Issues; Tough Questions and Faith in the Future.* The six issues he says can be solved together: (1) **time**, meaning how to weigh the present against the distant future; (2) **aggregation**, meaning whose preferences win (the Arrow and Sen impossibility results); (3) **rules**, meaning whether rule-consequentialism collapses into act-consequentialism ("I'm going to speak up for rules"); (4) **radical uncertainty** about long-run effects; (5) **rights** ("rights without embarrassment"); and (6) **common-sense morality** vs. utilitarian demandingness (Sidgwick, Parfit, Singer). Two "moves" settle them. First, don't take production for granted; he credits Ayn Rand, "with numerous unfortunate caricatures", for seeing production's moral weight. Second, shrink the "moral distance" to future people, which takes "an attitude very much akin to faith" (he cites Max Weber on religious long-termism).
- **2. Wealth Makes the World Go Round.** *On Value, the Crusonia Plant, and "Wealth Plus"; How Good Is Growth Anyway?; Does Economic Growth Make Us Happier?* Frank Knight's **Crusonia plant**, a self-growing crop, is the model "free lunch". The principle is "when in doubt choose the Crusonia plant". The social Crusonia plant is sustainable growth in **Wealth Plus**: GDP plus leisure, household production and environmental amenities. Breakneck growth isn't the aim; the Shah of Iran is his warning case. Civilizations are fragile, citing Shermer's database of 60 civilizations (see section 6). Three questions should be central for everyone: boosting growth (seen as a right or libertarian concern), stabilizing civilization (conservative), and the environment (left). Growth's record: the US standard of living has risen "by a factor of five to seven" since 1900. He cites 1900 household data, Fogel on European diets and working hours, malaria among US presidents, and migration and remittances. Global inequality has fallen. Sen's capabilities and Kerala are in his view mostly part of Wealth Plus. Small rate differences compound, as in the US–Mexico counterfactual and Lucas's "hard to think about anything else". On happiness, he cites Stevenson–Wolfers and Deaton for the log-linear income–happiness link. He argues that flat survey results reflect shifting language ("Kenya" example), that wealth cushions catastrophe (Greece's crisis), and that the dead don't fill in questionnaires.
- **3. Overcoming Disagreement.** *Modifications for Clashing Preferences; Aren't There Other Exceptions to the Rules?* A 1-percentage-point growth edge yields a 3:1 income ratio in 110.4 years, 2 points in 55.5 years, and 5 points in 22.5 years. After enough time, one option has a "clear and ongoing preponderance" of plural values (South Korea vs. DR Congo). Arrow's theorem fails once cardinal, interpersonal information is allowed. The Principle of Growth "would return economics back to its roots in Adam Smith". The East Asian miracles are "the highest manifestation of the ethical good to date in human history", which is his Hegel-style provocation. Rights must be Nozick-style **side constraints**, and "pretty close to absolute", or compounding growth would eventually override them. Positive rights are already counted in growth; that leaves "barebones" bans on murder, torture and abuse. Rights may yield only to end-of-the-world scenarios. Parfit's **firing squad** (six shooters, zero marginal product each) shows why judging acts as parts of rule-bundles is unavoidable. Most rules are weaker than the growth rule, which has no "embarrassing counterexamples".
- **4. Is Time a Moral Illusion?** *Pain, Gain, and the Distant Future; Risk, Faith, and the Distant Future; Should We Discount the Past?* People are impatient mainly about "now vs. soon". They show near-indifference between 10 and 20 years out, and he calls the bias toward the present an evolved holdover. He quotes Cowen and Parfit's Cleopatra example: a 21-year-old dying of cancer "because one evening Cleopatra wanted an extra helping of dessert". At a 5% discount rate, one death today equals about 39 billion deaths 500 years from now. Future generations can't bid in today's markets. **Relativity:** should we discount astronauts' welfare because they travel fast? Think of time as a block, "as Buddha suggested". Discount for **risk**, not for time. Institutions persist for centuries (Acemoglu–Johnson–Robinson; Comin–Easterly–Gong on 1000 BC). Long horizons call for something like faith, and Cowen rejects "the modern secular tendency to claim that a good politics can or should be devoid of faith". **Restitution:** compounding an 1854 theft gives absurd sums, so we don't discount the past either. The **opportunity-cost** argument for discounting applies to resources, not to well-being. The upshot is a **Deep Concern for the Distant Future**, formalized as the **Overtaking Criterion** (Appendix A).
