# Scientific Freedom *Donald Braben's case that the way science has been funded since about 1970, through peer review of proposals, priorities, milestones and demands for efficiency, has choked off the kind of unpredictable, field-changing discovery that made the twentieth century. He calls the scientists who made those discoveries (Planck, Einstein, McClintock, Townes and a few hundred more) the "Planck Club". His remedy is to find a few people with radical ideas, give them money and total freedom, and trust them. He argues from his own experiment: from 1980 to 1990 he ran BP's Venture Research Unit, which funded a few dozen researchers, most of them already turned down by national agencies, with no peer review, milestones or set objectives. Wiley first published the book in 2008. Stripe Press reissued it on 20 October 2020 with a new introduction and redesigned figures. Braben died in 2025.* > **What I read.** I did **not** read the printed book, the ebook or the audiobook. There is no legal free full text (see section 2). The Internet Archive has a scan of the 2008 Wiley paperback, but only for controlled lending, and I did not borrow it. Here is what I did read. **(1)** The **contents list** of the Stripe Press edition, as given in retailer listings (List of Posters; Introduction to New Edition; Preface; Introduction; chapters 1–7; Bibliography; Index). The 2008 edition has the same chapters, and the Ingram contents record gives its page numbers. **(2)** Short **search-inside snippets** from the Internet Archive scan of the 2008 edition, through Open Library's public full-text search. These confirmed several phrases, names and a few page headers. **(3)** The publisher's description, the **"Introduction to the New Edition"** excerpt and the blurbs printed on Amazon. **(4)** Readers' notes and reviews: Tom Girón-Littler's Kindle highlights (with Kindle locations), José Luis Ricón's review on Nintil, and Steven Lee's review (with page numbers). **(5)** Braben's own free talks, slides, articles and interviews, which repeat the book's arguments and numbers. Quotations from the book appear only where a named source prints them, and are marked with that source, for example "(loc. 1210, via Girón-Littler)" or "(p. 55, via Lee)". Kindle locations are the note-taker's, not page numbers. Lee's page numbers are presumably from the Stripe edition. I could not check either against a copy. Related in this vault: - Publisher folder: [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/Stripe Press|Stripe Press]]. This is the tenth Stripe Press book by release date, after [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/High Growth Handbook - Elad Gil|High Growth Handbook]], [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/The Dream Machine - M. Mitchell Waldrop|The Dream Machine]], [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/Stubborn Attachments - Tyler Cowen|Stubborn Attachments]], [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/The Revolt of the Public and the Crisis of Authority in the New Millennium - Martin Gurri|The Revolt of the Public]], [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/An Elegant Puzzle - Will Larson|An Elegant Puzzle]], [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/Get Together - Bailey Richardson, Kevin Huynh, and Kai Elmer Sotto|Get Together]], [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/The Making of Prince of Persia - Jordan Mechner|The Making of Prince of Persia]], [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/The Art of Doing Science and Engineering - Richard W. Hamming|The Art of Doing Science and Engineering]] and [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/Working in Public - Nadia Eghbal|Working in Public]]. - Closest companions in the vault: [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/The Art of Doing Science and Engineering - Richard W. Hamming|The Art of Doing Science and Engineering]], Hamming's view from Bell Labs of how great research gets done, which shares Braben's faith in long, self-directed work on important problems. [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/The Dream Machine - M. Mitchell Waldrop|The Dream Machine]] tells the story of a funder (J. C. R. Licklider at ARPA) who also backed people rather than projects. [[Book Summaries/Stripe Press/Stubborn Attachments - Tyler Cowen|Stubborn Attachments]] makes the moral case for sustained economic growth that Braben thinks only new science can supply. - Next in the Stripe Press queue: Michael S. Malone's *The Big Score* (#367). J. Storrs Hall's *Where Is My Flying Car?* (#368) and Vannevar Bush's *Pieces of the Action* (#369) come back to the themes of stagnation and how to fund science. ## 1. Book facts | | | |---|---| | Title | *Scientific Freedom: The Elixir of Civilization* | | Author | Donald W. Braben (1935–2025), British physicist and science-policy writer. He led BP's Venture Research Unit from 1980 to 1990 | | Publisher | Stripe Press (2020 reissue). Retail records list the publisher as Stripe Matter, Inc. First published by Wiley-Interscience (John Wiley & Sons), Hoboken, NJ ([Stripe Press](https://press.stripe.com/scientific-freedom); [Open Library work](https://openlibrary.org/works/OL8230545W)) | | Stripe Press hardcover | Publication date **20 October 2020**, 256 pages, ISBN 978-0578675916 / 0578675919. List price $23 ([Stripe Press catalog data](https://stripe.press/catalog.json); [Amazon](https://www.amazon.com/dp/0578675919); [Open Library OL31444096M](https://openlibrary.org/books/OL31444096M)). Amazon showed $21.44 on 2026-11-20. The Stripe Press page gives no exact date; the date is from retailers and Open Library | | What is new in 2020 | An "Introduction to New Edition" and, per the publisher's description, "over 30 redesigned charts and figures and a new foreword by Donald Braben" ([Amazon](https://www.amazon.com/dp/0578675919)). The "foreword" and the "Introduction to New Edition" appear to be the same piece: the retailer contents list shows only the introduction | | 2008 first edition | Wiley-Interscience paperback, ISBN 978-0470226544, xii + 184 pp., "Includes bibliographical references (p. 173-177) and index"; LCCN 2007030912; OCLC 162126870; LC class Q180.A1 B645 2008 ([Internet Archive record](https://archive.org/details/scientificfreedo0000brab); [Open Library OL10295135M](https://openlibrary.org/books/OL10295135M)). Open Library dates the paperback 15 February 2008; Wiley lists it as February 2008, 220 pages, ebook ISBN 978-0-470-24571-2 ([Wiley](https://www.wiley.com/en-hk/scientific-freedom-the-elixir-of-civilization-p-9780470245712)). Wiley Online Library dates the chapters "First published: 09 August 2007" (online) ([Wiley Online Library, ch. 1](https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/9780470245743.ch1)). *Times Higher Education* reported on 17 April 2008 that it had been "published in the UK last week" ([THE, 2008](https://www.timeshighereducation.com/news/kill-peer-review-save-civilisation/401457.article)) | | Ebook | Kindle ASIN B08HTWQC66, 20 October 2020, 257 pages print length, $12.99 on 2026-11-20 ([Amazon Kindle](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08HTWQC66)). Stripe ebook ISBN 9781953953292 per Open Library ([OL48530247M](https://openlibrary.org/books/OL48530247M)) | | Audiobook | Unabridged, read by **Simon Bowie**, 10 h 9 min, published by Stripe Press **11 January 2021** (Amazon audiobook ASIN B08SM48QSQ) ([Amazon audiobook](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08SM48QSQ)) | | Ratings | Amazon showed 4.6/5 from 44 ratings (formats combined) on 2026-11-20 | | Library data | Open Library work [OL8230545W](https://openlibrary.org/works/OL8230545W) (Stripe hardcover [OL31444096M](https://openlibrary.org/books/OL31444096M); Wiley paperback [OL10295135M](https://openlibrary.org/books/OL10295135M)); OverDrive titles 6144734 (Stripe) and 166665 (Wiley). I found no OCLC number for the Stripe edition: WorldCat gives nothing usable to my box, and the Google Books API was over quota (429) again | | Where it came up | Stripe Press catalog, added at Marshall's request on 2026-11-13 (relayed by Obsidian Author). Queue #366 | ## 2. Book resources **Free (legal).** - **No legal free full text of the book.** Neither Stripe Press nor Wiley has posted it. The Internet Archive scan of the 2008 Wiley paperback is lending-only (see below). Sites offering a "PDF free download" of *Scientific Freedom* are unauthorized copies. They are not linked here. - **Braben's slide talk "How to identify people who might radically change the way we think about an important subject"** (Copenhagen, 28 October 2011, Danish Society of Engineers' jubilee) is free. In about 30 slides it gives the Planck Club list, the "Planck Test", the case against "peer preview" of proposals, the Venture Research selection procedure and a list of Venture Research discoveries ([PDF](https://dg.dk/filer/20_aars_jubilaeum/Donald_Braben.pdf)). José Luis Ricón recommends it, with a RAND report, as a short substitute for the book ([Nintil](https://nintil.com/review-scientific-freedom/)). - **Written evidence to the House of Commons Science and Technology Committee** inquiry on peer review (2 March 2011). A free, compact version of the book's argument and its Venture Research numbers ([UK Parliament](https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201012/cmselect/cmsctech/856/856vw22.htm)). - **"Peer review is not the best way to promote major breakthroughs,"** Braben's opinion piece in *Times Higher Education*, 19 August 2021 ([THE](https://www.timeshighereducation.com/opinion/peer-review-not-best-way-promote-major-breakthroughs); free registration may be needed). - **"We need more scientific mavericks,"** an open letter in *The Guardian*, 18 March 2014, from Braben and about 30 co-signers, several of them former Venture Researchers ([Guardian](https://www.theguardian.com/science/2014/mar/18/we-need-more-scientific-mavericks)). - **Interviews and podcasts** (section 4) are free. James Kaufman's write-up of his 2020 conversation with Braben is a long, readable text interview ([jameshk.com](https://jameshk.com/don-braben-scientific-freedom)). **Where to get it.** - **Publisher:** [Stripe Press](https://press.stripe.com/scientific-freedom) ($23 hardcover; the catalog links to Amazon, Bookshop and Barnes & Noble). - **Amazon print:** [hardcover, 0578675919](https://www.amazon.com/dp/0578675919), Stripe Press, 20 October 2020, 256 pp., $21.44 on 2026-11-20. The 2008 Wiley paperback (0470226544) is sold used. - **Kindle:** [B08HTWQC66](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08HTWQC66), $12.99 on 2026-11-20. - **Audible:** available, read by Simon Bowie, 10 h 9 min, unabridged, 11 January 2021 ([Amazon audiobook B08SM48QSQ](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08SM48QSQ)). Audible.com returned an error page to my box, so I could not confirm the Audible-store ASIN. The Amazon audiobook page is the Audible edition. - **Other retailers:** [Bookshop.org](https://bookshop.org/books/scientific-freedom-the-elixir-of-civilization/9780578675916); [Barnes & Noble](https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/scientific-freedom-donald-w-braben/1116658063?ean=9780578675916) (both links from the Stripe Press catalog; not opened from my box). - **Libby/OverDrive:** **ebooks available at NYPL**. On 2026-11-20 New York Public Library had the Stripe Press ebook (OverDrive 6144734, 1 copy, 1 available) and the 2008 Wiley ebook (OverDrive 166665, 1 copy, 1 available) ([NYPL search](https://nypl.overdrive.com/search?query=scientific+freedom+braben)). Los Angeles, San Francisco and Chicago public libraries returned no copy. I found no OverDrive audiobook. - **Hoopla:** not checked reliably. Its search needs JavaScript and returned nothing usable to my box. - **Internet Archive lending / Open Library borrow:** **yes, the 2008 Wiley edition.** The scan `scientificfreedo0000brab` is in the controlled-lending (print-disabled and borrowable) collection. Open Library marks the work "borrowable" ([Internet Archive](https://archive.org/details/scientificfreedo0000brab); [Open Library](https://openlibrary.org/works/OL8230545W)). It lacks the 2020 introduction and redesigned figures. - **Project Gutenberg:** not applicable (in copyright). **Catalog records.