- **5. What About Redistribution?** *On Moral Obligation and Redistribution; Growth Rates and Long Time Horizons; Who Should Sacrifice? And When?; Should Money Be Redistributed to the Rich?; Our Obligations to the Elderly; One Final Building Block: The Nature of Economic Growth; Growth Begets More Growth.* "We should redistribute only up to the point which maximizes the rate of sustainable economic growth." A growth-friendly welfare state is an investment. Beyond that point it slows growth and crowds out immigration, "by far the most effective anti-poverty program that has been discovered". Radical redistribution is a one-time gain, while growth compounds: "a lasting trickle is better than eating our cake today". This lets utilitarianism converge with common-sense morality, so we need not become "utility slave[s]". The exceptions are a near end of the world, zero returns, and lifeboats, which is why **historical pessimism** is the deepest challenge. **Sacrifice** is a coordination game: someone should, not everyone, and saints are the "least cost supplier". With zero discounting, utilitarianism might even favor transfers *to* the rich, a burden Cowen turns back on the theory. **The elderly:** the replacement-cost puzzle, which an interviewer, the economist Julius Margolis, put to him in 1986. He concludes "we are spending too much on the elderly and not enough on the young". **Growth models:** Solow (catch-up; one-time losses heal, "lobster" claw) vs. Romer increasing returns (losses compound, "fertile rabbits"). In expected-value terms "Crusonia plants are everywhere". Ideas drive both, and he gives a second nod to Rand on reason.
- **6. Must Uncertainty Paralyze Us?** *Science Fiction, Hope and the Epistemic Critique; "About the Dog's Leg I Couldn't Say"; Aesthetics, Goodness, and Moral Reasoning; How to Be Most Likely Correct.* Bradbury's "A Sound of Thunder" and *Sliding Doors*: small acts reshuffle who is born, so long-run consequences are unknowable (the **epistemic critique**). Yet stopping a nuclear bomber in Manhattan is plainly right. James Lenman's **D-Day beach** case leads to Cowen's reply: "Stop the nuclear bomber in Manhattan, about the dog's leg I couldn't say." The **Principle of Roughness**, as in Beethoven vs. Mozart plus one bagatelle, explains why small benefits get lost in the "froth" of uncertainty and why only big goals rise above it. Practical upshots: be "a good agnostic" about means. Your best policy view may be right only with low probability (a "slightly crooked roulette wheel" in the draft; the World Series in the book), so political posturing is "disreputable". **Rights:** the real comparison is not "baby's life vs. $5 billion" but "baby's life vs. a froth of massive uncertainty". Only world-ending stakes, such as aliens from Alpha Centauri, could override rights. Lifeboat ethics strengthens rights. Uncertainty becomes a kind of "enchantment".
- **7. Where Have We Landed?** *Sustainable Growth, Fragility, and Our Future; Where Have We Landed?* In three points: growth is "philosophically imperative" (think big, have deep concern for the future); morality can be strict and rights-based, nesting the growth rules inside rights; and be very modest about specific policies. Recommendations (a–i): be more forward-looking; invest more ("an investment drought"); give growth priority ("your favorite value gets downgraded too"); attend to civilizational fragility; treat historical pessimism as the main challenge; be more charitable at the margin but work, save and invest; reconcile common-sense morality with consequences; and be agnostic on "small" policies. His "utopian political vision" is a society that "lets individuality, happiness, and autonomy flower to their maximum extent". Distrust the "little voice" of short-run pragmatism, "the thinking man's equivalent of the savage's short-run gratification".
- **Appendix A: Some Optional Mathematics and Remarks on a Few Metrics.** Zero discounting, the Golden Rule, and the **Overtaking Criterion**: sequence (a) 3,3,4,4,5,6,6… beats (b) 4,4,5,5,5… It also covers gamma discounting (Posner's 1%/5% example; Weitzman 2001) and cyclic theories (Vico, Montesquieu). *(2016 web edition. I could not confirm the appendix's form in the printed book.)*
- **Appendix B: Animal Welfare and Derek Parfit's Repugnant Conclusion.** Muzak-and-potatoes lives may resemble animal lives. There are "multiple competing Crusonia plants" once animals count, and his framework cannot choose between them. He praises Matthew Scully's *Dominion* and calls the conundrum likely "insoluble". (Sivers's book notes include this material, so it survives in print.)