** [Open Library](https://openlibrary.org/works/OL8230545W); [Google Books by ISBN](https://books.google.com/books?vid=ISBN9780578675916) (no volume ID confirmed: the API was over quota); [WorldCat search](https://search.worldcat.org/search?q=bn:9780578675916) (no OCLC number confirmed for the Stripe edition; the Wiley paperback is [OCLC 162126870](https://search.worldcat.org/title/162126870)); [Goodreads search](https://www.goodreads.com/search?q=9780578675916). **Cover:** [Open Library cover image (Stripe Press edition)](https://covers.openlibrary.org/b/id/10520599-L.jpg). ## 3. Author biography **Early life and physics.** Donald W. Braben was born in Liverpool on 29 May 1935 (Wikipedia, citing a UCL page) ([Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Braben)). He described a "very working-class background in Liverpool" and a boyhood love of astronomy, which school steered into physics and mathematics ([Kaufman interview](https://jameshk.com/don-braben-scientific-freedom)). He took a PhD at the University of Liverpool in 1962 with a thesis on energy levels of sodium-23 ([Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Braben)). He then worked in Alberta, came back to the Daresbury Nuclear Physics Laboratory, designed the magnet system for its accelerator, and moved into particle physics. His main experimental work was on pion electroproduction at threshold, with Italian collaborators (his own account, [Kaufman interview](https://jameshk.com/don-braben-scientific-freedom)). He described this as "16 years as an experimental physicist in nuclear structure and high-energy physics" ([UK Parliament evidence, 2011](https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201012/cmselect/cmsctech/856/856vw22.htm)). **Whitehall, the research council and the Bank.** Around 1973, rather than move to CERN as part of a large collaboration, he went on promotion to the scientific secretariat of the Cabinet Office. He then held posts at the Science Research Council and the Bank of England. He called the Bank job "a big mistake" because it turned out to be "a sinecure" ([Kaufman interview](https://jameshk.com/don-braben-scientific-freedom); [UK Parliament evidence](https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201012/cmselect/cmsctech/856/856vw22.htm)). **BP Venture Research (1980–1990).** In 1980 Dr Jack Birks, a BP managing director he knew from marine-technology work at the Science Research Council, invited him to set up BP's Venture Research Unit. The book itself names Birks and says Robert Malpas succeeded him as the Unit's contact managing director in 1982 (Open Library search-inside snippets of the 2008 edition). The book also says "British Petroleum set up the Venture Research Unit in 1980 and closed it down in 1990" (same source). He called it his "life's work" ([Kaufman interview](https://jameshk.com/don-braben-scientific-freedom); the interview transcript spells Birks "Burkes"). Its results are the subject of chapter 7 (see section 5). **UCL and later work.** He joined University College London in 1993 ([UK Parliament evidence](https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201012/cmselect/cmsctech/856/856vw22.htm)). In 2011 he signed himself as of the Department of Earth Sciences. Later he was an Honorary Professor in the office of the Vice-Provost (Research) ([UCL profile](https://profiles.ucl.ac.uk/2732-donald-w-braben)). In 2008–2009 UCL launched a staff-wide Venture Research scheme on his model. Its first fellow was the biochemist Nick Lane (2009–2012, about £150,000 over three years) ([Braben, THE 2021](https://www.timeshighereducation.com/opinion/peer-review-not-best-way-promote-major-breakthroughs); [Science, 2009](https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/prize-winning-researcher-ventures-unknown-origin-eukaryotes)). The Stripe Press and Amazon author notes add an Honorary Fellowship from UMIST and the First Trust Bank Chair of Innovation at Queen's University Belfast ([Amazon](https://www.amazon.com/dp/0578675919)). I did not find independent confirmation of either. **Books.** *To Be a Scientist: The Spirit of Adventure in Science and Technology* (Oxford University Press, 1994); *Pioneering Research: A Risk Worth Taking* (Wiley, 2004); *Scientific Freedom: The Elixir of Civilization* (Wiley, 2008; Stripe Press, 2020); *Promoting the Planck Club: How Defiant Youth, Irreverent Researchers and Liberated Universities Can Foster Prosperity Indefinitely* (Wiley, 2014) ([Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Braben)). Earlier papers include "Innovation and academic research," *Nature* 316 (1985) ([DOI](https://doi.org/10.1038/316401a0)) and "Blue Skies Research and the global economy," *Physica A* 314 (2002) ([DOI](https://doi.org/10.1016/S0378-4371(02)01065-8)). **Death.** He died in 2025, aged 89. *The Times* ran an obituary headed "Professor Don Braben, 89: Champion of scientific inquiry who promoted 'blue-skies research'" ([The Times](https://www.thetimes.com/comment/register/article/professor-don-braben-89-champion-of-scientific-inquiry-who-promoted-blue-skies-research-8cj8tpm8v); paywalled). Wikipedia gives the date as 23 February 2025 but marks it "citation needed". I could not confirm the exact day. Wikipedia, citing the *Times* obituary, says he kept a pilot's licence from the University Air Squadron throughout his life, and married Shirley, a fellow PhD, with whom he had three children. ## 4. Author interviews and talks **About the book (2020–2021 reissue)** - **Idea Machines #34, "Venture Research with Donald Braben" (9 November 2020).** Ben Reinhardt on the Planck Club, peer review, how Venture Research picked people, and why DARPA is a different thing. Transcript online ([Idea Machines](https://ideamachinespodcast.com/donald-braben)). - **James Kaufman, "Donald Braben on Venture Research and Scientific Freedom" (conversation October 2020, written up 2024).** Career story, funding success rates, disciplines and peer review ([jameshk.com](https://jameshk.com/don-braben-scientific-freedom)). - **Narratives #24, "Venture Research with Donald Braben" (11 January 2021).** Will Jarvis's podcast; the conversation starts about 21 minutes in ([Substack](https://willjarvis.substack.com/p/24-venture-research-with-donald-braben-871)). - **AEI Political Economy podcast, "Don Braben: The Importance of Scientific Freedom" (17 February 2021).** With James Pethokoukis ([AEI](https://www.aei.org/podcast/don-braben-the-importance-of-scientific-freedom/)), followed by a written "5 Questions for Don Braben" (1 March 2021) ([AEI](https://www.aei.org/economics/5-questions-for-don-braben-on-the-benefits-of-venture-research-and-scientific-freedom/)). **Talks and press on the first edition and after** - ***Times Higher Education*, "Kill peer review, save civilisation" (Zoe Corbyn, 17 April 2008).** News story on the first edition, with direct quotes from Braben about peer review being "disastrous" at the margins of science ([THE](https://www.timeshighereducation.com/news/kill-peer-review-save-civilisation/401457.article)). - **"How to identify people who might radically change the way we think about an important subject" (Copenhagen, 28 October 2011).** Slides ([PDF](https://dg.dk/filer/20_aars_jubilaeum/Donald_Braben.pdf)). - **Written evidence to the House of Commons Science and Technology Committee (2 March 2011)** ([UK Parliament](https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201012/cmselect/cmsctech/856/856vw22.htm)). ## 5. Summary **Thesis.** Most of the discoveries that made the twentieth century, from quantum theory to the laser, the double helix and molecular biology, came from a few hundred people Braben calls the **Planck Club**. Almost none of them had to compete for their first funding. Before about 1970 an appointed academic could follow a hunch for years without asking anyone. Since then, research money has gone through competitive peer review of proposals, with priorities, objectives and milestones. That works for incremental research but fails what Braben calls the **Planck Test**: it would not have funded Planck. The result, he argues, is a slowdown in transformative discovery and therefore in long-run economic growth, which pushes civilization toward a **"Damocles Zone"** of fragility. The fix is cheap. Set aside a small fund, pick people rather than projects through face-to-face discussion instead of peer review, give them total freedom and stay out of the way. The 2020 introduction puts it this way: "Nowadays, the funding of academic research is controlled by the consensus of experts, and peer review is by far the most common process for reaching consensus. The progress of science, therefore, depends on the support that researchers can find" (Introduction to the New Edition, via [Amazon](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08HTWQC66)). BP's Venture Research Unit, which he ran in the 1980s, is his evidence that this "low-risk, high-reward" approach works. **Outline.** Chapter titles are from the retailer contents list of the Stripe edition; the 2008 page numbers are from the Ingram contents record ([eCampus/Ingram](https://www.ecampus.com/scientific-freedom-elixir-civilization/bk/9780470226544)). What each chapter covers is drawn from reader notes and reviews (Girón-Littler, Lee, Ricón), Open Library search-inside snippets of the 2008 edition, and Braben's own talks. I could not check every detail against a copy, and where I cannot place something in a chapter I say so. **Front matter.** - **List of Posters.** The book sets off about twenty boxed "Posters" from the main text. Search-inside snippets name the first ones as "Charles Townes and the Laser", "The Twentieth-Century Planck Club", "The Wizard's Warning", "Global ...", "The Sword of Damocles and the Damocles Zone", "Economic Growth" and "R&D Investments" (Open Library search-inside, 2008 edition). - **Introduction to New Edition (2020).** Scientific progress used to seem inevitable. "Scientists could be relied upon to provide a steady trickle of unexpected major discoveries that would transform lives for the better. However, the past few decades have seen a major change" (via [Amazon](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08HTWQC66)). Reader highlights from the opening locations come from this part of the book. They include Planck's remark that science advances as its opponents die out, used to explain "the folly of using peer review to assess virtually all proposals" (loc. 91, via Girón-Littler); the claim that "we did not need special arrangements for finding the Einsteins in the past" (loc. 142); and the Venture Research story of Steve Davies at Oxford, whose 1985–91 project led to Oxford Asymmetry, sold in 2000 for £316 million to Evotec (loc. 158). - **Preface** (2008 p. xi) **and Introduction** (p. 1). The Introduction defines the Planck Club and the Planck Test and previews the chapters. Search-inside snippets confirm phrases such as "Chapter 1 introduces the formidable Damocles Zone" and the aim "to stimulate the creation of a twenty-first century Planck Club". They also include the note that sponsors "must recognize that major breakthroughs in scientific understanding are impossible to commission". **Chapters.** 1. **The Damocles Zone** (2008 p. 17). Starts from Cicero's tale of the sword over Damocles: "Does not Dionysius, then, seem to have declared there can be no happiness for one who is under constant apprehensions?" (loc. 762, via Girón-Littler). A society that loses its capacity for renewal can drift into a state where small shocks cause collapse and no rescue comes. The book's example is a society that cleared its tree cover and so "pushed it into what we might call the Damocles Zone" (search-inside snippet). New science is what lets a civilization "dull Swords of Damocles before they run us through", in Lee's paraphrase ([Lee](https://stevenlee.substack.com/p/review-of-scientific-freedom-the)). Braben ties the risk to slowing growth. Calling himself "a follower of Solow", he holds as a working hypothesis "that unconstrained creativity eventually leads to new opportunities and new growth", while directed creativity "eventually leads to diminishing returns" (loc. 972, via Girón-Littler; I could not confirm which chapter this passage is in). 