**Key ideas.**
- **Crusonia plant / Wealth Plus:** look for self-sustaining sources of rising value. Broadly measured sustainable growth is the main one.
- **Growth plus rights:** maximize sustainable growth subject to near-absolute negative rights. Everything else is downgraded.
- **Deep concern for the distant future:** no pure time discounting of well-being. Discount for risk only. The Overtaking Criterion is the formal version.
- **Redistribution limited by growth:** help the poor mainly through growth and immigration. The demandingness of utilitarianism shrinks.
- **Epistemic humility as a liberator:** uncertainty undercuts small calculations, not big goals or rights. Be tolerant and agnostic about policy means.
- **Faith and reason:** sustaining long horizons takes something "much closer to a kind of faith".
**Critiques worth knowing.** Noah Smith said it lacks actionable policy. Tax cuts raise levels, not long-run growth, unless Romer-style models hold, so he reads it as "a manifesto for basic research and green technology" ([Noahpinion](https://noahpinionblog.blogspot.com/2019/01/book-review-stubborn-attachments-by.html)). Will Compernolle found its treatment of well-being, relative deprivation and the content of rights underdeveloped ([LARB](https://lareviewofbooks.org/blog/reviews/human-rights-case-economic-growth-tyler-cowens-stubborn-attachments/)). F. E. Guerra-Pujol argued that "sustainable" is a caveat that could swallow the rule ([prior probability](https://priorprobability.com/2018/12/04/our-critique-of-stubborn-attachments/)). Joshua Kim, writing as a progressive, found it "too abstract"; Cowen said the abstraction was deliberate ([MR](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/12/progressive-review-stubborn-attachments.html)). Art Carden called it "a brief but tight argument" ([The Daily Economy](https://thedailyeconomy.org/article/growth-is-good/)). Cowen's own list of weak points, in the Arrow Lecture, includes total vs. per-capita growth, the sustainability/growth tension, and animals.
## 6. Fact-check
Overall verdict: **mostly supported**. The compounding arithmetic is right. The 2016 draft's restitution sum was wrong, and the book fixed it. Shermer's civilization figure is mis-copied as 402.6 instead of 420.6 in both versions. A few historical asides are loose.
| Claim | Verdict | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Published by Stripe Press 16 Oct 2018; hc ISBN 9781732265134; audiobook read by Jeremy Arthur, 3 h 32 min | Supported | [Amazon](https://www.amazon.com/dp/1732265135); [Kindle](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07G9DFC8W); [Audible](https://www.audible.com/pd/Stubborn-Attachments-Audiobook/B07HM6YW71); [MR, 9 Aug 2018](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/08/stubborn-attachments-published-stripe-press.html) |
| An earlier full text was free online from Cowen (Medium) | Supported | Post dated 25 Jul 2016 ([Wayback](https://web.archive.org/web/20170530204015/https://medium.com/stubborn-attachments/stubborn-attachments-full-text-8fc946b694d)); EconTalk July 2017 refers to it as online at Medium ([EconTalk](https://www.econtalk.org/tyler-cowen-on-stubborn-attachments-prosperity-and-the-good-society/)) |
| US living standards up "by a factor of five to seven" since 1900 | Supported | Maddison Project: US GDP per head about $8,038 (1900) vs. $53,301 (2016), roughly 6.6× ([OWID/Maddison](https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/gdp-per-capita-maddison-project-database)) |
| Had the US grown 1 point slower 1870–1990, 1990 America "would be no richer than the Mexico of 1990" | Supported (roughly) | The standard Barro & Sala-i-Martin textbook calculation (0.75% instead of 1.75% gives about $5,519, near Mexico and Hungary) ([IMF eLibrary summary](https://www.elibrary.imf.org/display/book/9781589060944/ch04.xml)). On today's Maddison numbers the counterfactual (~$11k) is still close to Mexico's $9,699 |
| 5% growth takes $500→$25,000 in "just over eighty years", 1% takes 393 years; 3:1 ratios at 110.4 / 55.5 / 22.5 years; quintupling at 161 / 81 / 33 years | Supported | Arithmetic checked: ln 50/ln 1.05 = 80.2; ln 50/ln 1.01 = 393.2; ln 3/ln 1.01 = 110.4, /ln 1.02 = 55.5, /ln 1.05 = 22.5; ln 5/ln 1.01 = 161.7, etc. |
| At 5% discounting, one death today ≈ 39 billion deaths in 500 years; a death in 200 years = 131.5 deaths in 300 years | Supported | 1.05^500 ≈ 3.93×10^10; 1.05^100 ≈ 131.5 (computed). Cowen repeats the 39 billion figure in the Arrow Lecture ([Discourse](https://www.discoursemagazine.com/p/is-economic-growth-a-moral-imperative)) |