2. **Scientific Freedom and Transformative Research** (p. 32). "Transformative research", the term then current in US science-policy circles, means research likely to change thinking radically or found a new field. Braben prefers the older "Venture Research". He argues that such work cannot be commissioned. Planck would not have spent "20 years" on thermodynamics if someone had assigned him the topic (loc. 1210). He asks whether Penzias and Wilson's work (which found the cosmic microwave background) would count as "transformative" and answers "I do not think it would". They had set out to study radio emission from the Milky Way, so today's labels do not fit how discoveries actually happen (loc. 1130). He quotes Einstein on Planck: the driving force "resembles that of the devotee or the lover … Its inspiration arises from a hunger of the soul" (loc. 1233). Braben used "hunger of the soul" in his 2008 press interview too ([THE](https://www.timeshighereducation.com/news/kill-peer-review-save-civilisation/401457.article)). 3. **Mismanagement by Objectives: The Need for Fresh Approaches** (p. 39). The longest argument against efficiency-driven management of research. "We now live in an age in which efficiency—that is, perceptions of efficiency—is paramount, particularly in resource allocation and use. But the relationship between efficiency and creativity is not understood" (p. 55, via Lee). Consensus dominates fields: the Big Bang is treated as "a tablet of stone" (p. 68, via Lee), and Lee Smolin is cited on string theory's grip (loc. 1631). Discovery has become "a faceless industry", credited to anonymous "researchers" (loc. 1506). Posters chart economic growth and R&D investment. In Lee's reading, rising R&D spending alongside fewer breakthroughs means declining returns, and agencies respond by tightening selection further ([Lee](https://stevenlee.substack.com/p/review-of-scientific-freedom-the)). I place these passages in this chapter by their location numbers; I did not confirm the chapter boundaries. 4. **Searching for Planck's Successors** (p. 67). How to find would-be Planck Club members, and why peer review of proposals fails the Planck Test. Search-inside snippets: initiatives "must pass the 'Planck test'", and "if it cannot pass the Planck test, peer review is fundamentally flawed". A reader-noted line, "Responsibility shared is responsibility declined" (loc. 1928; Lee gives p. 109), belongs to the argument that committees choose safety. Lee reads this part as a warning that "high-risk" schemes run by risk-averse bodies set their researchers up to fail. Braben's counter-claim is that properly chosen Venture Research is low-risk ([Lee](https://stevenlee.substack.com/p/review-of-scientific-freedom-the)). Lee's p. 109 may put this passage in a later chapter; I could not check. 5. **Universities for the Twenty-First Century: The Case for a Fifth Revolution** (p. 81). The university's freedom is under threat from mass expansion, managerial governance and accountability rules. Academics now face "taskmasters", and "'First glance' is, of course, the bureaucrat's weapon of choice" (loc. 2281). He quotes Waugh (2003) on executives recruited from business, and Morison on why teaching needs research (loc. 2523, 2372). He asks how universities can keep their "automatic association with excellence" "when 50% is the proportion usually associated with average" (loc. 2367; Lee p. 132). Britain's abolition of the University Grants Committee was, he says, done "solely on misplaced ideological grounds" (loc. 2484). He counts UK university Nobel prizes in science: about 41 for 1945–1979 against 10 for 1980–2006, most of the latter from protected institutes such as the MRC Laboratory of Molecular Biology (loc. 2476). He quotes the 1988 Bologna *Magna Charta Universitatum* on independence and the unity of teaching and research (loc. 2403–2405). His **"Fifth Revolution"** would treat the first three or four years of mass higher education as an extended secondary phase, with true universities after that (loc. 2493). Its seeds would be the recognition, about 2007, that growth is declining, that today's technology comes from old discoveries, and that "Managed creativity can at best produce only what its managers specify" (loc. 2334). 6. **Venture (or Transformative) Research: How It Works in Practice** (p. 101). A working design for a new scheme. Staff must be "Nature's ambassadors" and act "as Nature herself might if she had to make the selections" (search-inside snippet). His 2011 slides spell out the procedure. Invitations go out as widely as possible. Short proposals focus on concepts. The same two or three staff assess every field. No one is ever simply rejected: the "ball" is always returned. Then come open-ended discussions that build mutual trust, with questions such as "If you had infinite resources and freedom what would you do that you are not doing now?" The staff commit to the applicant's success, and a panel of senior scientists makes the final decision ([2011 slides](https://dg.dk/filer/20_aars_jubilaeum/Donald_Braben.pdf)). Even BP's board insisted on a "farcical, vestigial form of peer review": one peer chosen by the researcher, briefed and asked to endorse. It often declined, and "In every case, we were able to persuade the board to go ahead anyway" (quoted from the book by [Ricón](https://nintil.com/review-scientific-freedom/)). The money is "free": no milestones, deadlines, priorities or boundaries ([2011 slides](https://dg.dk/filer/20_aars_jubilaeum/Donald_Braben.pdf)). 7. **The Venture Research Harvest** (pp. 114–172, the longest chapter). The record of BP's Unit (1980–1990), with an "Old Recipe" for Venture Research and "Table 13. Some Transformative Discoveries". It goes through the funded groups one by one as numbered entries (for example "VR 6. Adam Curtis and Chris Wilkinson", "VR 10. Nigel Franks, Bristol; and Jean Louis Deneubourg and Simon Goss", "VR 22. Ken Seddon, The Queen's University of Belfast" at p. 159) (search-inside snippets). The book speaks of an "international community of 25-30 groups of Venture Researchers comprising about 100 scientists" and says they were "phenomenally successful. At least 14 ..." (search-inside snippets). Highlights in Braben's 2011 list: green chemistry with ionic liquids and supercritical fluids (Seddon, Martyn Poliakoff); small artificial enzymes for chiral selection (Steve Davies); rules of distributed intelligence in social insects (Franks and colleagues); geological fluid mechanics (Herbert Huppert, Steve Sparks); squeezed light (Jeff Kimble); a liquid–liquid phase transition in water (Gene Stanley, José Teixeira); sustained chemical patterns (Harry Swinney and colleagues) ([2011 slides](https://dg.dk/filer/20_aars_jubilaeum/Donald_Braben.pdf)). Ricón notes that the chapter includes established figures such as Edsger Dijkstra and the Nobel chemist Dudley Herschbach. It also includes a 1989–1992 physics project by Stan Clough and Tony Horsewill that Braben rates as a possible "significant milestone" but that remains little known (p. 171, via [Ricón](https://nintil.com/review-scientific-freedom/)). The Unit was moved into BP's research organization and then closed (search-inside snippet: "transfer of the Venture Research Unit into the protective custody of the research ..."). Lee gives Braben's explanation that BP wanted to show shareholders it was concentrating on core business (paraphrase, [Lee](https://stevenlee.substack.com/p/review-of-scientific-freedom-the)). **Back matter.** Bibliography (2008 pp. 173–177) and Index (p. 178). **Key ideas.** - **The Planck Club.** A few hundred twentieth-century scientists made the discoveries that transformed life. Braben's number varies: "about 300-500" (2011 evidence), "about five hundred others" (2011 slides), "500 or so" (2020 interview). - **The Planck Test.** Would a funding procedure have backed Planck, Einstein or McClintock when they started? Peer review of proposals would not, so it is the wrong tool at the frontier, though fine for mainstream work. - **Peer review versus "peer preview."** Refereeing finished work is acceptable. Using competitors' consensus to judge future potential has "little or no evidence of effectiveness" ([2011 slides](https://dg.dk/filer/20_aars_jubilaeum/Donald_Braben.pdf)). - **Low risk, high reward.** Done properly, radical research is not risky: it is cheap, and a few successes repay the whole program. - **Fund people, not projects.** Choose through dialogue, commit to the person's success, then grant total freedom, including freedom to change direction. - **The 1970 turning point.** Mass expansion of universities and the arrival of competitive, objective-driven funding marked the end of the freedom that produced the Planck Club. - **The Damocles Zone.** Slower discovery means slower growth, which leaves civilization exposed to shocks it cannot survive. - **A Fifth Revolution for universities.** Protect a small number of truly free research universities from mass higher education and managerialism. **Reception.** *ChemBioChem* (Peter Augsdorfer, 2008), *The Quarterly Review of Biology* and *Choice* reviewed the first edition ([ChemBioChem](https://doi.org/10.1002/cbic.200800670); [QRB](https://doi.org/10.1086/592853); [Choice](https://doi.org/10.5860/choice.46-0242); I did not read these paywalled reviews). Nobel laureates Dudley Herschbach and Richard J. Roberts and the volcanologist Steve Sparks endorsed the reissue ([Amazon](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08HTWQC66)); Herschbach and Sparks were connected to Venture Research. Among progress-studies readers, José Luis Ricón found the case for "at least a second trial" of Venture Research persuasive. He also judged that "most books should be blogposts" applied here, apart from the strong final chapter, and that the book is "scant in quantitative evidence and rich in anecdote" about the decline of science ([Nintil](https://nintil.com/review-scientific-freedom/)). Steven Lee was sold on funding transformative research but called the book's pessimism overdone, pointing to 2020's mRNA vaccines, reusable rockets and protein folding. He also wondered whether Venture Researchers would have succeeded anyway ([Lee](https://stevenlee.substack.com/p/review-of-scientific-freedom-the)). ## 6. Fact-check These checks rely on the publisher, catalog records, search-inside snippets, readers' notes and Braben's own other statements. I did not read the book through. Where a claim comes only from Braben, I say so. | Claim | Verdict | Evidence | |---|---|---| | Stripe Press edition 20 October 2020; ISBN 9780578675916; 256 pp.; first published 2008 by Wiley | Supported | [Amazon](https://www.amazon.com/dp/0578675919); [Open Library OL31444096M](https://openlibrary.org/books/OL31444096M); [Stripe Press catalog data](https://stripe.press/catalog.json); 2008 Wiley-Interscience paperback, LCCN 2007030912 ([Internet Archive record](https://archive.org/details/scientificfreedo0000brab)). Wiley Online Library dates the chapters 9 August 2007 (online), so "first published 2008" means the print edition | | BP ran the Venture Research Unit from 1980 to 1990, with Braben in charge | Supported | The book (search-inside: "British Petroleum set up the Venture Research Unit in 1980 and closed it down in 1990"); [UK Parliament evidence](https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201012/cmselect/cmsctech/856/856vw22.htm); [Stripe Press](https://press.stripe.com/scientific-freedom). Every source traces back to Braben; I found no independent BP history online | | Size and cost of Venture Research: 26 programmes for about £15 million | Disputed (Braben's own figures vary) | 2011 slides: "~£15 million", "Final number of research programmes: 26" ([PDF](https://dg.dk/filer/20_aars_jubilaeum/Donald_Braben.pdf)); 