| Restitution: $1,000 stolen in 1854, compounded, "more than $50 billion" (2016 draft) | **Disputed (draft) / corrected in book** | The draft mixes 7% and 5% and runs to 2015. That gives about $54 million at 7% or about $2.6 million at 5%, not $50 billion. The book's version (7%, 1854–2018, "more than $65 million") is right: 1.07^164 × $1,000 ≈ $65.9 million ([Sivers's book notes](https://sive.rs/book/StubbornAttachments)) |
| Shermer's database: 60 civilizations averaging 402.6 years; 304.5 years since Rome | **Partly disputed (transposed digits)** | Shermer: 60 civilizations, 25,234 years, "L = 420.6 years"; 28 post-Rome civilizations "averaging only 304.5 years" ([Shermer, *Scientific American* 2002](https://michaelshermer.com/sciam-columns/why-et-hasnt-called/); [SciAm](https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-et-hasnt-called/)). The book keeps 402.6 (Sivers) |
| "Crusonia was the name of Robinson Crusoe's island" | **Disputed** | The name is Frank Knight's ([Knight 1944, JPE](https://doi.org/10.1086/256134)). In Defoe, Crusoe calls the island "The Island of Despair" and the word "Crusonia" never appears ([Gutenberg #521](https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/521)) |
| Washington, Monroe, Jackson, Lincoln, Grant and Garfield all had malaria | Supported | [Entomology Today, "At Least Eight U.S. Presidents had Malaria"](https://entomologytoday.org/2014/02/17/at-least-eight-u-s-presidents-had-malaria/) |
| 1900 US households: 24% running water, 18% refrigerators, 12% gas or electric light | Unverified / doubtful wording | Cowen sources it to an unpublished DeLong lecture using Census data. Electric household refrigerators did not exist yet in 1900 ([Wikipedia: Refrigerator](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refrigerator)), so "refrigerators" must mean iceboxes or ice refrigeration. Not checked against the primary table |
| Life expectancy in Western Europe "about forty" at the end of the 19th century | Partly supported | Around 1900: UK 45.6, France 45.1, Netherlands 48.5, Sweden 52.2; Europe as a whole 42.7 ([OWID life expectancy](https://ourworldindata.org/life-expectancy)). "About forty" fits earlier decades or Europe-wide figures better than Western Europe in 1900 |
| Mid-19th-century workers worked 2,800–3,300 hours a year vs. 1,400–2,000 now | Supported | Cited to Huberman & Minns 2007 ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eeh.2007.03.002)). Their estimates for the 1870s are near 3,000 hours. I checked the paper's existence and scope, not each figure |
| Income and happiness are roughly linear-log, even in rich countries | Supported (contested literature) | Stevenson & Wolfers 2008 ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1353/eca.0.0001)); Deaton 2008 ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1257/jep.22.2.53)). The Easterlin-paradox side remains in dispute |
| Global inequality declined in recent decades | Supported | Lakner & Milanovic ([World Bank WP 6719](https://doi.org/10.1596/1813-9450-6719)) |
| Regional wealth around 1000 BC predicts wealth today; colonial institutions persist | Supported (as research findings) | Comin, Easterly & Gong 2010 ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1257/mac.2.3.65)); Acemoglu, Johnson & Robinson 2001 ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.91.5.1369)); Spolaore & Wacziarg 2013 ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1257/jel.51.2.325)). Causal readings are debated |
| Arrow's theorem disappears once interpersonal cardinal utility information is allowed | Supported | The standard social-choice result (Sen). Cowen cites Sen 1984 |
| Greece lost almost a quarter of output, unemployment over 20%, neo-Nazi party elected | Supported | [Wikipedia: Greek government-debt crisis](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_government-debt_crisis) (Golden Dawn entered parliament in 2012) |
| About 40,000 US road deaths a year | Supported (approximately) | NHTSA counted roughly 37–38k in 2016–17 and the NSC estimated about 40k ([Wikipedia: US motor vehicle fatalities by year](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in_U.S._by_year)) |
| US government investment about 3.6% of GDP vs. a postwar average of about 5% | Unverified | Cited to Harding, McGregor & Muller (2013). I did not check it against BEA series |