2011 evidence: "26 individuals or small groups" ([Parliament](https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201012/cmselect/cmsctech/856/856vw22.htm)); book: "25-30 groups ... about 100 scientists" (search-inside); 2020–2021: "some 40" programmes and "£20 million" ([Kaufman](https://jameshk.com/don-braben-scientific-freedom); [THE 2021](https://www.timeshighereducation.com/opinion/peer-review-not-best-way-promote-major-breakthroughs)); Idea Machines host: "about 2 million pounds per year" ([Idea Machines](https://ideamachinespodcast.com/donald-braben)). The differences may reflect counting groups versus projects and nominal versus later money, but the book should be read as the 26–30-group version | | About 10,000 proposals received over the decade | Unverified | Braben's later statements only ([Kaufman](https://jameshk.com/don-braben-scientific-freedom); [THE 2021](https://www.timeshighereducation.com/opinion/peer-review-not-best-way-promote-major-breakthroughs)). I did not find the figure in the book snippets | | "At least 14" Venture Research groups made scientific breakthroughs; estimated value ~£1 billion | Unverified (self-assessed) | Braben's own count ([2011 slides](https://dg.dk/filer/20_aars_jubilaeum/Donald_Braben.pdf); book search-inside "At least 14"). There is no independent evaluation. Ricón: "one'd need an impartial careful assessment to truly believe that" ([Nintil](https://nintil.com/review-scientific-freedom/)). Several of the named researchers became leaders in their fields, but whether Venture Research caused that is not shown | | Almost all funded proposals had already been rejected by national agencies ("every proposal except one") | Unverified | Braben only ([Parliament](https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201012/cmselect/cmsctech/856/856vw22.htm)) | | Steve Davies's Oxford Asymmetry was sold to Evotec in 2000 for £316 million | Supported (sale); disputed (founding year) | Sale: [Oxford Mail](https://www.oxfordmail.co.uk/news/6629941.drugs-groups-316m-merger/); [Nature Biotechnology, 2000](https://www.nature.com/articles/nbt0900_912c). Founding year: the book says 1992 (loc. 158, via Girón-Littler), Braben's 2021 article says 1990, and Oxford's chemistry department says 1991 ([Oxford Chemistry](https://www.chem.ox.ac.uk/people/stephen-davies)) | | Ken Seddon's proposal was rated "gamma" (lowest) by the research council before Venture Research funded it; he became the UK's top-cited chemist in a 2011 *THE* list | Unverified | Braben's account ([Parliament](https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201012/cmselect/cmsctech/856/856vw22.htm)). Seddon was VR 22 in the book (search-inside, p. 159). I did not check the 2011 *THE* list | | Peer review of research proposals became the dominant funding gatekeeper only around 1970 | Partly supported / oversimplified | Expert review of grant proposals is older: NIH study sections from the late 1940s, NSF outside reviewers "from the outset" (1950s). But Melinda Baldwin shows that "peer review" became the term and the test of legitimacy in the US in the 1970s, after congressional scrutiny of the NSF in 1974–1975 ([Baldwin, *Isis* 2018](https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/700070); [PDF](https://melinda-baldwin.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/baldwin-isis-article.pdf)). | | Global per-capita economic growth has fallen since about 1970 | Supported in broad terms | The 1950–1973 "Golden Age" of growth is standard economic history. World per-capita growth was lower in later decades, though it recovered in the 2000s ([World Bank data](https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.KD.ZG?locations=1W)). Braben's causal link to research policy is his hypothesis; the book says "There may be other reasons" (loc. 972) | | UK university researchers won about 41 science Nobel Prizes in 1945–1979, versus 10 in 1980–2006 | Unverified | Braben's count (loc. 2476, via Girón-Littler). Counts depend on how laureates are assigned to institutions; I did not recount | | The UK's University Grants Committee was abolished | Supported | The UGC ran from 1919 to 1989, when the Universities Funding Council (Education Reform Act 1988) replaced it ([Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/University_Grants_Committee_(United_Kingdom))). Braben's view that this was "solely on misplaced ideological grounds" is opinion | | Sydney Brenner, Nobel lecture: "Such longterm research could not be done today, when everybody is intent only on assured short term results and nobody is willing to gamble" | Supported | Brenner's 2002 Nobel lecture ([nobelprize.org PDF](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/brenner-lecture.pdf)). Ricón says the book quotes it | | Planck took about 20 years to reach energy quantization | Supported, roughly | Planck's doctoral thesis on the second law of thermodynamics was 1879, and the quantum hypothesis came in December 1900 ([Wikipedia: Max Planck](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Planck)) | | UCL's Venture Research scheme (2009) funded Nick Lane, about £150,000 over three years | Supported | [Science, 2009](https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/prize-winning-researcher-ventures-unknown-origin-eukaryotes); [Braben, THE 2021](https://www.timeshighereducation.com/opinion/peer-review-not-best-way-promote-major-breakthroughs) | | The Big Bang model is treated as "established fact" when it is still a hypothesis (p. 68, via Lee) | Disputed | The hot Big Bang model is supported by several independent lines of evidence (cosmic microwave background, light-element abundances, expansion) and is a well-tested theory, not a mere hypothesis ([NASA WMAP, tests of the Big Bang](https://map.gsfc.nasa.gov/universe/bb_tests.html)). Braben's real point is that funding by consensus leaves little room for challengers, and that is a fair point about incentives | ## 7. Citations and references **Notable sources the book draws on or points to** - Max Planck's remark that new truths win because opponents die out (*Scientific Autobiography*), used in the 2020 introduction (loc. 91, via Girón-Littler) - Albert Einstein, "Principles of Research" (1918 address for Planck's 60th birthday), the "hunger of the soul" passage (loc. 1233, via Girón-Littler) - Cicero, *Tusculan Disputations* V, the Sword of Damocles (loc. 762, via Girón-Littler) - Robert Solow's growth theory, as the working hypothesis linking creativity to growth (loc. 972) - Lee Smolin, *The Trouble with Physics* (2006/2007), on string theory (loc. 1631) - Sydney Brenner, Nobel lecture, 2002 ([PDF](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/brenner-lecture.pdf)) - Samuel Eliot Morison (cited as Morison 1969, pp. 335–336), quoted on why university teachers must also do research (loc. 2372). I did not identify which Morison book - Waugh (2003), on universities recruiting executives from business (loc. 2523). I did not check the full reference - *Magna Charta Universitatum* (Bologna, 1988) ([text](https://www.magna-charta.org/magna-charta-universitatum)) - Braben's earlier books, *To Be a Scientist* (1994) and *Pioneering Research* (2004) - The book's own bibliography is at pp. 173–177 of the 2008 edition; I could not see it **Every link used** - Publisher and catalog: [Stripe Press book page](https://press.stripe.com/scientific-freedom); [Stripe Press catalog data](https://stripe.press/catalog.json); [Wiley product page](https://www.wiley.com/en-hk/scientific-freedom-the-elixir-of-civilization-p-9780470245712); [Wiley Online Library ch. 1](https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/9780470245743.ch1); [eCampus/Ingram contents](https://www.ecampus.com/scientific-freedom-elixir-civilization/bk/9780470226544) - Retail: [Amazon hardcover](https://www.amazon.com/dp/0578675919); [Amazon Kindle](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08HTWQC66); [Amazon audiobook](https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08SM48QSQ); [Bookshop.org](https://bookshop.org/books/scientific-freedom-the-elixir-of-civilization/9780578675916); [Barnes & Noble](https://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/scientific-freedom-donald-w-braben/1116658063?ean=9780578675916) - Libraries: [NYPL OverDrive](https://nypl.overdrive.com/search?query=scientific+freedom+braben); [Internet Archive (lending)](https://archive.org/details/scientificfreedo0000brab) - Catalog records: [Open Library work](https://openlibrary.org/works/OL8230545W); [OL31444096M](https://openlibrary.org/books/OL31444096M); [OL48530247M](https://openlibrary.org/books/OL48530247M); [OL10295135M](https://openlibrary.org/books/OL10295135M); [WorldCat search](https://search.worldcat.org/search?q=bn:9780578675916); [OCLC 162126870](https://search.worldcat.org/title/162126870); [Google Books by ISBN](https://books.google.com/books?vid=ISBN9780578675916); [Goodreads search](https://www.goodreads.com/search?q=9780578675916); [cover](https://covers.openlibrary.org/b/id/10520599-L.jpg) - Author: [Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Braben); [UCL profile](https://profiles.ucl.ac.uk/2732-donald-w-braben); [The Times obituary](https://www.thetimes.com/comment/register/article/professor-don-braben-89-champion-of-scientific-inquiry-who-promoted-blue-skies-research-8cj8tpm8v); [UK Parliament written evidence, 2011](https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201012/cmselect/cmsctech/856/856vw22.htm); [Nature 1985](https://doi.org/10.1038/316401a0); [Physica A 2002](https://doi.org/10.1016/S0378-4371(02)01065-8) - Braben's free material: [Copenhagen slides, 2011](https://dg.dk/filer/20_aars_jubilaeum/Donald_Braben.pdf); [THE opinion, 2021](https://www.timeshighereducation.com/opinion/peer-review-not-best-way-promote-major-breakthroughs); [Guardian letter, 2014](https://www.theguardian.com/science/2014/mar/18/we-need-more-scientific-mavericks) - Interviews and press: [Idea Machines #34](https://ideamachinespodcast.com/donald-braben); [James Kaufman interview](https://jameshk.com/don-braben-scientific-freedom); [Narratives #24](https://willjarvis.substack.com/p/24-venture-research-with-donald-braben-871); [AEI podcast](https://www.aei.org/podcast/don-braben-the-importance-of-scientific-freedom/); [AEI 5 Questions](https://www.aei.org/economics/5-questions-for-don-braben-on-the-benefits-of-venture-research-and-scientific-freedom/); [THE 2008 news story](https://www.timeshighereducation.com/news/kill-peer-review-save-civilisation/401457.article) - Reader notes and reviews: [Tom Girón-Littler's notes](https://tomgiron.com/book-notes/scientific-freedom); [José Luis Ricón, Nintil](https://nintil.com/review-scientific-freedom/); [Steven Lee](https://stevenlee.substack.com/p/review-of-scientific-freedom-the); [ChemBioChem review](https://doi.org/10.1002/cbic.200800670); [QRB review](https://doi.org/10.1086/592853); [Choice review](https://doi.org/10.5860/choice.46-0242) - Fact-check: [NASA WMAP, tests of the Big Bang](https://map.gsfc.nasa.gov/universe/bb_tests.html); [Oxford Mail on the Evotec deal](https://www.oxfordmail.co.uk/news/6629941.drugs-groups-316m-merger/); [Nature Biotechnology 2000](https://www.nature.com/articles/nbt0900_912c); [Oxford Chemistry, Steve Davies](https://www.chem.ox.ac.uk/people/stephen-davies); [Baldwin, Isis 2018](https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/700070); [Baldwin PDF](https://melinda-baldwin.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/baldwin-isis-article.pdf); [World Bank GDP per capita growth](https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.KD.ZG?locations=1W); [Wikipedia: University Grants Committee](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/University_Grants_Committee_(United_Kingdom)); [Wikipedia: Max Planck](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Planck); [Science 2009 on Nick Lane](https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/prize-winning-researcher-ventures-unknown-origin-eukaryotes); [Brenner Nobel lecture](https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/brenner-lecture.pdf)