| Bradbury's "A Sound of Thunder" was published in 1952 | Supported | [Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Sound_of_Thunder) (*Collier's*, 1952) |
| Lucas (1988): "once one starts to think about [exponential growth], it is hard to think about anything else" | Supported (minor wording) | Lucas 1988 ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1016/0304-3932%2888%2990168-7)). The original reads "simply staggering: Once one starts to think about them…". Cowen's bracket stands in for Lucas's "them", i.e. questions about growth rates |
| Parfit's Repugnant Conclusion wording | Supported | Parfit, *Reasons and Persons* (1984). Cowen cites p. 387; the page is unverified by me ([Wikipedia: Mere addition paradox](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere_addition_paradox)) |
| East Asian miracles are the only clear application of the Principle of Growth, "the highest manifestation of the ethical good to date" | Opinion | Normative claim. Smith and Carden accept the growth emphasis; Kim and Compernolle question what it implies for policy and rights |
## 7. Citations and references
**Notable sources in the book** (from the 2016 edition's notes and reference list; linked where I found them)
- Frank H. Knight, "Diminishing Returns from Investment," *JPE* 52 (1944): the Crusonia plant ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1086/256134))
- Derek Parfit, *Reasons and Persons* (1984): the Repugnant Conclusion and "Mistakes in Moral Mathematics" (not linked)
- Tyler Cowen & Derek Parfit, "Against the Social Discount Rate," in Laslett & Fishkin (eds.), *Justice Between Age Groups and Generations* (Yale, 1992) (not linked)
- Robert Nozick, *Anarchy, State, and Utopia* (1974): rights as side constraints (not linked)
- Tyler Cowen, "The Epistemic Problem Does Not Refute Consequentialism," *Utilitas* (2006) ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1017/S0953820806002172))
- James Lenman, "Consequentialism and Cluelessness," *Philosophy & Public Affairs* (2000) ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1088-4963.2000.00342.x))
- Martin Weitzman, "Gamma Discounting," *AER* (2001) ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.91.1.260)); Richard Posner, *Catastrophe: Risk and Response* (2004) (not linked)
- Robert E. Lucas, "On the Mechanics of Economic Development," *JME* (1988) ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1016/0304-3932%2888%2990168-7))
- Robert Solow (1956) ([doi](https://doi.org/10.2307/1884513)); Paul Romer, "Endogenous Technological Change" (1990) ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1086/261725))
- Robert Fogel, *The Escape from Hunger and Premature Death, 1700–2100* (2004); Benjamin M. Friedman, *The Moral Consequences of Economic Growth* (2005); Elhanan Helpman, *The Mystery of Economic Growth* (2004) (not linked)
- Stevenson & Wolfers (2008) ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1353/eca.0.0001)); Deaton (2008) ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1257/jep.22.2.53)); Huberman & Minns (2007) ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eeh.2007.03.002))
- Acemoglu, Johnson & Robinson (2001) ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1257/aer.91.5.1369)); Comin, Easterly & Gong (2010) ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1257/mac.2.3.65)); Spolaore & Wacziarg (2013) ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1257/jel.51.2.325)); Lakner & Milanovic ([doi](https://doi.org/10.1596/1813-9450-6719))
- Michael Shermer, "Why ET Hasn't Called," *Scientific American* (2002) ([link](https://michaelshermer.com/sciam-columns/why-et-hasnt-called/))
- Ray Bradbury, "A Sound of Thunder" (1952); Matthew Scully, *Dominion* (2002); Ayn Rand; Amartya Sen on capabilities; Ruth Chang on incommensurability (not linked)
**Every link used**
- Text read: [Cowen, "'Stubborn Attachments': Full Text", Medium, 25 Jul 2016, Wayback capture 30 May 2017](https://web.archive.org/web/20170530204015/https://medium.com/stubborn-attachments/stubborn-attachments-full-text-8fc946b694d) (original [Medium URL](https://medium.com/stubborn-attachments/stubborn-attachments-full-text-8fc946b694d), now offline); book-wording comparisons: [Derek Sivers notes](https://sive.rs/book/StubbornAttachments), [Fluidself notes](https://fluidself.org/books/business/stubborn-attachments), [Kamdar notes](https://mbkamdar.github.io/book-notes/cowen-stubborn-attachments/)
- Publisher and author posts: [Stripe Press catalog](https://press.stripe.com/); [book page](https://press.stripe.com/stubborn-attachments); [MR, published by Stripe Press](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/08/stubborn-attachments-published-stripe-press.html); [MR, preface/royalties](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/08/preface-stubborn-attachments-book-especially-important.html); [MR, Alphachat](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2017/04/stubborn-attachments-podcast-ft-alphaville.html); [MR, progressive review](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2018/12/progressive-review-stubborn-attachments.html); [MR, Stanford talk](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2019/11/my-stanford-talk-on-all-the-problems-with-my-arguments-in-stubborn-attachments.html); [MR, Stanford transcript](https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2020/03/transcript-of-my-stanford-talk-on-stubborn-attachments.html)
- Catalog and retail: [Open Library work](https://openlibrary.org/works/OL26422034W); [OL hardcover](https://openlibrary.org/books/OL35682676M); [Google Books](https://books.google.com/books?id=ZxnBEAAAQBAJ); [WorldCat ISBN search](https://search.worldcat.org/search?q=bn:9781732265134); [Smart Library Search record](https://www.smartlibrarysearch.com/book/stubborn-attachments-cowen-tyler-S152C1190336); [Syndetics cover](https://secure.syndetics.com/index.aspx?isbn=9781732265134/LC.JPG&client=sfpl); [Amazon hardcover](https://www.amazon.com/dp/1732265135); [Amazon Kindle](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B07G9DFC8W); [Audible US](https://www.audible.com/pd/Stubborn-Attachments-Audiobook/B07HM6YW71); [Audible UK](https://www.audible.co.uk/pd/Stubborn-Attachments-Audiobook/B07HM5V6NF); [OverDrive LAPL](https://lapl.overdrive.com/media/6144780); [OverDrive NYPL](https://nypl.overdrive.com/media/6144780)
- Author: [Wikipedia: Tyler Cowen](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tyler_Cowen); [GMU faculty page](https://economics.gmu.edu/people/tcowen)
- Interviews and talks: [Alphachat transcript PDF](https://ftalphaville-cdn.ft.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/02124823/TylerCowenAlphachatTranscript-1.pdf); [EconTalk](https://www.econtalk.org/tyler-cowen-on-stubborn-attachments-prosperity-and-the-good-society/); [80,000 Hours #45](https://80000hours.org/podcast/episodes/tyler-cowen-stubborn-attachments/); [Conversations with Tyler](https://conversationswithtyler.com/episodes/rob-wiblin-interviews-tyler/); [Arrow Lecture video](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EO5jJFpbJvg); [Discourse transcript](https://www.discoursemagazine.com/p/is-economic-growth-a-moral-imperative)
- Reviews: [Noahpinion](https://noahpinionblog.blogspot.com/2019/01/book-review-stubborn-attachments-by.html); [LARB, Compernolle](https://lareviewofbooks.org/blog/reviews/human-rights-case-economic-growth-tyler-cowens-stubborn-attachments/); [prior probability](https://priorprobability.com/2018/12/04/our-critique-of-stubborn-attachments/); [The Daily Economy, Carden](https://thedailyeconomy.org/article/growth-is-good/)
- Fact-check: [OWID/Maddison GDP per capita](https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/gdp-per-capita-maddison-project-database); [OWID life expectancy](https://ourworldindata.org/life-expectancy); [IMF eLibrary, sources of growth](https://www.elibrary.imf.org/display/book/9781589060944/ch04.xml); [Shermer column](https://michaelshermer.com/sciam-columns/why-et-hasnt-called/); [SciAm](https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-et-hasnt-called/); [Gutenberg, Robinson Crusoe](https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/521); [Entomology Today, presidents and malaria](https://entomologytoday.org/2014/02/17/at-least-eight-u-s-presidents-had-malaria/); [Wikipedia: Refrigerator](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Refrigerator); [Wikipedia: Greek government-debt crisis](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greek_government-debt_crisis); [Wikipedia: US motor vehicle fatalities](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in_U.S._by_year); [Wikipedia: A Sound of Thunder](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Sound_of_Thunder); [Wikipedia: Mere addition paradox](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mere_addition_paradox); DOIs as listed above (checked against Crossref)